Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'South Africa's second XV beat New Zealand's first XV': 101-cap veteran

Beauden Barrett of New Zealand looks on during The Rugby Championship & Bledisloe Cup match between New Zealand All Blacks and Australia Wallabies at Sky Stadium on September 28, 2024 in Wellington, New Zealand. (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

World champions South Africa have three teams that could possibly beat any other team in the world currently, former England scrum-half Danny Care has claimed.

ADVERTISEMENT

The 101-cap veteran, who retired from international rugby earlier this year, made this assertion on his podcast Hits Different alongside fellow host Mark Atkinson and current Harlequins coach, former All Black Nick Evans.

In the section of the show labelled โ€˜Debatableโ€™, Care and Evans discussed whether South Africa now produce better rugby players than New Zealand. However, the conversation descended into whether the Springboksโ€™ second XV could beat the All Blacksโ€˜ first XV.

Video Spacer

Louis Rees-Zammit โ€“ Walk the Talk trailer | RPTV

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:58
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:58
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
    • en (Main), selected
    Video Spacer

    Louis Rees-Zammit โ€“ Walk the Talk trailer | RPTV

    Wales try-scoring wizard Louis Rees-Zammit joins Jim Hamilton for an exclusive chat about life in the NFL. Watch the full show on RugbyPass TV

    Watch now

    While both Care and Atkinson believe a second-string South Africa side would come out on top, Evans vehemently disagreed, saying they had โ€œno chanceโ€.

    Of course, the sides have already met this year, with South Africa coming out on top in back-to-back Tests on their way to winning The Rugby Championship. Scorelines of 31-27 and 18-12 show how close both encounters were, but the Englishman believes the Springboksโ€™ bench, plus seven more players could achieve the same feat.

    Fixture
    Internationals
    Japan
    19 - 64
    Full-time
    New Zealand
    All Stats and Data

    โ€œYou look at the strength in depth in South Africa right now and think they could put three different XVs against any other team in the world and I think they might win or be very, very close,โ€ Care said.

    โ€œI think currently South Africaโ€™s second XV would beat the current New Zealand first XV.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Atkinson added: โ€œI think they beat them. If youโ€™re signing individuals, then Kiwis still seem like better rugby players as individuals, but at the moment itโ€™s hard to argue that South Africa arenโ€™t producing better teams.

    The Quins legend cited former team-mate Andre Esterhuizen, who left the Stoop this summer, as an example of the depth that the Springboks currently have following a Rugby Championship where the centre did not see a minute of action.

    โ€œLook at the players that canโ€™t even get in the South Africa team,โ€ the scrum-half added. โ€œAndre Esterhuizen, one of the best players thatโ€™s ever worn a Harlequins shirt, currently canโ€™t get a game for South Africa. He would be in the second team. I think they beat New Zealandโ€™s first team.

    Related

    Louis Rees-Zammit joins Jim Hamilton for the latest episode of Walk the Talk to discuss his move to the NFL. Watch now on RugbyPass TV

    ADVERTISEMENT

    LIVE

    Vancouver SVNS | Day 3

    Boks Office | Episode 35 | Six Nations Round 2 Review

    O2 Inside Line: This Rose | Episode 3 | France Week

    Second round of the Men's Six Nations | Whistle Watch

    Harlequins vs Bristol Bears | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

    Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Saitama Wildknights | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

    Watch now: Lomu - The Lost Tapes

    The Dupont Ploy: How France went from underdogs to Olympic gods | The Report

    Former rugby player is truly an NFL superstar | Walk the Talk | Jordan Mailata

    Trending on RugbyPass

    Comments

    26 Comments
    B
    BP 121 days ago

    Even as big Bok Supporter, I think that's a stupid statement.

    L
    LB 121 days ago

    The Springboks did play a B team against the pumas and lost.


    When the springboks started a B team against the No 10 ranked wallabies, they only led 11-9 until the bomb squad came on.

    J
    JH 121 days ago

    If NZ selected their overseas players, and could have kept the ones that have now been lost to other nations as a result of their outdated policy, they'd have more than enough depth and firepower to match the Boks. The playing field isn't exactly even in this regard.

    H
    HA 122 days ago

    Having read Wayne Smith's observations after recently being with the All Blacks for a week or so, I think there are far more interesting debates to be had about that team's place in world rugby going forward, than hypothetical first and second teams beating other hypothetical first and second teams.

    So, having said that, I shall go and look for them.

    B
    BA 122 days ago

    I would not bet money on that

    G
    GM 123 days ago

    Silly, circuitous debate, highlighted by the fact that the All Blacks could also pick a 'Second XV' which on its day could beat the AB 'First XV' - particularly if the same Saffer eligibility rules applied re overseas players (maybe even an AB Third XV could do the job!) SA getting a lot of kudos re depth but ABs are rapidly building depth too.

    I
    Icefarrow 123 days ago

    Define a second XV, because there are multiple definitions. Is it a mixture of experienced and inexperienced players? A team solely comprised of inexperienced players? A development team like your As and XVs? Pretty broad and pointless claim if you leave it ambiguous.

    H
    HW 123 days ago

    The All Blacks are picked from in country. We don't select from overseas players. If all countries picked from in Country playing group how would everyone stack up. Anyway The Sprinboks are playing awesome rugby and have an amazing Coaching group with team strategies that everyone is chasing, good luck to them for many years to come. Die hard All Black Fanatic.

    G
    GG 123 days ago

    HE, would be interesting? Might also be interesting for each country to only pick guys born in their country? Argies will be good.

    J
    JK 123 days ago

    ABs would be better but still behind RSA IRL and possibly FRA

    L
    Lulu 123 days ago

    Picking only local players for SA does not work. Allister Coetsee results show 57-0.

    No ways a bok 2nd team can beat AB. With a so called average team they pushed the Boks in both away games.

    AB will always remain a dominant team. Simply to much talent at their disposal.

    J
    JW 123 days ago

    Depends how many cards they're asking to be given.


    Also sounds like they're suggesting the Springboksโ€™ second XV would beat the Springboksโ€™ first XV.


    Fair.

    R
    RedWarrior 124 days ago

    South Africa's A team couldn't beat Ireland's B Team.


    Discuss.... (hides under table)

    B
    BP 121 days ago

    Stop taking drugs - you just embracing yourself.

    M
    MakeOllieMathisAnAB 124 days ago

    Yeah nah stick to doing drugs mate.

    F
    Forward pass 124 days ago

    And an NZXV would beat SAs top side. Providing they got a neutral ref and TMO. Perhaps wait until SA is actually the world no 1 before starting this stuff.

    J
    JD 124 days ago

    Care might be right, but as a South African I don't like any form of triumphalism. Success is fleeting and never lasts forever. I prefer to be humble.

    G
    GG 123 days ago

    JD, agree 100 %. For me the benchmark always is the ABs. Beating them for us Saffas is the ultimate as we know how good they are. Trying to compare sides from NH and SH difficult between WC cycles as sides are either ending or starting seasons, and often donโ€™t have all players available due to injury or rest. The best point to measure sides is at WC as then all sides have similar preparation and all available

    N
    Ninjin 125 days ago

    The Springboks are in a good place atm regarding player depht. Just waiting for all the new systems to click and then Care might just be right.

    J
    Jmann 125 days ago

    whatevs...

    G
    GrahamVF 124 days ago

    Be scared - be very scared ๐Ÿ‘ป

    U
    Utiku Old Boy 125 days ago

    Danny Care?! LOL

    T
    Tom 125 days ago

    It'd certainly be a close match. SA strength in depth is ridiculous.

    H
    Head high tackle 123 days ago

    Is that why Arg beat them in the first test? Their depth?

    F
    Forward pass 124 days ago

    As proven v Arg... But the Top side couldnt beat Ireland and needed TMO help to beat NZ.

    Load More Comments

    Join free and tell us what you really think!

    Sign up for free
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Latest Features

    Comments on RugbyPass

    R
    RegineIsaksen 1 hour ago
    Reds name 10 Wallabies in starting side for teamโ€™s season-opener

    Sometimes life gives you signs-you just got to be paying attention. One night, deep in an Uber ride, I struck up a conversation with the driver. The topic of Bitcoin came up, and he mentioned that he once lost his wallet containing $50,000.

    I thought this would be the end of the story-something like regret, lessons learned, and moving on. But then he said something that stuck with me: "Thankfully, I found Lee Ultimate Hacker. They got everything back." I nodded, really interested but unconcerned. After all, I was so very careful with my wallet security. I thought, That's rough, but it could never happen to me. A week later, it happened to me. I lost the wallet holding $300,000 while overhauling my crypto storage system. In one wrong move, my funds became completely unreachable. I retraced passwords, checked backups, tried everything that normally works, but nothing worked. Panic kicked in. My mind was racing, trying to figure out my next move. And then, I remembered the Uber driver's story.

    I didn't waste a moment and contacted Lee Ultimate Hacker. Right upon connecting to their team, I could feel my nerves calm down. They did not right away get to work but also asked questions, analyzed my situation, and explained how the recovery would go. It was next-level professionalism; they didn't just work on how to return my money but also how to make me understand what happened and how I could avoid it in the future. Finally, after what felt like the longest wait of my life, came the message that I had been waiting for: My wallet was recovered successfully.

    Relief doesn't even begin to describe my feeling at that moment. That $300,000 wasn't just money; it was years of careful investments and strategic planning. And in an instant, it was all back where it belonged. In retrospect, I owe more than a five-star rating to that Uber driver. His story gave me a lifeline which I didn't know I needed. Lesson learned: Pay attention to those random conversations-you never know when they might save you a fortune.

    LEEULTIMATEHACKER @ AOL . COM

    telegram: LEEULTIMATE

    wh@tsapp +1 (715) 314 - 9248

    1 Go to comments
    S
    SusanLiebman 1 hour ago
    England explain their backing for Marcus Smith to stay on the kicks

    Iโ€™ve always been careful with my cryptocurrency, but even the most cautious investors can fall victim to cyber threats. My nightmare began when a ransomware attack locked me out of my $500,000 Bitcoin wallet. The hackers demanded payment in exchange for access, but I refused to negotiate with criminals. Desperate and running out of options, I started researching legitimate crypto recovery services, something I never thought Iโ€™d need.During my search, I came across an article about crypto recovery services that highlighted Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery as an industry leader. While I was skeptical at first, I was also desperate. Every hour that passed felt like my funds were slipping further away. Finally, I decided to take a chance and reached out to their team.From the very first call, I knew I was dealing with professionals. The team at Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery listened patiently to my situation and reassured me that I wasnโ€™t alone,ransomware attacks were becoming increasingly common, and they had successfully helped many people recover their stolen crypto. Their confidence gave me hope.Once I provided the necessary details about my wallet and the attack, their forensic specialists got to work. Unlike the hackers, who demanded money without guarantees, Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery provided clear expectations, a transparent process, and constant updates. Their team used advanced blockchain analysis tools to trace the compromised transactions and locate vulnerabilities that could be exploited to regain access.The waiting period was nerve-wracking, but they delivered on every promise. Within a matter of days, I received the news I had been praying forโ€”my $500,000 had been fully restored. I could barely believe it. My funds were back, and the hackers had failed.Beyond the recovery itself, Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery also educated me on preventing future attacks. They advised me on strengthening my wallet security, using cold storage, and recognizing suspicious links or downloads that could contain malware. Their insight and expertise ensured that I wouldnโ€™t be caught off guard again.What started as a moment of complete despair ended with an incredible victoryโ€”all thanks to Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery. If you ever find yourself in a situation where you think your crypto is gone for good, donโ€™t lose hope. They are the real deal, and they proved that even after a ransomware attack, your assets can still be saved.

    Email: prowizardgilbertrecovery(@)engineer.com

    Telegram: https://t.me/Pro_Wizard_Gilbert_Recovery

    WhatsApp: +1 (920) 408โ€‘1234

    0 Go to comments
    S
    SusanLiebman 3 hours ago
    Leon MacDonald lands first Super Rugby job since All Blacks exit

    Iโ€™ve always been careful with my cryptocurrency, but even the most cautious investors can fall victim to cyber threats. My nightmare began when a ransomware attack locked me out of my $500,000 Bitcoin wallet. The hackers demanded payment in exchange for access, but I refused to negotiate with criminals. Desperate and running out of options, I started researching legitimate crypto recovery services, something I never thought Iโ€™d need.During my search, I came across an article about crypto recovery services that highlighted Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery as an industry leader. While I was skeptical at first, I was also desperate. Every hour that passed felt like my funds were slipping further away. Finally, I decided to take a chance and reached out to their team.From the very first call, I knew I was dealing with professionals. The team at Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery listened patiently to my situation and reassured me that I wasnโ€™t alone,ransomware attacks were becoming increasingly common, and they had successfully helped many people recover their stolen crypto. Their confidence gave me hope.Once I provided the necessary details about my wallet and the attack, their forensic specialists got to work. Unlike the hackers, who demanded money without guarantees, Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery provided clear expectations, a transparent process, and constant updates. Their team used advanced blockchain analysis tools to trace the compromised transactions and locate vulnerabilities that could be exploited to regain access.The waiting period was nerve-wracking, but they delivered on every promise. Within a matter of days, I received the news I had been praying forโ€”my $500,000 had been fully restored. I could barely believe it. My funds were back, and the hackers had failed.Beyond the recovery itself, Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery also educated me on preventing future attacks. They advised me on strengthening my wallet security, using cold storage, and recognizing suspicious links or downloads that could contain malware. Their insight and expertise ensured that I wouldnโ€™t be caught off guard again.What started as a moment of complete despair ended with an incredible victoryโ€”all thanks to Pro Wizard Gilbert Recovery. If you ever find yourself in a situation where you think your crypto is gone for good, donโ€™t lose hope. They are the real deal, and they proved that even after a ransomware attack, your assets can still be saved.

    Email: prowizardgilbertrecovery(@)engineer.com

    Telegram: https://t.me/Pro_Wizard_Gilbert_Recovery

    WhatsApp: +1 (920) 408โ€‘1234

    6 Go to comments
    LONG READ
    LONG READ Super Rugby rolls back the years but challenges lie ahead Super Rugby rolls back the years but challenges lie ahead
    Search