Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

A question remains around England and the All Blacks haka

By PA
New Zealand players perform the Haka before the Autumn International match between England and New Zealand at Twickenham Stadium on November 19, 2022 in London, England. (Photo by Craig Mercer/MB Media/Getty Images)

England are seeking their first home victory over New Zealand since 2012 when Manu Tuilagi ran amok to inspire a famous upset.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here, the PA news agency examines five talking points heading into Saturday’s blockbuster clash to open the Autumn Nations Series.

Time to deliver
England’s record under Steve Borthwick reads played 24, won 13, lost 11. Setbacks during that time have been forgiven due to the mess he inherited from Eddie Jones in 2022 and a generally positive direction of travel but there can be no excuses this autumn, particularly as Alex Mitchell and Ollie Chessum are the only front line stars missing through injury. It is time for Borthwick’s England to deliver a rousing campaign by turning the type of near misses witnessed over the last 12 months against New Zealand, South Africa and France into statement wins. Anything less than three victories from four Tests – Australia, South Africa and Japan also visit Twickenham – would be viewed as a major disappointment.

Marler baits the All Blacks
In the words of captain Jamie George, Joe Marler has “prodded the bear” by calling for the “ridiculous” Haka to be “binned”. The All Blacks are fiercely protective of the Maori war dance and the veteran prop’s comments caused a stir in New Zealand, where even politicians were happy to respond. Storm in a tea cup or ammunition for a side who are already favourites? Marler’s outburst on social media has certainly not done England any favours, even if he has since apologised, but it will add to the theatre surrounding the pre-match ritual at Twickenham with England deciding whether to issue a challenge when it is performed.

Double Curry
For the first time, Tom and Ben Curry have been picked in the same matchday squad to raise the prospect of the identical twins – who to the untrained eye are distinguishable only by the colour of their boots or the number of the shirt on their backs – realising their boyhood dream of playing for England together. Tom, the younger brother by 90 minutes, makes his first start for a year after recovering from a serious hip injury with Ben poised to join the action off the bench in the second-half. England will need the relentless Sale flankers to fire if they are to stun the All Blacks.

Slade ready to shine
When asked if picking Henry Slade to take on New Zealand was a risk given he has played only 55 minutes this season, Borthwick replied that the Exeter centre is in “fantastic condition”. It is a sign of Slade’s value to the team a year after he was a surprise omission from the World Cup squad that he is deemed essential despite being so early in his comeback from shoulder surgery. Selecting the 65-cap veteran is a gamble worth taking given Borthwick needs tried and tested combinations knowing the autumn starts with a bang.

Fading aura
New Zealand may be favourites but there is no hiding that this is not a vintage year having lost three of their six Rugby Championship matches. Scott Robertson opened his reign as head coach with a 2-0 series victory over England but both Tests went down to the wire and Borthwick’s men were left wondering how they failed to edge at least one of them. Their team is still packed with stars – Beauden Barrett, Ardie Savea and Rieko Ioane among them – and they remain a devastating outfit, but the current All Blacks simply do not possess the fear factor of their predecessors.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Boks Office | Episode 37 | Six Nations Round 4 Review

Cape Town | Leg 2 | Day 2 | HSBC Challenger Series 2025 | Full Day Replay

Gloucester-Hartpury vs Bristol Bears | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Boks Office | Episode 36 | Six Nations Round 3 Review

Why did Scotland's Finn Russell take the crucial kick from the wrong place? | Whistle Watch

England A vs Ireland A | Full Match Replay

Kubota Spears vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | JRLO 2024/2025 | Full Match Replay

Watch now: Lomu - The Lost Tapes

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

6 Comments
F
Flankly 146 days ago

I would dial up the "fear factor" if I were England. NZ were RWC finalists a year ago, have world class players, and now have a very capable coach whose plans are starting to take shape. It's certainly been a rocky season by their standards, but its a team that is going to click in the next few months. England do not want that to happen this w/e.

R
RedWarrior 145 days ago

Come on! They had one significant victory (versus Ireland) in the RWC in which they lost twice to top 4 opponents.


England will show NZ due respect as they always do. But they need to play. When I hear George talking about emotional energy that was significant against Ireland, I'd take note.

If they reproduce that combination of emotional energy and accuracy then they will probably win.

T
Tk 145 days ago

Yes rocky season probably describes it quite well. I've been a bit disappointed that Razor has stuck with a number of previous ABs who perhaps should have been moved on by now, but get that he wanted some experience and stability while bringing in new philosophy and systems. After several months together I'm hoping that now is the time for it to start coming together. I expect at least parity in tight 5 and if the backs click they will score tries.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
MS 36 minutes ago
Andy Farrell answers burning Owen Farrell Lions question

I can understand negotiations for Kinghorn, White, and Ribbans. All three are playing very, very well at the current time. Kinghorn has been a leading contended for some time now; Ribbans looks as powerful as he’s ever been; while on the evidence of the most recent Six Nations, White benches behind JGP at Scrumhalf.


However, noone in their right mind should be considering Kyle Sinckler, Courtney Lawes, nor Owen Farrell. Sinckler looks unfit and can barely move around the field with any great urgency. He would be a liability on tour to Australia. Lawes is clearly ‘enjoying life’ in ProD2, and his rugby looks every bit second tier level now.


As for Farrell, not only has he been plagued by poor form and injury since moving to Racing, even the much vaunted ‘kicking record’ has long since been debunked as a USP with a percentage that simply does not stand up to scrutiny. That leaves only the intangible (desperate…) claim he would add ‘leadership’, which in a Lions squad resplendent with talent and international caps is I’m afraid, much like Farrell, a complete non-starter.


Willis is the elephant in the room…a leader and standout option for one of the best club teams in the World. Yet still a relative unknown at Test Match level. I could well see him being included on the tour - and it would prove quite the headache for the RFU if he delivers. But Back Row is so competitive across all three positions, and with genuine World Class talent there too. I’m just not sure the Lions need him.

4 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Departing Quins boss Billy Millard in talks over huge Test job Departing Quins boss Billy Millard in talks over huge Test job
Search