Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Talking Point: Should rugby look to the NFL for post-match sanctions?

Owen Farrell speaks with match official during England's win over Springboks at Twickenham. (Photo by Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

It seems as though the controversy over Owen Farrell’s last-minute tackle on Andre Esterhuizen at Twickenham is going nowhere fast.

ADVERTISEMENT

World Rugby have taken the decision not to cite, but that hasn’t stopped the issue being talked about ad nauseam and whether or not the decision not to cite Farrell will create a precedent moving forward, in regard to the legality of similar tackles.

The clear winners out of this situation are the broadcasters, who can continue to bill England versus New Zealand, or more specifically Farrell vs Beauden Barrett, as a battle of two of the preeminent competitors in international rugby.

One question that has arisen out of the furore surrounding the tackle is that of post-match sanctions in rugby union.

No one is suggesting that World Rugby’s zero tolerance towards contact with the head on the pitch is unfit for purpose. Red cards are a necessary determent to help change the long-term tackling behaviour of players and the adoption of such a hard line is to be praised, even if it has caused short-term confusion.

That said, could rugby learn from the NFL in terms of how it deals with the subsequent punishment of these incidents?

The NFL will rarely ban players from games for on-field misdemeanours, especially when they lack any kind of malicious intent. Unnecessary roughness, hitting a defenceless receiver and other similar penalties will often be treated with an on-field sanction and then the player will receive a monetary fine in the following week.

ADVERTISEMENT

Continue reading below…
Watch: Eddie Jones

Video Spacer

If there is adjudged to be intent and that the player made a conscious decision to act, rather than a reflex, then a short one or two game ban may be handed out, but generally the NFL reserves banning from play sanctions for use of performance-enhancing drugs and violations of the league’s personal conduct policy.

Would this be a preferable outcome in rugby?

Had World Rugby, or referee Angus Gardener, adjudged Farrell to have made contact with Esterhuizen above the shoulder line, and therefore picked up a red card and a multiple-week ban, there is no doubt it would have diminished the upcoming England vs New Zealand contest.

It could be argued that fans, as shareholders in the game, are the ones being punished, as much as the player and the team.

ADVERTISEMENT

In those situations, would a significant fine – bearing in mind the matchday fee for an England player is £22k – be a better outcome for the game? That money could then be invested in grassroots rugby, be donated to a charitable organisation or, perhaps most apt, be used to fund concussion research?

The flip side of the coin is the argument that it’s the potential cost of letting your teammates down, by your exclusion from important fixtures, that is most likely to change tackling behaviour long-term, not financial losses.

Or, is rugby still at a point where financial losses can dictate behaviour? After all, the earning potential in rugby is much lower than it is in football and the NFL.

It is a debate worth having, at the least.

You may also like: Wallabies Ashley-Cooper and Beale look ahead to Wales

Video Spacer

ADVERTISEMENT

South Africa vs New Zealand | The Rugby Championship U20's | Full Match Replay

Argentina vs Australia | The Rugby Championship U20's | Full Match Replay

Saitama Wildknights vs Tokyo Sungoliath | Japan Rugby League 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

The Game that Made Jonah Lomu

The gruelling reality behind one of the fastest sports in the world | The Report

Boks Office | Episode 40 | The Steven Kitshoff Special

Perry Baker in the house | HSBC Life on Tour | Los Angeles

Confidence knocks and finding your people | Flo Williams | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

S
Solenn Bonnet 4 days ago
Leinster cleanse palette with record URC scoreline against Zebre

My name is Solenn Bonnet, and I am a single mother navigating the challenges of raising my two-year-old child while trying to make ends meet. I came across a trading platform that promised astonishing daily profits of 18%. The allure of such a high return on investment was too tempting to resist, and I found myself drawn into cryptocurrency trading. Excited by the prospect of financial freedom, I invested a significant amount of my savings, totaling over 5.7 BTC. However, what started as a hopeful venture quickly turned into a nightmare. The platform was a scam, and I lost everything I had invested. The emotional toll of this loss was immense; I felt devastated and helpless, struggling to provide for my child and keep up with my bills. In my desperate attempt to recover my funds, I sought help from various recovery experts. Unfortunately, I encountered numerous fraudulent individuals who claimed they could help me retrieve my lost money. Each time I reached out, I was met with disappointment and further scams, which only deepened my despair. Last year was one of the most challenging periods of my life, filled with anxiety and uncertainty about my financial future. Feeling overwhelmed and at a loss, I confided in a close friend from church about my situation. She listened compassionately and shared her own experiences with financial difficulties. Understanding my plight, she introduced me to Tech Cyber Force Recovery, a group of skilled hackers known for their expertise in recovering lost funds. Skeptical yet hopeful, I decided to reach out to them as a last resort. Their services came at a higher cost, but my friend generously offered to help me with a partial payment. I was amazed by how quickly they responded and began the recovery process. Their team was professional, efficient, and incredibly supportive throughout the entire ordeal. To my relief, they successfully recovered more than I had lost to those heartless scammers. This was truly transformative, and I felt a sense of relief and gratitude that I hadn’t felt in a long time. I strongly encourage anyone who has faced similar challenges or fallen victim to scams to reach out to Tech Cyber Force Recovery. If you’ve invested in a fraudulent platform like I did, they are highly capable of helping you reclaim your hard-earned money. Don’t lose hope; there is a way to recover what you’ve lost.

CONSULT TECH CYBER FORCE RECOVERY

EMAIL.. support@techyforcecyberretrieval.com

WhatsApp.. +15617263697

website.. https://techyforcecyberretrieval.com

Telegram.. +15617263697

0 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING 'No offence to him, but I never knew how good he was' Tom Farrell: 'No offence to him, but I never knew how good he was'
Search