1
‘That worries me’: Ex-All Black’s bold Damian McKenzie selection call
By Finn Morton
Former All Black Shane Howarth has boldly predicted that Damian McKenzie won’t start at first five-eighth against England this weekend. McKenzie wore the No. 10 jersey against Japan, but Howarth believes the playmaker has “probably” played himself out of another start.
ADVERTISEMENT
With Richie Mo’unga leaving the All Blacks after last year’s Rugby World Cup, coach Scott Robertson had no choice but to make a change at flyhalf. ‘Razor’ Robertson picked McKenzie to start in that role in the first Test of the year and didn’t look back for quite some time.
McKenzie started against England in Dunedin to kick off the All Blacks international season, and the 29-year-old retained that role for the next seven Tests. Robertson rarely hooked the pivot as well, with McKenzie playing the entire 80 minutes in all but one of those starts.
But, McKenzie came under fire during The Rugby Championship as the All Blacks fell to three losses from six matches. Beauden Barrett was given the nod to start at flyhalf against the Wallabies in Wellington while ‘DMac’ looked to provide impact off the bench.
While McKenzie was given another chance to silence any doubters against Eddie Jones’ Brave Blossoms in Yokohama, the All Black didn’t quite do that. Howarth highlighted the second quarter of the Test as a particularly concerning period for the team and McKenzie.
“In the end of the whole rundown of the game, I think Damian McKenzie probably took himself out of the 10 spot,” Howarth said on SENZ’s Scotty & Izzy.
“I like Damian McKenzie and he’s been very good for the Chiefs this year at 10, but I think with these upcoming games, we can’t afford to be loose.
ADVERTISEMENT
“There was a 20-minute period in the backend of that first half where it was exceptional, and then we should have… with All Blacks sides, they put their foot on the throat, and they’re ruthless and we lost that in the second half.
“Watching Damian McKenzie, it’s like we couldn’t get ourselves on the track we’re on and that worries me a little bit because your decision-makers have to be able to change the tact of the game and I just didn’t see it.
“There were some great performances in terms of Wallace Sititi, and I thought Billy Proctor was impressive, Cam Roigard a little rusty but gees, you can see the talent that he’s got.
“Overall, I thought Damian McKenzie probably took himself out of the 10 jersey for this weekend’s Test.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Whether or not McKenzie gets the nod to start remains to be seen, with Barrett another leading contender to steer the ship against Steve Borthwick’s England. There’s a lot riding on this too, as both teams look to make a statement for different reasons.
Fans around the world don’t seem quite convinced by the All Blacks at the moment, so the visitors will look to prove some of their own critics wrong while they’re up north. As for the English, they’ll be out for revenge after going down in two thrillers during the July window.
England fell agonisingly short of wins in both Dunedin and at Auckland’s Eden Park. If it hadn’t been for some Beauden Barrett miracles off the bench, the All Blacks’ long-lasting winning streak at the famous rugby venue very well could’ve come to an end.
But now they’re playing England at the venue formerly known as Twickenham. It’s one of the more famous and intimidating venues around the rugby world, and the All Blacks may need to be at their very best if they’re to get the chocolates at the end of the 80-minute battle.
“It’s an intimidating place to play,” Howarth said.
“The English, they probably should’ve won the second Test, I believe, down here.
“They’ve picked a heck of a side and just technically 11 or 12 of our All Blacks haven’t played since our last Aussie Test so there’s going to be a little bit of rustiness in us.
“I think for the All Blacks, they’ve got to try and be dominant for that first 20 minutes, take the crowd out of it. I know it’s easy to say but I think we have to front up upfront because looking at the English pack, that’s what their whole mantra is going to be.”
He just making a few to many errors just needs to cut down on some of them he’ll get another go Dmac can play
Dmac is a weapon not a general, as an impact player he is deadly.
The longer Dan Carter is retired the more invincible he becomes. I was in HK when Aus deservedly beat NZ. Carter had a very poor game by his standards but Stephen Donald with a 10 min cameo was the reason NZ lost - apparently. Henry never played Donald again on that tour nor spoke to him.
Hardly anyone making comments has played 10 at any level but everyone knows how to play there and how easy it is! DMac should just go to Japan and forget about the ABs - he gets little respect for his brilliance.
Carter had heaps of poor games prob for Dmac he hadn’t really had a statement game at international level Carter had bad games but had plenty of good ones too diff stages
Agree its time he looked after himself and not sit around waiting for the hatred. The reason people blamed Donald was because he missed a reletively easy kick at goal that would have put NZ out to an 8 point advantage with 5 mins left.
Many forget his form leading up the 2015 WC was so bad that people were calling for him to be dropped. The rest is history but he was far from infallible, and spent chunks of his career in average form when coming back from so many long term injuries. Had Nick Evans stayed in NZ Carter's career may not have been what it turned out to be.
There are many people who comment on this site who think a fly half kicking the ball is the greatest sin that can be committed. Accusations of "aimless" kicking are levelled frequently with no appreciation whatsoever of why someone might be kicking and how good defences are these days - Like they can sum up the game situation better than Barrett or DMac.
Nothing wrong with Mac. A superb player. But one man does not make a team.
Where are the other 14 or 23 odd?
Yes it seems he is getting dropped because his team mates let Aus score 4 tries. He blew 2 tries in that match but he also set up 9 line breaks in that match which resulted in the win. Then in the return match he comes on and sets up their only try all year past the 60 min mark.
DMac has flair, no doubt about that, but if you think there's nothing wrong with him you haven't seen what everyone else has; passes to nowhere, aimless box kicks under pressure, and basically a guy who leaves his team-mates wondering what the heck he is doing.
I can see Reuben Love being a future 10. There's just something about him that shows calmness and the ability to attack space and free up those outside him. Hopefully he gets a chance there for the Canes next year.
yes, since there is a big gap between our best #10 (probably MoUnga, sad to say) and what Carter was, we do need to start auditioning a few more players, because I don't think BB is the answer, and DMac definitely isn't.