Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The challenges facing rugby union in 2022

(Photo by Visionhaus)

2021 was certainly a turbulent year for rugby and sport as a whole. Whilst the last year has taught us that it can be difficult to forecast what could happen in the coming year, there are a number of issues that have made headlines in 2021 which are very likely to roll on into 2022.

ADVERTISEMENT

In this article, Jamie Horner, sports partner at Keystone Law, offers his predictions on the key challenges facing the sport in 2022.

The Future of Championship Clubs
Will we ever see another team like Exeter rise from the Championship? It seems unlikely at the current time with such a significant funding gap between the top-flight and second tier.

Video Spacer

Francois Hougaard on Wasps beating Tigers and Bakkies Botha memories | RugbyPass Offload | Episode 16

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:00
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
      Video Spacer

      Francois Hougaard on Wasps beating Tigers and Bakkies Botha memories | RugbyPass Offload | Episode 16

      Reduced finance is affecting the sustainability of Championship Clubs, with RFU CEO Bill Sweeney countering criticism that the sport’s governing body is ignoring the needs of Tier 2 rugby. Funding which had doubled in 2016 was then cut dramatically in 2019 at the start of Sweeney’s tenure as part of a strategy of fiscal tightening at HQ. Against the background of the pandemic, funding for the Championship was further reduced in 2020/21 even with the Premiership providing financial support.

      The RFU Council will gather this month to hear recommendations following an in-depth review of the Championship. These are rumoured to include conference structures, more regionality, a greater number of National One clubs, the creation of Premiership second teams, a focus on English player ratios, and age restrictions (with potentially 80 per cent of Championship teams to be made up of U23s).

      With a moratorium in place regarding relegation from the Premiership until the end of the 2023/24 season, the discussion regarding the pros and cons of ringfencing the Premiership also continues.

      Unlike say football where teams in the Championship ultimately aspire to be promoted to the Premier League, in rugby this aspiration is not so simple.

      ADVERTISEMENT

      In fact, few, if any, clubs in the Championship are equipped with the financial resources and stadiums required to flourish in the Premiership, nor do many have the desire to step up. Championship clubs have also argued that the funding cut effectively amounts to ring fencing in any case.

      The threat of relegation for clubs in the topflight is particularly pertinent due to COVID-19 and the unpredictability that has occurred. Clubs in the Premiership may be pushing for ringfencing to be made permanent, at least for the short-term as to cement their positions at such a precarious time.

      On the flipside, if ringfencing is made into a permanent measure, could this mean that clubs in the Championship effectively become no more than feeder clubs for those above them? But isn’t this already the case as the funding gap has already, in effect, ringfenced the Premiership? Is this the best option for the future sustainability of all concerned?

      Championship RFE England
      (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
      ADVERTISEMENT

      The Premiership will increase to 14 clubs from the start of the 2022/2023 with a play-off between the clubs that finishes bottom of the Premiership and top of the Championship in 2023/2024. Relegation and promotion are due to return in 2024-2025, unless the RFU council decides otherwise. The play-off scenario is surely a better option that enforced relegation and promotion and at least offers the opportunity of upward mobility for the Exeter of the future, if there is one.

      Traumatic Brain Injury
      A year ago, it was first revealed that eight former professional rugby players, all aged under 45, were contemplating legal action against World Rugby, the RFU and WRU following diagnosis with early onset dementia.

      The number of players involved in the potential class action unsurprisingly continues to grow and now numbers in excess of 175 players, including several international players.
      Traumatic brain injury (TBI) of which concussion is a mild form, is a major ongoing problem for rugby, despite the introduction of the Head Injury Assessments (HIA) and an increasing number of red cards for dangerous tackles.

      The red card debate is a regular feature of the coverage and review of many games. Alongside this, the research into and development of the definition of concussion and the return-to-play protocols after a player has suffered a TBI continue to progress.

      Wales’ Hadleigh Parkes has blood seeping from a head wound during the Guinness Six Nations match at Scotland (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

      However, the problem runs deep, as is evidenced by the ongoing research being carried out by the Drake Foundation into the short and long-term impact of sport on brain health in rugby and football. The latest Drake Rugby Biomarker Study released in July 2021, indicates that 23% of elite adult rugby players who were still actively involved in the sport had abnormalities in brain structure, and half showed an unexpected change in brain volume.

      From a legal perspective, the claims made in the class action are probably unlikely to make it to court, which could result in negative press for the game’s governing bodies.

      Equally, these claims will not just disappear. An out of court settlement, or the establishment of a fund for injured players as followed the NFL litigation, is the likely result. However, the governing bodies and their legal advisors may decide that this should be a test case, which requires a judicial decision given the legal hurdles that will need to be overcome for the players to make their claims stick. Either way, it is inevitable that other players will follow suit and seek compensation because of rugby-related TBI, which could have significant financial consequences for the game. The shadow cast by TBI could also see the sport’s global popularity wane significantly.

      Insurance premiums covering for player injury, including TBIs, are also likely to rocket. Who will cover this cost – the clubs, the players or the governing bodies?

      Clearly, the need to monitor the cumulative effect of contact is crucial and is resulting in technology playing an increasing role in player welfare, for example, accelerometers in gum shields will be introduced in the Premiership in 2022. These technologies cannot help players already suffering from the effects of the sport but can protect future generations for years to come.

      The benefits of rugby are well documented, however, set against high-profile head injury- related compensation claims in an increasingly risk-averse society, is this enough to sustain both player numbers and rugby as we know it at a grass roots level?

      One wonders whether rugby in its current form will remain on the school curriculum in years to come.

      The bite of the salary cap reduction
      As further fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic, Premiership clubs are now operating under a reduced salary cap of £5 million this season after £1.4m was cut from their spending capacity due to the financial impact of COVID. Also, only one rather than two “marquee players” may sit outside the salary cap.

      With player salary expectations not matching the new cap, there is already a telling impact on a Premiership club’s ability to attract global talent and also maintain their current squads.
      Looking at Exeter, for example, both Jonny Hill and Sam Skinner have already been confirmed as moving on at the end of the season. Will Stuart Hogg and Jonny Gray follow?

      Exeter <a href=
      Sale Premiership” width=”1920″ height=”1081″ /> (Photo by PA)

      A clear benefit will be the focus on developing “local” talent of which Exeter has a proven track record with the likes of Jack Nowell, Luke Cowan-Dickie and Henry Slade all being products of the Chief’s highly regarded academy structure. As a long-term initiative, English clubs are likely to increasingly rely on nurturing homegrown talent in order to prosper. Clubs in England will be judged compared to their counterparts on this ability.

      Nonetheless, this scenario is creating an increasingly unfair playing field in European club rugby with English teams facing teams from France and Ireland that are not subject to the same degree of financial restriction. This will likely have an effect on the success of English teams in both the European Champions Cup and the European Challenge Cup. Will sponsors look to European clubs with celebrity status players at the top of the international game as opposed to English players moving forward? Perhaps.

      The ongoing dispute between Premiership clubs and agents
      The stand-off between Premiership clubs and agents stemming from the interpretation of recent HMRC guidance on the payment of agents’ fees is unresolved and could also potentially see an increasing number of players move overseas.

      New guidance was issued by HMRC on 31 March 2021 (HMRC Manual EIM01150 on ‘Football Clubs: Payments to Intermediaries’) concerning the payment of football agents’ fees. The guidance could be equally applied to the tax position of rugby players, clubs and agents’ fees. Premiership clubs are, therefore, proposing that the payment of agents’ fees by clubs should be prohibited. On the other hand, the agents view this proposal as an attempt to sideline them and remove their influence from the game. They also feel that this proposal is motivated by a desire by clubs to save money in the face of the financial pressures brought on by Covid-19 and the lowered salary cap biting.

      generic Twickenham
      Twickenham Stadium /Press Association

      Agents continue to threaten not to endorse deals with the Premiership clubs until the situation has been resolved and may increasingly focus their attention on securing overseas moves for players to countries, such as Japan, where clubs do pay agents fees.

      The dispute has been the subject of mediation between the clubs and agents. Common ground will have to be found in order to nip this issue in the bud and prevent long-term damage to the game.

      Ultimately, the financial burden will fall most on the players and both sides must work together to act in their best interests. Players will no doubt also increasingly question the value of the player/agent relationship and what is in their best interests in the long run. Solutions such as fixed fee arrangements rather than commission-based contract negotiation fees could prove to be an attractive alternative for some players, especially those renewing existing contracts.

      Players may justifiably begin to question the value for money offered by their agents moving forward. Professional advice should be sought when a player signs for or renews his or her contract with a club, but a specialist sports lawyer accredited by the RFU could offer a cost-effective alternative moving forward especially for those players who wish to become more involved in their own management enabling them to seek third party advice and support, as and when required.

      COVID-19
      The damage to sport caused by the pandemic continues with the pre-Christmas surge in cases as a result of the Omicron variant.

      Aside from the increasing number of players, coaches and support staff being affected by COVID-19, strict quarantine requirements have already impacted heavily on clubs like Cardiff and Scarlets.
      With Mark Drakeford, the Welsh First Minister, recently announcing that from Boxing Day sport in Wales will carry on behind closed doors, URC derby games will be affected for a second successive year along with football and the Welsh Grand National. The financial effects on the sustainability of the professional game in the Welsh Regions is of grave concern, despite the support provided to clubs and venues from the Spectator Sports Fund.

      Similarly, in Scotland, crowds have been capped at 500 people for three weeks from the 26 December. It was announced this week that this will be revoked in time for the Six Nations.

      The Premier League’s decision to play on with crowds over the Christmas and New Year period set a helpful precedent for English rugby. However, if there is another lockdown or period of playing behind closed doors, would the Premiership be able to survive in its current form?

      Recently, Pat Lam, the director of Rugby at Bristol Bears, has suggested that the possibility of the sport being restricted in England could mean that some of England’s top clubs near the brink of bankruptcy. If richer, more endowed teams like Bristol Bears are expressing concerns here, the effects further down the sport could possibly be dire.

      As we approach the Six Nations, it seems that all games will be played in front of crowds. It is arguable that more so than in the past, the international sports arena has become increasingly disjointed. This is an unforeseen consequence the pandemic has had on the sport. How will the sport recover this international culture? Perhaps we will have to wait until the World Cup in 2023 to find out.

      Jamie Horner is a partner at Keystone Law, specialising in sport law, and is an RFU Accredited Agent.

      ADVERTISEMENT

      LIVE

      Vancouver SVNS | Day 2

      Boks Office | Episode 35 | Six Nations Round 2 Review

      O2 Inside Line: This Rose | Episode 3 | France Week

      Second round of the Men's Six Nations | Whistle Watch

      Harlequins vs Bristol Bears | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

      Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Saitama Wildknights | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

      Watch now: Lomu - The Lost Tapes

      The Dupont Ploy: How France went from underdogs to Olympic gods | The Report

      Former rugby player is truly an NFL superstar | Walk the Talk | Jordan Mailata

      Trending on RugbyPass

      Comments

      0 Comments
      Be the first to comment...

      Join free and tell us what you really think!

      Sign up for free
      ADVERTISEMENT

      Latest Features

      Comments on RugbyPass

      J
      JW 1 hour ago
      Where is the new breed of All Black 10?

      Players like Prendergast and Finn Smith already have a few seasons at top club level under their belt and are now test players, at an age when NZ players make their debuts in SR.

      That’s just a difference in standards. You’re confusing SR for being their local domestic comps, where it’s more accurately comparable to Champions Cup, apart from that teams are happy to throw games as it’s in a bit of a limbo in terms of importance atm.


      All these kids have been playing for a comparable NPC team for years now. Sam is no where near ready for tests but he has a great temperament, much like Sextons, that makes it a good choice to speed up his development. He wasn’t even a comparable Super Rugby starter before playing for Ireland, so not a great comparison.


      Fin would be much better example, but then England don’t have 3 world class Test tens in front of him (not that I’d put Beauden their but obviously in terms of young NZ players chances, he is). Would he otherwise have debuted at the same age as Fergus Burke (injury and leaving withstanding), around 24, a couple of years later? England also aren’t as pedantic to who they give jerseys to, in NZ a test jersey is very hard earned for the most part.


      In general I think the effects are as you say, but the only difference is the money involved, as you yourself said, their paths are just as all over the show being loaned out playing for clubs etc. My solution to that, and what you perceive as the problem, would be to introduce university football that utilitizes the large investment they have into high performance sport.

      88 Go to comments
      J
      Jennifer Ross 4 hours ago
      One rule for Europe's copycats, another for the Springboks

      The topic of recovery services and the efficacy of Wizard Hilton Cyber Tech warrants a closer examination. Recovery services are a critical component of any comprehensive cybersecurity strategy, as they provide the means to restore systems, data, and operations in the event of a breach or other disruptive incident. Wizard Hilton Cyber Tech is a leading provider in this space, offering a suite of advanced recovery solutions designed to ensure business continuity and mitigate the potentially devastating impacts of cyber attacks. At the core of their offerings is a robust, AI-driven platform that continuously monitors systems, detects anomalies, and triggers rapid, automated recovery procedures. This allows organizations to bounce back quickly, often with minimal downtime or data loss. Wizard Hilton's approach also emphasizes the importance of comprehensive testing and simulation, putting recovery protocols through their paces to validate effectiveness and uncover potential weaknesses. Additionally, their team of seasoned cybersecurity experts provides hands-on guidance, tailoring solutions to the unique needs of each client. By combining cutting-edge technology with deep industry expertise, Wizard Hilton Cyber Tech has established itself as a trusted partner in the realm of recovery services, empowering organizations to safeguard their most valuable digital assets and ensure business resilience in the face of ever-evolving cyber threats. Contact: for assistance.

      Regards.

      28 Go to comments
      J
      Jennifer Ross 4 hours ago
      One rule for Europe's copycats, another for the Springboks

      The topic of recovery services and the efficacy of Wizard Hilton Cyber Tech warrants a closer examination. Recovery services are a critical component of any comprehensive cybersecurity strategy, as they provide the means to restore systems, data, and operations in the event of a breach or other disruptive incident. Wizard Hilton Cyber Tech is a leading provider in this space, offering a suite of advanced recovery solutions designed to ensure business continuity and mitigate the potentially devastating impacts of cyber attacks. At the core of their offerings is a robust, AI-driven platform that continuously monitors systems, detects anomalies, and triggers rapid, automated recovery procedures. This allows organizations to bounce back quickly, often with minimal downtime or data loss. Wizard Hilton’s approach also emphasizes the importance of comprehensive testing and simulation, putting recovery protocols through their paces to validate effectiveness and uncover potential weaknesses. Additionally, their team of seasoned cybersecurity experts provides hands-on guidance, tailoring solutions to the unique needs of each client. By combining cutting-edge technology with deep industry expertise, Wizard Hilton Cyber Tech has established itself as a trusted partner in the realm of recovery services, empowering organizations to safeguard their most valuable digital assets and ensure business resilience in the face of ever-evolving cyber threats. Contact: for assistance,

       Email : wizardhiltoncybertech ( @ ) gmail (. ) com  OR  support ( @ ) wizardhiltoncybertech (.) com

      WhatsApp number +13024457895

      28 Go to comments
      J
      JW 4 hours ago
      Where is the new breed of All Black 10?

      JJ and DMac shows how little attention you actually pay to the substance of the articles.

      What do you mean by that? For lack of an answer from you I’d suggest yuo need to look at the game again and then read your article. Because although I’m not going to again but I did quickly review the videos and they all match correctly with my perception.

      JTPL is shifting towards overseas players being JQP in future

      No they’re not, thats a flatout lie Nick. You can find an article on here with their CEO where they want more out of their deals but it’s standard professional sports fair, nothing underhand like the NH does. I find that quite foul that you would share such a view.


      I suppose the new World Club League thats starting would die for the best ABs even for just a year, and probably set them up even better. Mo’unga hadn’t done enough to earn a sabbatical though. This is where NZR needs to start questioning itself. You can’t blame the player if the NZR are not even interesting in offering you a contract. In situations where say NZR aren’t able to reach 70% of the offer I think a great starting point would be for them to be treated differently than someone who just left for money. NZR could say make that player immediately eligible if NZR decide to make a fair offer and they sign to return, with players putting in their overseas contracts a right to leave early if they resign back with NZR.


      Even with Japans fading desire for sabbaticals I still think NZ can make it a good destination and have many reciprocal agreements with JRFU and the JRLO teams. The situation still very much favours NZ and Australia but it’s upto them to make the most of it or the JRFU won’t see any reason to be the ones always giving the favours.

      88 Go to comments
      LONG READ
      LONG READ ‘Golden boy of English rugby may be destined to be frustrated super-sub' ‘Golden boy of English rugby may be destined to be frustrated super-sub'
      Search