Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The 'one difference' between Boks and the back-to-back All Blacks

Richie McCaw captain of the New Zealand All Blacks shakes hands with Willie Le Roux of South Africa after the 2015 Rugby World Cup Semi Final match between South Africa and New Zealand at Twickenham Stadium on October 24, 2015 in London, United Kingdom. (Photo by Steve Bardens - World Rugby via Getty Images/World Rugby via Getty Images)

Former England captain Dylan Hartley has highlighted what he sees as the ‘one difference’ between South Africa’s back-to-back Rugby World Cup triumphs and the 2011 to 2015 All Blacks.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Springboks face a crestfallen England team tomorrow in Twickenham and are favourites to come away with the win after England lost to New Zealand and then Australia, with both matches coming down to the buzzer.

Hartley, who captained England to a Grand Slam under Eddie Jones, dismissed any leadership concerns within the squad and explained that the current team were simply missing a collective focus, intensity and understanding in key moments, which has cost them in matches against New Zealand and Australia.

Video Spacer

Joe Rokocoko on teams challenging the Haka | RPTV

New Zealand and Racing 92 legend and now coach Joe Rokocoko joins Mathieu Bastareaud for the latest episode of The Basta Show. Watch now [French] on RugbyPass TV.

Watch now

Video Spacer

Joe Rokocoko on teams challenging the Haka | RPTV

New Zealand and Racing 92 legend and now coach Joe Rokocoko joins Mathieu Bastareaud for the latest episode of The Basta Show. Watch now [French] on RugbyPass TV.

Watch now

On the challenge of the world champions, Hartley explained that England will be confident that they can get a result though he admitted that they’ll be hurting after the two defeats.

The 38-year-old reckons the current Boks squad is quite the same calibre as the All Blacks team that won the 2011 and 2015 Rugby World Cups.

Hartley noted the All Blacks, led by legends like Richie McCaw and Dan Carter, were near-unbeatable between World Cups, while South Africa focuses on peaking during the tournament itself.

“The current South African team, back-to-back World Cup winners, much like the All Blacks. There’s one difference between this South Africa team and the All Blacks back-to-back World Cup winners.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The All Blacks seem to be far more dominant; I don’t know if the stats prove that, but it felt that they were unplayable in many instances in that period of back-to-backs World Cup wins. Conrad Smith, Dan Carter, Richie McCaw, that gang of guys, it seemed in between the World Cups they were so dominant, whereas I feel South Africa, and this might just be my perception, they dominated the World Cup, they turn up, they do the business, but in between they’re probably not as convincing as the All Blacks. That’s just my opinion.”

He praised South Africa’s achievement, stressing the current era’s heightened competition due to advances in global coaching and analytics. Hartley argued that comparing the two teams is unfair, as the game has evolved significantly since New Zealand’s 2011 and 2015 victories.

“What I do think is impressive, if we want to give the South Africa a pat on the back, is the fact that the game is so tight at the top now. When the All Blacks were doing their thing, there was quite a big disparity, a big gap between the Northern and Southern Hemisphere. Australia, New Zealand and South Africa were still light years ahead in the way that they were playing the game. Whereas with South Africa now, every national coach is travelling around the globe, everyone’s sharing knowledge, everyone understands the game in a more analytical way.

“I think it’s even more impressive that South Africa have won back-to-back when the competition’s actually got much better, and teams are far more competitive. The game’s different now. The game’s four years on, it’s eight years on, it keeps moving. The game’s different to what they were playing back in 2011 and 2015. To compare the two teams, the All Blacks and South Africa, from different eras of the game, I don’t think it’s very fair.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Hartley was talking to Prime Casino. 

Related

Watch the exclusive reveal-all episode of Walk the Talk with Ardie Savea as he chats to Jim Hamilton about the RWC 2023 experience, life in Japan, playing for the All Blacks and what the future holds. Watch now for free on RugbyPass TV

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

115 Comments
H
Hellhound 43 days ago

What a disappointing game. Stop start, penalties, cards, knockons. Not at all played to their usual standards.

B
Bull Shark 44 days ago

I think you have it spot on.

H
Hellhound 44 days ago

It's what I said when I saw the line up. As usual the English will fall back to WC semi tactics. Rassie is expecting that and don't be surprised if the Boks run from their own half and 22 because the English will hand us the ball kicking the whole time.


You can't win if you don't have the ball, and with them still busy implementing Tony Browns attacking strategy or rather trying to perfect it, it's the perfect opportunity to exploit it.


The 5/3 split is also indicative of the Boks game plan. I'm expecting an expansive attacking game. The English will try and make it ugly. Their defence is very porous and the Boks attack is very dangerous. With box kicks from the English, it will most likely create 50/50 balls, and the Boks is extremely dangerous with that pace in broken play.


I may read the whole game strategy wrong because it is Rassie after all, but that is what this team and bench tells me.

D
DrinkAwayTheConcussion 44 days ago

The 2023 Springboks had the toughest run in history. They were dead on their feet by the end of the final, hanging on by sheer bloody mindedness.

It was one the most impressive sporting achievements I have ever seen.

Some calls were fortuitous, some weren’t.

Such is the game.

I look forward to the All Blacks exacting ruthless revenge.

R
Rhett Hammond 44 days ago

There is the small matter of Bryce Lawrence in that 2011 semi between SA and Australia, widely acknowledged as probably the worst reffed game in RWC history. He is now head of reffing in Kiwiland. Aside from this factor Richie and Co were excellent at ref management, they were the first to implement it as part of their strategy. SA under Rassie have managed the adverse penalty count with huge effect. That is all I have to say.

M
MM 44 days ago

It was actually the quarter final where Australia humbled the Boks Rhett. Just like Ireland, the Boks couldn’t get a semi…..

The ABs then smashed the Aussies in the semi-final.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

A
AllyOz 19 hours ago
Does the next Wallabies coach have to be an Australian?

I will preface this comment by saying that I hope Joe Schmidt continues for as long as he can as I think he has done a tremendous job to date. He has, in some ways, made the job a little harder for himself by initially relying on domestic based players and never really going over the top with OS based players even when he relaxed his policy a little more. I really enjoy how the team are playing at the moment.


I think Les Kiss, because (1) he has a bit more international experience, (2) has previously coached with Schmidt and in the same setup as Schmidt, might provide the smoothest transition, though I am not sure that this necessarily needs to be the case.


I would say one thing though about OS versus local coaches. I have a preference for local coaches but not for the reason that people might suppose (certainly not for the reason OJohn will have opined - I haven't read all the way down but I think I can guess it).


Australia has produced coaches of international standing who have won World Cups and major trophies. Bob Dwyer, Rod Macqueen, Alan Jones, Michael Cheika and Eddie Jones. I would add John Connolly - though he never got the international success he was highly successful with Queensland against quality NZ opposition and I think you could argue, never really got the run at international level that others did (OJohn might agree with that bit). Some of those are controversial but they all achieved high level results. You can add to that a number of assistants who worked OS at a high level.


But what the lack of a clear Australian coach suggests to me is that we are no longer producing coaches of international quality through our systems. We have had some overseas based coaches in our system like Thorn and Wessels and Cron (though I would suggest Thorn was a unique case who played for Australia in one code and NZ in the other and saw himself as a both a NZer and a Queenslander having arrived here at around age 12). Cron was developed in the Australian system anyway, so I don't have a problem with where he was born.


But my point is that we used to have systems in Australia that produced world class coaches. The systems developed by Dick Marks, which adopted and adapted some of the best coaching training approaches at the time from around the world (Wales particularly) but focussed on training Australian coaches with the best available methods, in my mind (as someone who grew up and began coaching late in that era) was a key part of what produced the highly skilled players that we produced at the time and also that produced those world class coaches. I think it was slipping already by the time I did my Level II certificate in 2002 and I think Eddie Jones influence and the priorities of the executive, particularly John O'Neill, might have been the beginning of the end. But if we have good coaching development programmes at school and junior level that will feed through to representative level then we will have


I think this is the missing ingredient that both ourselves and, ironically, Wales (who gave us the bones of our coaching system that became world leading), is a poor coaching development system. Fix that and you start getting players developing basic skills better and earlier in their careers and this feeds through all the way through the system and it also means that, when coaching positions at all levels come up, there are people of quality to fill them, who feed through the system all the way to the top. We could be exporting more coaches to Japan and England and France and the UK and the USA, as we have done a bit in the past.


A lack of a third tier between SR and Club rugby might block this a little - but I am not sure that this alone is the reason - it does give people some opportunity though to be noticed and play a key role in developing that next generation of players coming through. And we have never been able to make the cost sustainable.


I don't think it matters that we have an OS coach as our head coach at the moment but I think it does tell us something about overall rugby ecosystem that, when a coaching appointment comes up, we don't have 3 or 4 high quality options ready to take over. The failure of our coaching development pathway is a key missing ingredient for me and one of the reasons our systems are failing.

131 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Gaston Mieres: 'Rugby has been an addiction - a good one' Gaston Mieres: 'Rugby has been an addiction - a good one'
Search