Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The predictability problem with Super Rugby Pacific

SUPERRUGBY PACIFIC BOAT

How many of you tipsters went six-for-six in week one of Super Rugby Pacific?

And are there any of you now worried about blemishing your perfect record in week two?

As I cast my eye towards the, ironically-named, Super Round at AAMI Park, there aren’t too many clashes causing me sleepless nights.

ADVERTISEMENT

Particularly given I’ve got Covid again, which makes staying awake harder than falling asleep.

But I digress.

The one tipping dilemma I have this week is wondering who’s worse out of the Rebels and Force.

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

Home advantage isn’t a factor, given the Rebels have no following and are marked for extinction, while the Force failed to fire a shot against the Hurricanes.

Beyond that game, though, I see clear winners in every other clash in Melbourne this weekend.

Assuming you did go six-for-six last week, how many games did you regard as having been a contest?

The Chiefs’ win over the Crusaders was hard-fought and in the balance for all 80 minutes but and then what?

Moana Pasifika put in a manful effort against the Highlanders and the Waratahs competed with the Reds for a while, but the results never really appeared to be in doubt.

ADVERTISEMENT

Put simply, the teams that should’ve won in week one did and, as far as I can tell, will continue doing so until the end of the season.

It’d be a shame to have all that rugby and end up where the competition started (and finished a year ago), with the Chiefs playing the Crusaders in Hamilton again.

But that’s where we are. Resigned to having probably already had a preview of this year’s final.

That’s not to say I wasn’t entertained at times, during week one. Or that there definitely won’t be an upset in the 14 weeks of regular-season footy that follow.

ADVERTISEMENT

It’s just that, to be a real competition, you have to have competitiveness. Otherwise you’re simply playing exhibition games.

When you get past the sabbaticals and the retirements and all the elite All Blacks who are not playing in Super Rugby Pacific for whatever reason, this is my actual problem with the competition.

We have two good teams, a couple of useful ones and the rest.

Regardless of changes of personnel or seasons, the outcomes seem to stay the same.

What’s Super about that?

Unless you have a huge emotional investment in your particular team – or rugby as a whole – what’s your incentive to watch?

I’ll put it to you a different way.

I know few people who had any intention of watching the recent test cricket series between Australia and the West Indies, mostly because of the assumption that it wouldn’t be a contest.

Well, you wouldn’t believe how many closet Caribbean cricket fans emerged after the West Indies won the final test in Brisbane. People were compelled to tune in because of the way the West Indies competed.

India is leading England 3-1 in a test series at the moment. That looks decisive on paper, but it’s been great viewing because the matches themselves have been contests.

I don’t want to see the Chiefs or Crusaders weakened but, for Super Rugby Pacific to endure, things have to be done to strengthen the other teams.

Drafts, transfers, salary caps, whatever. We can’t let teams languish and disincentivize fans from watching.

It really shouldn’t be that hard to cobble together 12 competitive and profitable teams from countries with our playing, coaching and financial resources.

Related

ADVERTISEMENT

Boks Office | Episode 32 | How To Win Europe

Round 12 Highlights | PWR 2024/25

Bristol Bears vs Gloucester-Hartpury | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Toshiba Brave Lupus Tokyo vs Kobelco Kobe Steelers | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match

Edinburgh vs Brython | Celtic Challenge 2024/25 | Match Highlights

Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Toshiba Brave Lupus Tokyo | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Global Schools Challenge | Day 2 Replay

AUSTRALIA vs USA behind the scenes | HSBC SVNS Embedded | E04

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

5 Comments
g
gordon 315 days ago

League and Warriors fans are always saying how much much better the NRL is than rugby. Penrith have won the competition 3 years in a row…..

P
Pecos 315 days ago

Just profiled all competitions, give or take.

J
JJGhost 316 days ago

Super rugby was last interesting when it was the Super12 and focused on the best teams from SA, NZ and a small enough pool of Aussie teams to make them competitive. It’s been downhill ever since they expanded to 14, then 18 and now the NZ only version.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

F
Flankly 1 hour ago
Hansen saga has no winners but rugby needs characters and referees – Andy Goode

Refs make mistakes and they make 50/50 decisions that people don't like. Everyone knows that. And if we're aiming for a world in which people can't discuss those decisions then we're being idiotic.


But there is a big difference between questioning a decision and questioning the integrity of a referee. I don't mind a player or coach saying that they disagree with a Busby decision about Barrett, for example. In fact I am fine if they want to go and produce a tape and a commentary about it. Refs are in the public eye just as much as players are, and it's cool for people to analyze their performances IMV.


What's not OK is to say that they are biased, have hidden agendas, or intentionally favor certain teams or individuals. Nor is it great to call into question their competence, notwithstanding the obvious fact that some refs are more talented and/or experienced than others. Stick to discussing what they did, not who they are or what there intentions may be.


Also, while I think it should be fine (and not penalized) for a player or coach to disagree with certain decisions, I would observe that great teams don't blame "uncontrollables" for their losses and failures. As a player Hansen should treat refereeing the same as the bounce of the ball, the weather or injuries in the team. Uncontrollables are part of the challenge, regardless of how fair you think they are in any particular case.

5 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Why teenager Henry Pollock is 'ready now' to play in new-look England back row Why teenager Henry Pollock is 'ready now' to play in new-look England back row
Search