Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The Springboks’ Erasmus dilemma – stick or twist?

(Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images).

Are we to believe Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus when he suggests that he could be out of a job on Sunday?

ADVERTISEMENT

Yes, Erasmus has, publicly, stated that “if we do really bad here [against the All Blacks in Wellington on Saturday], then I will probably not be in the seat for the next couple of matches and somebody else will probably be there”.

The Bok coach, who is also the South African Rugby Union’s Director of Rugby, has also said he will “accept the consequences” for the team’s current losing streak.

However, only the short-sighted will support calls for the removal of Erasmus.

Let’s take a step back and take the emotion out of the situation.

Yes, the Springboks – winning or losing – remain and emotive subject, especially in a country where portions of the population follow it with religious devotion.

However, that has – repeatedly in the past – resulting in the axing of coaches before the end of their terms.

We often compare the Springboks to the All Blacks and want them to be as efficient and consistent as New Zealand.

That will only happen if they take a leaf out of the All Black book.

ADVERTISEMENT

After what, for them, was a disaster at the 2007 World Cup, they did not throw the baby out with the bathwater.

They showed faith in Graham Henry and Steve Hansen and a decade later are the most dominant force in the sport’s history.

Reading between the lines – and given his six-year contract – Erasmus’ appointment was done with the same vision.

Despite the headline-grabbing statement in New Zealand this week, Erasmus will certainly NOT walk away – regardless of the outcome of their encounter with the mighty All Blacks.

ADVERTISEMENT

He made it clear his current selection policy – given the political directives he functions under – is with a view to the long-term sustainability of Bok rugby.

“We [the coaching staff] should take that [pressure],” he said, adding: “We are selecting them [those players], we are backing them and we think we will win with them.

“I know we are doing the right things to fix South African rugby in the long run,” he said, adding that he doesn’t believe in crisis management.

“We should back these young guns and start building a future.”

Despite the demands – especially from they keyboard warriors – for instant success, axing Erasmus now will serve no purpose.

Firstly, who would replace him?

Have we learnt nothing from the departure of coaches like Jake White, Heyneke Meyer and Allister Coetzee?

I want to echo what Erasmus said to the media in New Zealand this week.

“If you think like that [instant success], then you never will build a squad that will be competitive.

“The only thing that six-year contract tells me is not to think about next week, think about the World Cup [next year] and the 2023 World Cup as well.”

That is why I tend to feel – going against every fibre of my rugby soul – we should not look at the results, but at the growth.

I will probably attract heaps of abuse from the keyboard warriors, but perhaps it is time to take emotion out of the equation and let the players grow – from where we give them two, three and four for ratings, till where they are six, seven and eight.

By Jan de Koning
@king365ed
Credit: @rugby365com

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

H
Hellhound 3 hours ago
Brett Robinson looks forward to 'monumental' year in 2025

I'm not very hopeful of a better change to the sport. Putting an Aussie in charge after they failed for two decades is just disgusting. What else will be brought in to weaken the game? What new rule changes will be made? How will the game be grown?


Nothing of value in this letter. There is no definitive drive towards something better. Just more of the same as usual. The most successful WC team is getting snubbed again and again for WC's hosting rights. What will make other competitions any different?


My beloved rugby is already a global sport. Why is there no SH team chosen between the Boks, AB's, Wallabies and Fiji? Like a B&I Lions team to tour Europe and America? A team that could face not only countries but also the B&I Lions? Wouldn't that make for a great spectacle that will also bring lots of eyeballs to the sport?


Instead with an Aussie in charge, rugby will become more like rugby league. Rugby will most likely become less global if we look at what have become of rugby in Australia. He can't save rugby in Australia, how will he improve the global footprint of rugby world wide?


I hope to be proven wrong and that he will raise up the sport to new heights, but I am very much in doubt. It's like hiring a gardener to a CEO position in a global company expecting great results. It just won't happen. Call me negative or call me whatever you'd like, Robinson is the wrong man for the job.

3 Go to comments
J
JW 3 hours ago
The Fergus Burke test and rugby's free market

The question that pops into my mind with Fergus Burke, and a few other high profile players in his boots right now, and also many from the past to be fair, is can the club scene start to take over this sentimentality of test footy being the highest level? Take for a moment a current, modern day scenario of Toulouse having a hiccup and failing to make this years Top 14 Final, we could end up seeing the strongest French side in History touring New Zealand next year. Why? Because at any one time they could make up over half the French side, but although that is largely avoided, it is very likely at the national teams detriment with the understanding these players have of playing together likely being stronger than the sum of the best players throughout France selected on marginal calls.


Would the pinnacle of the game really not be reached in the very near future by playing for a team like Toulouse? Burke might have put himself in a position where holding down a starting spot for any nation, but he could be putting himself in the hotbed of a new scene. Clearly he is a player that cherishes International footy as the highest level, and is possibly underselling himself, but really he might just be underselling these other nations he thinks he could represent.

Burke’s decision to test the waters with either England or Scotland has been thrown head-first into the spotlight by the relative lack of competition for the New Zealand 10 shirt.

This is the most illogical statement I've ever read in one of your articles Nick. Burke is behind 3 All Stars of All Black rugby, it might be a indictment of New Zealand rugby but it is abosolutely apparent (he might have even said so himself) why he decided to test the waters.

He mattered because he is the kind of first five-eighth New Zealand finds it most difficult to produce from its domestic set-up: the strategic schemer, the man who sees all the angles and all the bigger potential pictures with the detail of a single play.

Was it not one of your own articles that highlighted the recent All Black nature to select a running, direct threat, first five over the last decade? There are plenty of current players of Burke's caliber and style that simply don't fit the in vogue mode of what Dan Carter was in peoples minds, the five eight that ran at the slightest hole and started out as a second five. The interesting thing I find with that statement though is that I think he is firmly keeping his options open for a return to NZ.

A Kiwi product no longer belongs to New Zealand, and that is the way it is. Great credo or greater con it may be, but the free market is here to stay.

A very shortsighted and simplistic way to end a great article. You simply aren't going to find these circumstances in the future. The migration to New Zealand ended in 1975, and as that generation phases out, so too will the majority of these ancestry ties (in a rugby context) will end. It would be more accurate to say that Fergus Burke thought of himself as the last to be able to ride this wave, so why not jump on it? It is dying, and not just in the interests or Scottish of English fans.

47 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Sam Burgess' admission of guilt over rugby union experience Sam Burgess' admission of guilt over rugby union experience
Search