Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The Wayne Barnes tweet that hasn't aged well

Dublin , Ireland - 11 February 2023; Referee Wayne Barnes during the Guinness Six Nations Rugby Championship match between Ireland and France at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin. (Photo By Seb Daly/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

Referee Wayne Barnes commendably hasn’t shied away from using social media despite the massive amount of abuse received in November after he took charge of the France versus South Africa match in Marseille. That Autumn Nations Series game was the occasion when he became the world’s most capped Test referee, his 101st appointment moving him ahead of Nigel Owens.

ADVERTISEMENT

The fallout from that game which featured two red cards turned nasty on social media, resulting in the RFU shelving plans for an on-pitch half-time presentation of a referee memento to Barnes at Twickenham a fortnight later for fear that it would be marred by booing at the England-South Africa game.

It was a few weeks after in December when the 43-year-old detailed a harrowing account on The Good, the Bad & the Rugby podcast of the direct abuse aimed at his wife Polly and the threats made to their family.

Video Spacer

What makes Wayne Barnes such a unique referee in rugby

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 2:29
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 2:29
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
    • en (Main), selected
    Video Spacer

    What makes Wayne Barnes such a unique referee in rugby

    “Criticism on social media quickly becomes abuse,” said referee Barnes at the time. “That’s the world we live in. That’s social media. But I make the decision to be a referee, make the decision to be on social media. Polly, my wife, doesn’t make the decision to be a referee.

    “On the Saturday night, there started to be some direct abuse at Polly. And then, the following two or three days, there was direct abuse to Polly. Threats of sexual violence and threats against the kids. To Polly and to me, direct threats about our kids. That takes it to a different level.

    “When you have done 100 games, you have got a lot of experience and think you can prepare for most things. You can’t prepare for that. When I said it’s been a s***** couple of weeks, it’s been a s***** couple of weeks. It wasn’t even a line that was crossed – you have gone so far beyond it you can’t even see the line.”

    Having since pulled back from contemplating quitting as a referee, law firm partner Barnes was rostered last Saturday to referee his 26th Six Nations match. Ahead of that Ireland versus France clash, he tweeted a 70-second video about the application of the head contact process in rugby.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    “How does a referee decide on the degree of danger when using the head contact process in rugby union? The turtles explain all. Hope this helps with this weekend of Six Nations rugby. #ThrowTheBook.”

    That tweet went on to have nearly 100,000 views after Barnes was caught up in a major talking, his 26th-minute decision to only yellow card French prop Uini Atonio for his juddering collision with Rob Herring. Before it was confirmed on Monday that Atonio was being cited and will appear at a disciplinary hearing this Wednesday, Barnes’ tweet attracted numerous responses. Below is a selection of the debate it ignited:

    “This didn’t age too well Wayne.”

    “Thanks, Wayne. If a player leaves the field with a brain injury following an upright no-wrap ‘tackle’, what degree of danger are they likely to have been subject to would you say? Just wondering.”

    “Red all day long! Shocking decision Wayne.”

    “I believe you are one of the best refs in the game, and without refs, there is no game, so maybe commenters might ease up? That all said, having reviewed the incident post-game, would you say you’re happy with yellow? Do you expect the citing commissioners to cite Antonio?”

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Related

    “Tweet not aging spectacularly well after this game but still think Barnes is a fantastic ref.”

    “This is a timely video, Wayne, thanks for sharing. Would love to see an updated video using the turtles as an analogy for the decision in the Ireland and France game.”

    “The assistant ref’s facial expression speaks volumes.”

    “The yellow card decision was completely wrong. It was the textbook definition of a red card. I think an apology and acknowledgment of the mistake are in order. Did the TMO agree with this decision?”

    “Bad, bad call, if you want to look after players you can not let tackles like that go without a straight red card I’m afraid. All you can do now is learn from your mistakes.”

    “Good referee you are. But you must admit the call was wrong.”

    “Absolute state of the one-eyed responses to this. Well reffed, Wayne.”

    “Wayne, you should probably stay off social media for a bit and take a long hard look at yourself. You had replay after replay and still came up with the wrong card! I think you’re a good ref btw but come on, you need to make these difficult calls to protect players from injury!”

    “Ya may go back to playing with the turtles. You got it wrong. Definitely red. What does Leonardo or Donatello think?”

    “I respect you as a ref, but today’s decision was shocking. His jaw nearly came out the other side of his mouth, and your view was a low degree of danger. And then to not immediately demand a HIA. The first job of a ref is protect the player, not keep it entertaining for TV.”

    “Very little force going into the chest? Red all day. Thanks for the Lowe try, though.”

    “Was high all day with no intention to reduce his body height and there was loads of force. What was frightening was the failure of the officials to demand a HIA for a clearly dazed player, but demanding one would have questioned the validity of their card decision.”

    “You will need to be very creative to justify your yellow card v red card. It would be very refreshing.”

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Kubota Spears vs Saitama Wild Knights | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

    The gruelling reality behind one of the fastest sports in the world | The Report

    Boks Office | Episode 40 | The Steven Kitshoff Special

    Perry Baker in the house | HSBC Life on Tour | Los Angeles

    O2 Inside Line: All In | Episode 6 | Le Crunch

    The Unexpected Journey to USA 7s Glory | Aaron Cummings | Sevens Wonders

    USA vs Japan | Full Match Replay

    Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

    Confidence knocks and finding your people | Flo Williams | Rugby Rising Locker Room

    Tackling reasons for drop-out in sport | Zainab Alema | Rugby Rising Locker Room

    Jet Lag: The biggest challenge facing international sports? | The Report

    Trending on RugbyPass

    Comments

    8 Comments
    J
    JM 816 days ago

    Andrew Porter broke Retallick's cheekbone with an upright tackle that was described by Barnes as "absorbing"; where were the same whingeing Irish idiots after that decision that was subsequently cleared by the judiciary. Luck of the Irish I guess.

    W
    World 784 days ago

    What do call a guy a 1 inch dick Justin

    J
    JS 816 days ago

    "Head contact" joins "forward pass" on the list of issues Mr. Barnes struggles with.

    m
    mikejjules 817 days ago

    Ahh the Irish.... Forever victims

    B
    Ben 818 days ago

    When parents look at that decision they will not allow their kids play rugby. I never appreciated Mr Barns arrogance on the pitch. I'm sure he is a nice man, but he will never be Nigel. If we were all as negligent in our work we would be sacked. I hope Rob makes a full recover.

    J
    John 818 days ago

    Jeez the comment saying the condemnation of Barnes is one eyed is ridiculous. If an Irish player had done that, then gotten away with only a yellow card, I would still say it was a very bad decision. I suspect many other fair minded people would say the same. I wonder did Barnes watch that documentary that the England World Cup winner made about the effects of concussion on his health. It seems what was at the forefront of Barnes' mind was not to ruin the game as a contest, rather than player safety.

    M
    MM 818 days ago

    Classic example of 'solution looking for a problem' approach. Wayne's starting point was 'I am not giving a red card no matter what I see'...then started to build a scenario that delivered that solution. Mebbe forgot that he was not in the courtroom where sophistry abounds. He lessened his reputation significantly in the eyes of all fairminded people. Admit it Wayne and be a better man for doing so!

    R
    Richie 816 days ago

    Wayne Barnes’ approach to the laws are reminiscent of ‘Lord’

    Denning’s

    Load More Comments

    Join free and tell us what you really think!

    Sign up for free
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Latest Features

    Comments on RugbyPass

    R
    Rafel Olszewski 5 hours ago
    'Frankly insulting': The 2 clear trends in Lions' squad reactions

    The Initial Coin Offering (ICO) I invested in appeared flawless, its website was sleek and authentic, the whitepaper was detailed and convincing, and the team boasted impressive credentials in cryptocurrency.I was eager to capitalize on a golden opportunity. Confident in my research, I invested $200,000, only to watch in horror as the entire operation vanished days later. Just as I was resigning myself to the loss, I discovered Muyern Trust Hacker by searching online ( web: ht tps://muyerntrusthacker . o r g /  ). Taking a leap of faith, I reached out, and from the very first interaction, their team stood out for their professionalism and urgency. Their experts meticulously followed the digital trail across multiple wallets and exchanges, leaving no stone unturned. After a week of relentless effort, they achieved the impossible: $175,000 was recovered. While not the full amount, it was a staggering victory considering I had assumed everything was lost forever. The relief was indescribable. Thanks to Muyern Trust Hacker,  I could repay a significant portion of what I owed my mother and regain some financial stability. This has taught me a harsh lesson about the risks of crypto investments but it also showed me the power of expert intervention. For anyone who has fallen victim to a scam, Muyern Trust Hacker ( Tele gr am: muyerntrusthackertech ) is the rescue team in an otherwise bleak situation. Their recovery services turned my crypto disaster into a second chance.

    9 Go to comments
    R
    Rafel Olszewski 5 hours ago
    Ilona Maher drops biggest retirement hint yet after loss to Canada

    The Initial Coin Offering (ICO) I invested in appeared flawless, its website was sleek and authentic, the whitepaper was detailed and convincing, and the team boasted impressive credentials in cryptocurrency.I was eager to capitalize on a golden opportunity. Confident in my research, I invested $200,000, only to watch in horror as the entire operation vanished days later. Just as I was resigning myself to the loss, I discovered Muyern Trust Hacker by searching online ( web: ht tps://muyerntrusthacker . o r g /  ). Taking a leap of faith, I reached out, and from the very first interaction, their team stood out for their professionalism and urgency. Their experts meticulously followed the digital trail across multiple wallets and exchanges, leaving no stone unturned. After a week of relentless effort, they achieved the impossible: $175,000 was recovered. While not the full amount, it was a staggering victory considering I had assumed everything was lost forever. The relief was indescribable. Thanks to Muyern Trust Hacker,  I could repay a significant portion of what I owed my mother and regain some financial stability. This has taught me a harsh lesson about the risks of crypto investments but it also showed me the power of expert intervention. For anyone who has fallen victim to a scam, Muyern Trust Hacker ( Tele gr am: muyerntrusthackertech ) is the rescue team in an otherwise bleak situation. Their recovery services turned my crypto disaster into a second chance.

    3 Go to comments
    LONG READ
    LONG READ Mick Cleary: 'Many Lions might have opted for the safe route - not Maro Itoje' Mick Cleary: 'Many Lions might have opted for the safe route - not Maro Itoje'
    Search