Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'They played no rugby': Ex-All Blacks at loggerheads over historic loss to Pumas

New Zealand regroup during The Rugby Championship match between the New Zealand All Blacks and Argentina Pumas at Orangetheory Stadium on August 27, 2022 in Christchurch, New Zealand. (Photo by Joe Allison/Getty Images)

Former All Black wingers Jeff Wilson and John Kirwan have got into a heated debate over the latest loss to Argentina in Christchurch.

ADVERTISEMENT

The pair could not on agree on Sky Sport NZ’s The Breakdown over who had control of the test match with Wilson arguing that the All Blacks conceded the game through ill-discipline despite having a hold over proceedings.

The former right wing admitted he had trouble sleeping after watching the loss in Christchurch, the sixth defeat in the last eight tests for the All Blacks.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

“I’m at a bit of a loss, I really am,” Wilson told The Breakdown panel.

“I look at the key moments in the game and we are not winning those right now.

“We were in control of that test match, we were up by six points, we miss a single kick-off which leads to them going in front.

“In the first half we were in control of that test match. The only opportunities they were getting to score points were from our ill-discipline.”

John Kirwan quickly interjected to refute Wilson’s idea that New Zealand had control of the test after heading into the sheds with a slim 15-12 lead.

“I disagree, we weren’t in control, we were never in control,” Kirwan said.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We weren’t in control of the scoreboard because you’ve got to be fifteen points ahead of any team to be in control now.

“I just don’t think we were in control, if you are playing Argentina. What was the score at halftime?”

Wilson reiterated his position that because Argentina did not have possession in position to attack for tries, they were never threatening but Kirwan wasn’t having any of it.

“Because we allowed them through our ill-discipline to score in threes but they weren’t threatening our goal line,” he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

“They never looked like scoring tries against the All Blacks.”

“I don’t care mate,” Kirwan retorted.

“They were outstanding, they were outstanding at the breakdown and they put us under so much pressure.”

Wilson: “They played no rugby and we allowed them into it.

Kirwan: “Who cares?”

The former Blues coach put the loss into the wider context of where the All Blacks are currently at and said that the Ellis Park win was not an instant fix.

“I think we all got carried away with one win [in South Africa]. It was an amazing win done on courage and passion and commitment,” he said.

“But if you are wobbling, you can’t change things that quickly. For me there is still a disconnect between the NZR and the players.

“I come back to three things that Ian Foster needs to look at: selection, our kicking game, our attacking kicking game when you are playing a team like Argentina.

“If you looked at that game yesterday, it was exactly the same loss that we had last time [in 2020].

“So under pressure, what is happening with our leadership. Our practising under pressure our decision-making because it looked a little bit like ‘wow’ yesterday and we made some really critical errors under pressure.”

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

11 Comments
E
Emery Ambrose 842 days ago

I think we could have even had it in the final ten, we organised to destroy the scrum twice and get penalties then a lineout close, then an individual player did not execute his role twice.
Should not have in that position in the first place, but it was there to claim.

J
Jmann 842 days ago

Wilson was bang on. Many of the brawn over skill teams realise that playing rugby is too dangerous in test rugby and play for territory and kicks at goal. SA are ,masters at it. England were for years, and it has been noticeable with Argentina for a while.

Rugby as a sport is in deep trouble. Kick chase is boring. The refs have far too much say, the situation with cards is a nonsense and the state of refs from the NH is a joke.

If the world's greatest ever rugby nation is struggling... well. think about it

H
Hybridly 842 days ago

How arrogant and ignorant is Jeff Wilson saying “they play no rugby” . Jeff Wilson , you better apologize to the rugby community. Who do think you are ? Argentina put pressure on you and you didn’t know how to deal with it. All blacks didn’t play bad at all but the pumas were better. That comment made you look so ignorant like a cave man.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

T
Tom 5 hours ago
Will Bristol's daredevil 'Bears-ball' deliver the trophy they crave?

Also a Bristol fan and echo your sentiments.


I love watching Bristol but their approach will only get them so far I think. Exeter played like this when they first got promoted to the prem and had intermittent success, it wasn't until they wised up and played a more balanced game that they became a consistently top side.


I really want Bristol to continue playing this brand of rugby and I don't mind them running it from under their posts but I don't think they need to do it every single time. They need to be just a little bit more selective about when and where on the pitch they play. Every game they put themselves under so much needless pressure by turning the ball over under their posts trying to do kamikaze moves when it's not required. By all means run it from your goal line if there is a chance for a counter attack, we all want to see Bristol running in 100m tries from under their posts but I think until they learn when to do it and when to be pragmatic, they are unlikely to win the premiership.


Defense has been a real positive from Bristol, they've shown a lot of improvement there... And I will say that I think this kamikaze strategy they employ is a very good one for a struggling side and could be employed by Newcastle. It's seems to have turned around Gloucester's fortunes. The big advantage is even if you don't have the biggest and best players, what you have is cohesion. This is why Scotland keep battering England. England have better individuals but they look muddled as a team, trying to play a mixed strategy under coaches who lack charisma, the team has no identity. Scotland come out and give it full throttle from 1-15 even if they struggle against the top sides, sides like England and Wales who lack that identity drown under the relentless will and synergy of the Scots. If Newcastle did the same they could really surprise some people, I know the weather is bad up there but it hasn't bothered the Scots. Bristol can learn from Scotland too, Pat is on to something when he says the following but Scotland don't play test matches like headless chickens. They still play with the same level of clarity and ambition Bristol do but they are much better at picking their moments. They needed to go back to this mad game to get their cohesion back after a couple of seasons struggling but I hope they get a bit wiser from matches like Leinster and La Rochelle.


“If there’s clarity on what you’re trying to do as a team you can win anything.”

2 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Return of 30-something brigade provides welcome tonic for Wales Return of 30-something brigade provides welcome tonic for Wales
Search