Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'They should be working together': All Blacks legend Sir John Kirwan slams ex-Wallabies for Raelene Castle criticism

(Photo by Kai Schwoerer/Getty Images)

John Kirwan has denounced the ex-Wallabies calling for the head of Rugby Australia boss Raelene Castle, saying former All Blacks would never air dirty laundry in public.

Kirwan also launched a fierce defence of Kiwi compatriot Castle, saying 17 years of ongoing mismanagement is to blame for RA’s teetering financial state.

Former Wallabies Rod Kafer and Nick Farr-Jones have been critical of Castle in the past week since the chief executive revealed the chasm the organisation finds itself in.

A group of former Wallabies are reportedly agitating for change, with Phil Kearns believed to be a favoured replacement as CEO. Former Wallabies captain Kearns has denied having designs on the top spot.

Ex-All Blacks winger Kirwan said he could barely fathom why a sport would want to overthrow its boss while the impact of the coronavirus pandemic is so acute.

“They should be working together. As ex-All Blacks, we very rarely go outside with our criticism before we’ve said it inside,” Kirwan told Sky TV‘s The Breakdown programme.

“Getting attacked by so many people, it must be a pretty lonely place for her.

“Some of these famous ex-Wallabies maybe need to knock on her door or have a Zoom, and just say ‘these are my concerns and these are my solutions’.”

Kirwan said blaming Castle was a “cop-out” given the gradual deterioration of the sport in Australia since 2003, when it reaped enormous revenue by staging the Rugby World Cup after cutting New Zealand out of the co-hosting.

That was also the last year Australia held the Bledisloe Cup.

“I know we’re going a long way back but they were one of the wealthiest unions in the world,” Kirwan said.

“What has happened to the development of the game, for the game as a whole?

“We’re seeing Waratahs teams that don’t have a strong bench. There’s a whole lot wrong.”

Castle has come under intense scrutiny over her handling of the Israel Folau affair which played a big part in a heavy financial loss for 2019.

Kirwan believed she handled a delicate situation as well as possible and her experienced leadership would be needed to ride out the ravages of Covid-19.

“How can you even be talking about sacking your CEO during a world crisis? I don’t even get that,” he said.

“We need our Australian brothers, we need Australian rugby really strong.”

– AAP

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

R
RW 1 hour ago
Everyone knows the Springboks' ranking was juiced

Ah yes, as soon as I saw the article headline I knew dear Ol' BS was going to spout his BS again. What he fails to realise is that, firstly this isn't a World Cup year so Rassie isn't particularly worried.

Secondly Rassie and Springboks and fans don't care much about the World Rankings because it is a joke. Yes Ireland won a long streak of games but they can't win that elusive WC they have been striving for. The reason that the World Cup gives extra points is because everyone wants to be able to lift that cup. The satisfaction and pride of being able to lift that trophy has been the Springboks' for four times now, thrice to All Blacks, twice to Wallabies and once to England. Where does Ireland feature? Where has France been? Neither team has the BTT or Big Tournament Temperament. Ireland never having won a playoff match. You might call it luck or fluke but like you said and I quote "It takes sustained winning over a rival to proclaim one’s superiority" Ireland just don't have the stamina. They proven themselves to flop when the game matters the most. It's easier to win when the stakes are lower, the pressure is lower and not much rides upon the result. It takes another level of endurance and stamina to play and win three play-off matches in a row and win.


You call it luck because Springboks won but what if either France England or ABs had beaten us by one point. Would that have been luck or top quality skill to down the reigning champions?


Also to win one game by one point is luck, to do it twice is skill, but to do it three times is master strategy.


Because Benny ol' fruit all you see is the score, but what you fail to realise is that there was massive psychological games happening there. The way Rassie planned his play style against France differed drastically against England, and then also against New Zealand. If you don't believe me watch Squidge Rugby's analysis of each play off match on Y0uTube.


It was an entire mastermind. Also he knew he had a top quality Bomb Squad that he had planned to play with throughout each play-off match.


Lastly, Rassie doesn't mind losing mid season matches if it means he properly prepares for the next World Cup. Because that way you give your teams rest and figure who are the best combinations to play with and for what opponent.


Rassie doesn't put too much faith on each match although he will always want to win. He is more interested in figuring out how to be innovative for the next WC. Whereas France and Ireland seek to win each game, they inevitably sacrifice learning, blooding good players and rest for longest win streaks. Neither team has ever won a World Cup and as such have to work much harder to reach #1 and even harder to retain it.


Also sidenote, World Rankings setup is a joke. It hardly accounts for what is actually happening.


Sorry BS, you are not givings us facts, you are giving us rantings. It's your hot air and not much light scenario.

118 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Why Rassie Erasmus should cull some Boks veterans for 2027 Why Rassie Erasmus should cull some Boks veterans for 2027
Search