Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Wallabies reject uncontested scrum claims against Boks

Captain Allan Ala’alatoa and fellow prop Angus Bell were both forced off at half-time with replacement James Slipper following them in the second half (Photo Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Senior Wallabies prop Allan Alaalatoa has rubbished allegations that they faked front-row injuries to avoid scrummaging against South Africa in their recent Rugby Championship Test in Perth.

ADVERTISEMENT

SA Rugby has reportedly made a request to World Rugby to investigate Australia’s injuries that led to uncontested scrums after the Wallabies lost all three props – Angus Bell, James Slipper and Alaalatoa – during the match.

Bell suffered a cut above his eye and Alaalatoa failed a head injury assessment (HIA), with both not returning after halftime. Slipper then also suffered a head knock.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Match officials deemed the lack of props meant it was no longer safe to continue with contested scrums.

Slipper’s exit occurred just after Springboks coach Rassie Erasmus turned to the “bomb squad” – bringing on Rugby World Cup-winning forwards Ox Nche and Malcolm Marx – leading to the allegations.

The South Africans still triumphed easily, running over the top of the Wallabies in the second half for a 30-12 scoreline.

Ahead of their second Test against the Pumas in Argentina, Alaalatoa said his team wanted to scrum against the world No.1 side and considered it a strength.

ADVERTISEMENT

Indeed, the Wallabies’ scrum success rate in the tournament is 95.7 per cent, exactly 10 per cent higher than the Springboks.

“Do they think I was trying to fake an HIA or something?” Alaalatoa asked after being made aware of the report.

“Mate, we want to scrum, that’s what we want to do, especially as front-rowers, and that’s a game where you want to take on that challenge, you don’t want to shy away from that.

“We’re at a stage in our team where we want to keep growing and keep fronting up against the best, so you never want to shy away from that.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Among the players to have led the Wallabies this year, Alaalatoa said he’d never seen a run of injuries like it in his 72 Test caps.

With replacement hooker Josh Nasser also forced off, leaving the team temporarily with 14 players, coach Joe Schmidt described the situation as “bizarre”.

“I remember Joe (Schmidt) at the end of that game saying he’s never been a part of that game where things like that have happened, and I don’t think I have as well,” Alaalatoa said.

The Wallabies take on the Pumas in Santa Fe in northeast Argentina looking for back-to-back victories after a 20-19 thriller in La Plata.

Alaalatoa said the tourists took some confidence from a win over the Pumas, who shocked New Zealand in the opening round, pleased with their patience and endeavour.

He said their poor restarts throughout the match had been a focus for improvement at training this week.

“That’s definitely an area of growth for us,” the 30-year-old Brumbies skipper said.

“Maybe the weather had something to do with that, but also a communication thing between the (forward) pod and our wingers there, but definitely an area we need to improve.”

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

5 Comments
M
Mitch 108 days ago

Well said, Allan. Unfortunately, the perception that Australia wants to depower scrums is what has enabled some people to form the view that Australia manipulated the laws to get uncontested scrums. Anybody who believes Australia gamed the system to get uncontested scrums, come to the table with irrefutable evidence.

T
Terry24 108 days ago

There is no substantiation for Erasmus' claim and no chance of proving it. He knows Australia didn't do this. He doesn't want uncontested scrums so he is throwing shade hoping for a change in subs rules that will eliminate the possibility of incontested scrums. He should just say that instead of throwing dirt at players and other teams.

J
JK 108 days ago

Props are among the toughest players on the field normally...

J
JD 109 days ago

If it's white, quacks and looks like a duck, it's almost certainly a duck. I remember that they also denied sandpapering the cricket ball. Nobody will ultimately know the truth, but if I were to bet, I'd give pretty long odds that they engineered the uncontested scrum saga.

O
OJohn 108 days ago

We have a kiwi coach so a cunning attempt to cheat wouldn't be surprising would it ?

Do they have a point about the protocol about standing down after HIA ?

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

G
GrahamVF 1 hour ago
Does South Africa have a future in European competition?

"has SA actually EVER helped to develop another union to maturity like NZ has with Japan," yes - Argentina. You obviously don't know the history of Argentinian rugby. SA were touring there on long development tours in the 1950's

We continued the Junior Bok tours to the Argentine through to the early 70's

My coach at Grey High was Giepie Wentzel who toured Argentine as a fly half. He told me about how every Argentinian rugby club has pictures of Van Heerden and Danie Craven on prominent display. Yes we have developed a nation far more than NZ has done for Japan. And BTW Sa players were playing and coaching in Japan long before the Kiwis arrived. Fourie du Preez and many others were playing there 15 years ago.


"Isaac Van Heerden's reputation as an innovative coach had spread to Argentina, and he was invited to Buenos Aires to help the Pumas prepare for their first visit to South Africa in 1965.[1][2] Despite Argentina faring badly in this tour,[2] it was the start of a long and happy relationship between Van Heerden and the Pumas. Izak van Heerden took leave from his teaching post in Durban, relocated to Argentina, learnt fluent Spanish, and would revolutionise Argentine play in the late 1960s, laying the way open for great players such as Hugo Porta.[1][2] Van Heerden virtually invented the "tight loose" form of play, an area in which the Argentines would come to excel, and which would become a hallmark of their playing style. The Pumas repaid the initial debt, by beating the Junior Springboks at Ellis Park, and emerged as one of the better modern rugby nations, thanks largely to the talents of this Durban schoolmaster.[1]"


After the promise made by Junior Springbok manager JF Louw at the end of a 12-game tour to Argentina in 1959 – ‘I will do everything to ensure we invite you to tour our country’ – there were concerns about the strength of Argentinian rugby. South African Rugby Board president Danie Craven sent coach Izak van Heerden to help the Pumas prepare and they repaid the favour by beating the Junior Springboks at Ellis Park.

158 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Does the next Wallabies coach have to be an Australian? Does the next Wallabies coach have to be an Australian?
Search