Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Welsh clubs face daunting task this weekend amid crisis

Dai Young /Press Association

The four Welsh clubs will head to South Africa for the resumption of the Vodacom United Rugby Championship eager to salvage some of the pride that was battered by the national team’s unexpected loss to Georgia at the weekend.

ADVERTISEMENT

Wales, a week after beating the Argentina Pumas but just a fortnight after a chastening hammering by the All Blacks, who posted more than 50 points against them in Cardiff, lost at home to the Eastern European nation on Saturday, the first time they have done so.

The defeat brought back references to the dark days of Welsh rugby in the 1990s, which featured an almost 100 point demolition at the hands of South Africa in Pretoria in 1998 as well as seismic World Cup loss to Western Samoa.

With the loss to Georgia featuring in the same year as the Welsh lost at home to Italy, there are big questions being asked about not just the Welsh team and the future of national coach Wayne Pivac, but also the state of the club game. Wales did salvage some pride after the Italy defeat that ended a miserable Six Nations campaign by winning the middle test in their three game series in South Africa, their first ever success against the Springboks on South African soil, but the recent sequence of results has edged Wales back towards crisis point.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

The Welsh media and ex-players have got stuck into the team, with former Bok World Cup winning wing Bryan Habana, in Wales as a television pundit, joining the fray by suggesting that veteran lock and British and Irish Lions captain Alun Wyn Jones should be recalled to the Wales captaincy.

But many of the post-mortems have gone much further, probing into the state of the club game in Wales. The current international results certainly aren’t out of kilter with what has been happening with the Welsh club teams competing in the URC, with no Welsh team managing last year to get into the top eight of the inaugural competition and because of that there was no Welsh representation in the play-off phase.

A curve ball for the Welsh teams this week is that they will all be traveling to South Africa with key players missing to international duty, with the under-pressure Pivac sure to want all hands on deck as his team prepares to play the final game of the autumn international season against Australia in Cardiff on Saturday.

Australia will have been decimated by injuries and club calls – the game falls outside the international window – but that should make it even more crucial for Wales to get a much needed victory to ease the pressure. Of the 35 players Pivac called up for squad duty at the start of November, 15 players were from the Ospreys, seven from the Scarlets, five from Cardiff and three from the Dragons.

ADVERTISEMENT

So the Ospreys, who have the tough task of going to altitude to face the Bulls, will consider themselves to be up against it, and the Scarlets too as they go to Cape Town to face the champions on Friday night.

Fortunately for the Scarlets, the Stormers should be considerably weakened by their representation in the Bok squad that is currently in London preparing for Saturday’s clash with England at Twickenham. John Dobson’s men have though shown signs of impressive growth of squad depth recently and the Stormers might welcome this opportunity to give fringe players a run ahead of a tough December and January that will feature a clutch of crucial derby fixtures over the festive season as well as their entry into the European Champions Cup competition for the first time.

The Bulls don’t have as many Boks these days as either the Stormers or the Cell C Sharks, with the latter team set to be part of a Sunday double header which in addition to their game against Cardiff in Durban will also feature the Emirates Lions against the Dragons in Johannesburg earlier in the afternoon.

Credit: URCSA

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

T
Tom 1 hour ago
England player ratings vs South Africa | 2024 Autumn Nations Series

That 2019 performance was literally the peak in attacking rugby under Eddie. If you thought that was underwhelming, the rest of it was garbage.


I totally get what you're saying and England don't need or have any God given right to the best coaches in the world... But I actually think the coaches we do have are quite poor and for the richest union in the world, that's not good enough. 


England are competitive for sure but with the talent pool up here and the funds available, we should be in the top 3. At the very least we should be winning six nations titles on a semi-regular basis. If Ireland can, England definitely should.


England's attack coach (Richard Wigglesworth) is Borthwick's mate from his playing days at Saracens, who he brought to Leicester with him when he became coach. Wigglesworth was a 9 who had no running or passing game, but was the best box kicker in the business. He has no credentials to be an attack coach and I've seen nothing to prove otherwise. Aside from Marcus Smith’s individual brilliance, our collective attack has looked very uninspiring.

 

England's defence coach (Joe El-Abd) is Borthwick's housemate from uni, who has never been employed as a defence coach before. He's doing the job part time while he's still the head coach of a team in the second division of French rugby who have an awful defensive record. England's defence has gone from being brutally efficient under Felix Jones to as leaky as a colander almost overnight.


If Borthwick brings in a new attack and defence coach then I'll absolutely get behind him but his current coaches seem to be the product of nepotism. He's brought in people he's comfortable with because he lacks confidence as an international head coach and they aren't good enough for international rugby.


England are competitive because they do some things really well, mostly they front up physically, make a lot of big hits, have a solid kicking game, a good lineout, good maul, Marcus Smith and some solid forwards. A lot of what we do well I would ascribe to Borthwick personally. I don't think he's a bad coach, I think he lacks imagination and is overly risk averse. He needs coaches who will bring a point of difference.


I guess my point is, yes England are competitive, but we’re not aiming for competitive and I honestly don't believe this coaching setup has what it takes to make us any better than competitive.


On the plus side it looks like we have an amazing crop of young players coming through. Some of them who won the u20 world cup played for England A against Australia A on the weekend and looked incredible... Check out the highlights on youtube.

12 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING What Joe Schmidt said to Warren Gatland before thumping Wales What Schmidt said to Gatland before thumping Wales
Search