Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

What Exeter make of Joe Simmonds the sub and not the starting No10

(Photo by Bob Bradford/CameraSport via Getty Images)

Rob Baxter has given his perspective about the delicate situation that has seen skipper Joe Simmonds only chosen on the Exeter bench in recent weeks following a disappointing start to the new Gallagher Premiership season. It wasn’t that long ago when there were demands that the 24-year-old was deserving of a call-up to Eddie Jones’ England squad.

ADVERTISEMENT

That hype has since been diluted, Marcus Smith winning their head-to-head battle in last June’s Premiership final and the Harlequins No10 has since gone on to play for England and the Lions. Meanwhile, Simmonds has unexpectedly slipped down the pecking order at the Chiefs. 

Whereas this time last year he was expertly leading them to Premiership and Champions Cup title glory when the delayed 2019/20 season was eventually played to a conclusion, Simmonds has now lost his place in his club’s starting line-up following the September league defeats to Leicester and Northampton.

Video Spacer

Jonny Hill guests on the RugbyPass Offload

Video Spacer

Jonny Hill guests on the RugbyPass Offload

Baxter has since elected to go with the 23-year-old Harvey Skinner as his starting No10 in the successive wins over Sale, Worcester and Wasps. It is a considerable shake-up given that Skinner had only started in six of his previous 21 league appearances until this season and it has left Simmonds with fewer minutes on the field this term compared to his emerging rival for the Exeter starting spot (192 minutes to 243). 

Having benched Scotland captain Stuart Hogg for last June’s Premiership final and semi-final, Exeter coach Baxter isn’t shy in demoting star players to the Chiefs bench but he is liking the response that Simmonds has shown as a replacement in the wins that have helped the team climb to fourth in the Premiership following their awkward start.   

“He [Simmonds] has been very good, has been very good in meetings,” reported Baxter about his benched captain and No10. “He has certainly carried on being productive in the things he has done in and around training, his interaction with players have been very good. If anything he is probably stepping up that part of his game. 

“He is one hundred per cent ready to go and actually all his contributions off the bench so far have been very good so he is on form as well in an odd kind of way. He has been left out of the team but he is actually on form if you watch him play. We have got a great couple of options there and we are just very pleased with how they are both going.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s what you want – when you make a change you want that guy to play well and you want to win and that is exactly what has happened. Harvey has been reaping the rewards of that, he has been reaping the rewards of playing well himself and the team has been functioning well around him and that is all it is. When Joe is in a similar position we have stuck with Joe, but that doesn’t mean we are not open to making the odd change as well,” continued Baxter, who has since recalled Simmonds to the starting line-up for this Saturday’s game at home to London Irish.

“The one thing is when a player does step up to lead the team in positions like ten, especially when they are a younger player, sometimes it is good to give him a breather every now and again and try and keep everything on a real positive curve for them, almost give them a breather before a loss happens so to speak. So we are still considering that as well and we know Joe is a very good player, merits all the selections he has previously and will merit all the selections he has in the future as well.”

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 20 minutes ago
Scott Robertson explains the new halves pairing for the All Blacks ahead of France

More indecision and excuses from Razor.


You've given a spot at 6 to Finau whom you haven't even had the courage to use off the bench in the last two games. Now the young enforcer is going into a big much with no rugby, we should expect a similar result to how Aumua struggled to impact a game after he'd hardly been given any chances of the bench either.


Weve now dropped a back three player who also wasn't even given any game time off the bench for someone coming in cold when they really need to have been playing constantly to perform at their best. There are just so many better pictures that should have been present rather than this mickey mouse selection.


I really hope Finau can overcome this, it won't be the first time he's had to. How is the bench even made up? Could you not just have included these changes in the article as well? I actually like BB coming back in, it highlights how courageous he is after sitting out through another concussion that could just as easily sent him back into months of symptoms again.


Dmac was also off his game last week, as was Ratima, with the poor platform Razor and his team have been setting the players up with. He needs to freedom to clear his mind from the clutter that saw him make so many bad decisions last week. It will still probably be a net loss for the team performance not having him on from the start but it should be better for them in the long run if he's allowed to just come on late and play his game trying to claw things back for the team.


With Roigard starting that might prove an outlet for the team to actually get on top first however. Along with Ardie busting a gut in his new role and emptying the tank by halftime, and being replaced by another new star, might mean that Dmac is just icing on the cake at the end.

12 Go to comments
F
Flankly 46 minutes ago
Jake White: If I was England coach, I’d have been livid

I am not an England fan, but still very disappointed at what Borthwick is serving up. Regardless of winning or losing, they should be executing the basics at a world class level. That was the reason they replaced Eddie with Steve. After two years England has not built the solid foundations that the RFU were presumably after. Its hard to see it as anything other than a coaching problem.


Having said that I really hope that Rassie has got his team fired up for the game. The Boks at maximum intensity and with no crises (eg red cards) would be expected to win this game. But it does not take much reduction in pressure for Bok teams to lose. The Boks lose when complacency sets in.


On Felix Jones, my guess is that they can't agree on a non-compete so they kept him on payroll for the duration of the Nov tests. The risk was that he would be hired by Rassie or Razor prior to the tests.


As relates to law tweaking, it feels like WR are more comfortable discussing changes in laws than insisting on implementation. For my money the biggest thing they could do is to be strict and consistent in officiating ruck behavior. In every game we see flopping, lazy lying, clearing of unbound players, making plays while off your feet, delays in placing the ball, side entry, offside line infringements, and similar nonsense. It's really really bad, and the WR attitude seems to be that we should turn a blind eye in pursuit of "flowing rugby". In truth it's just boring, because it randomizes the outcome.

9 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Wales 'in one of their deepest holes for a long time' Wales 'in one of their deepest holes for a long time'
Search