1
What Sam Cane's All Blacks recall means for his fellow flankers
By Ned Lester
Former New Zealand captain Sam Cane is back in black in Scott Robertson’s Rugby Championship squad, a selection that has raised some questions over the current crop’s performances.
ADVERTISEMENT
Six flankers made the July Series squad and when push came to shove it was Dalton Papali’i backed for Cane’s No. 7 jersey against England. Samipeni Finau started at blindside and Luke Jacobson provided impact off the bench.
Of course, it was reigning World Rugby Player of the Year Ardie Savea holding down the back of the scrum at No. 8, one of the few players whose jersey is all but guaranteed in the starting XV.
Cane’s reintroduction to the squad was celebrated by Robertson on Sunday, with the coach exclaiming “It’s great to have the sheriff back!” When appearing on The Breakdown.
He went on to praise the standards Cane drives within camp.
Former All Black Israel Dagg voiced his thoughts on the selection when asked this week, saying Cane enables the best version of those around him, specifically Savea.
Prompting Dagg’s thoughts was a thought from pundit Scotty Stevenson, who questioned whether the coaches had seen what they wanted from the loose forward trio in the opening three Tests of the year.
“I’m not surprised by this and I fully back the decision,” Stevenson said on SENZ. “But, is this an indication that neither (Dalton) Papali’i, (Luke) Jacobson or (Ethan) Blackadder have quite owned that No. 7 jersey? That the All Blacks are after quicker ball? That they need someone in there that can dominate both sides of the ball, both on attack with his cleanout work – Cane’s probably the best cleaning seven I think in New Zealand still – and then defensively around the ruck and that big stat that we talk about so often, back in game, and Sam Cane does that so well.
ADVERTISEMENT
“They want quick ball. Scott Robertson bemoaned the fact that England tried to slow their ball down during that two-Test series here in New Zealand. Absolutely they do, every team tries to do that against the All Blacks so we need the players who can get in there and generate that quick ruck ball. Is that part of the reason Sam Cane is back?”
Dagg agreed with the diagnosis and went on to question when we might see Cane back on the field.
“That’s 100 per cent it, Sumo,” he replied. “You spoke about it a lot; Ardie Savea, in those two Tests, wasn’t able to have the impact – yes it could have been a lot of points around maybe coming back from Japan, having played less rugby, having tired legs, but you look at him against the Fijians and you had Ethan Blackadder who was immense, big in that performance, and Luke Jacobson, they do the hard yards. They get in there, they make their tackles, they’re very good around the park, and they run hard. That allows Ardie to focus on his other roles, core roles, and that’s what Sam Cane does.
“Sam Cane, he’s not really a big TV time player like you’ve alluded to, but he comes in, brings experience, tackles his heart out. For me, it’s where does Sam Cane come into it? How do they ease him into this All Blacks outfit?
ADVERTISEMENT
“They’ve got Argentina, are they going to just throw him into the fold after two club rugby matches? I don’t think so. I think it’s more of an easing transition for Sam Cane but we’ll have to wait and see.
“There’s going to be winners, there’s going to be losers and there’s going to be debates.”
I’ve been a harsh cane critic over the years . Cause he hasn’t been the same since his injuries and concussions . But if he can find form and play like he did against the Irish . Even if he comes off the bench and does it for 20-30 minutes consistently.
He could be a super sub upfront. Wishful thinking … but hoping for the best .
“The standards Cane drives within camp.”
That's probably the key phrase. The new players will learn a lot from him.
Keep Daltz at 7, best tackler in NZ, test match animal. He can play more open if others do their jobs with more go o forward than we saw against England. Cane past his best a long time ago
‘Blackadder immense in that performance’? Really? Hope they stick with Papali’i - his tackles basically neutered Ben Earls, one of England’s biggest attacking weapons. Papali’i can carry powerfully, but the ABs seldom played over the top of England and he was needed in the trenches. Also like Razor to persevere with Finau and use him more in the line-out, instead of Savea up front - Ardie was too easily closed out by Itoje. Sam Cane’s real value might be off-field, unless there are injuries.
Spot on for all
Yep on the money with all your points
Good comment and on the money.
I think that Cane will be the bench loose forward in the Argentina tests with 6 Luke Jacobson, 7 Ethan Blackadder, and 8 Ardie Savea.
Papalii makes a lot of tackles. However he just does not make enough involvements on the attacking side of the game- no ball carries, no short passes to forwards or pull passes out the back to the backs, no linking out wide with the backs.
And Samipeni Fineau looks completely lost on both sides of the ball- no dominant tackles, no dominant carries over the gainline. Too early to give up on him but he needs to buy his time until All Blacks play Japan and Italy later in the year.
Blackadder should be playing NPC
“Papalii makes a lot of tackles”
Indeed usually the teams top tackler often with no misses
Enough said
Oh and throw in the odd intercept try like against wales …
Finau is the one who needs to massively up his game
He’s an athlete so let’s see it
I want him to become a great 6 too but agree with your comments. He did look lost against England and I’d debate any stat that says he was our top tackler. As someone else said, Frizzell took a couple of seasons for people to believe in him. Here’s hoping Finau can do likewise, but he needs to show a lot more very soon.
Final literally made the most tackles out of everyone in the two tests also a 6s job isn’t to attack that’s an 8s job 6 on attack is the cleaner most of the time not a single loose forward playedvwell against England not even savea played well
I hope not.
I hope they stick with the guys who started against England or move Savea to 7 and Sititi to 8.
Finau has done enough to keep his position with those two wins against England and we’ll need his height in the lineout against the Boks. His development needs to continue. There’s no long term future at 6 for any of the other guys in the squad.
The wins against England should not be underestimated.
It seems they want him there more as a player coach, which might work well for them. It would be a nice story for him to get “revenge” against the Boks, but we accept the challenge and we will be ready I’m sure. It will be a cracker of a game at Ellis Park that’s certain.