Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Where are they now? – France 2019 Junior World Championship

France's Mattias Haddad kisses the trophy in 2019 (Photo by Rodrigo Valle/Getty Images)

It’s hard to fathom that it was 2019 when the last full-on Junior World Championship was held, but that is about to change later this month when the best of the current U20s players from around the globe assemble in South Africa for matches in Stellenbosch, Paarl and Cape Town from June 24.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ireland will travel as the recently crowned Six Nations champions, but it is France who will arrive as the reigning World Championship champions given that the cup is still theirs following their nerve-shredding June 2019 win over Australia in the final.

The lead changed hands no fewer than seven times in Rosario before France out-half Louis Carbonel eventually kicked what proved to be the winning penalty with 15 minutes to go at the Racecourse Stadium.

Video Spacer

U20 Highlights AUS vs NZL | The Breakdown

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:56
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:56
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
    • en (Main), selected
    Video Spacer

    U20 Highlights AUS vs NZL | The Breakdown

    That 24-23 triumph allowed the French to become the third country to win back-to-back U20s titles, following in the footsteps of New Zealand, who went four in a row from 2008 to 2011, and England, who topped the charts in 2013 and again in 2014.

    Carbonel had been the star for France in their 2018 final win over England and his 14 points off the kicking tee in the Argentinian decider were crucial in getting the better of an Australian side that scored the second-fastest try in U20 Championship final history, Mark Nawaqanitawase diving over after only 49 seconds.

    France Junior World Championship 2019
    France celebrate their 2019 Junior World Championship title win (Photo by Marcelo Endelli/World Rugby via Getty Images)

    The lockdown restrictions caused by the pandemic prevented the Junior World Championship from being staged in 2020, 2021 and 2022, but it will now thankfully return and it is pleasing to note the progress of the title-winning French squad in the meantime.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Six of the XV that started the 2019 final and one sub have progressed to Test-level rugby, a half-dozen with France and another with Portugal, and all 27 squad members listed for the decider are playing professionally four years later – mostly in the Top 14. Here is their story:

    15. Matthis Lebel
    Had already made seven Top 14 appearances for Toulouse by the time of this age-grade tournament and has since gone on to make the No11 jersey his own at the club, playing an integral part in their 2021 league and Heineken Champions Cup double. Hasn’t progressed as smoothly with France. Just five Test caps, his most recent start coming in November 2021.

    14. Vincent Pinto
    Another who was already making his way in the Top 14 prior to this tournament, Pau giving him his debut, but his progress has been limited. This past season, for instance, there were just two starts in the league. In the meantime, he has since declared for Portugal and is looking to gain selection in their Rugby World Cup squad having appeared off the bench in their play-off win over the USA last November in Dubai.

    13. Arthur Vincent
    Another who was already playing first-team rugby when he skippered these U20s to World Championship glory. Still at Montpellier but ruptured knee ligaments at the start of the 2021/22 season have hampered him massively, particularly as he aggravated that issue on his comeback. Prior to those setbacks, he had become a Fabien Galthie favourite, starting in 10 of his 14 Test appearances. Hasn’t been forgotten as he was named in this week’s 26-man France squad for the two-day camp at Marcoussis.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    12. Julien Delbouis
    Was a Stade Francais regular leading into the age-grade tournament and is still at the capital club, starting in 13 of his 20 Top 14 appearances in the campaign that ended last weekend. Uncapped at Test level but was named in the training squad to prepare for the 2023 Guinness Six Nations. That was a good morale booster as he has had his share of serious injuries, starting with a bicep problem in December 2019 and then cruciate knee ligament setbacks in February and August 2021.

    11. Donovan Taofifanua
    Had little impact at Clermont on his return from Argentina but his 2020 switch to Racing was the making of him at Top 14 level. Has become a regular on their right wing, starting as recently as the derby win over Stade Francais last Saturday to set up this Friday’s semi-final against Toulouse. Uncapped by France despite making a training squad breakthrough in 2022/21.

    10. Louis Carbonel
    Had already established himself as a Toulon regular before guiding France to age-grade glory. Is now orchestrating operations at Montpellier following his summer 2022 switch, taking over the position left vacant when Handre Pollard exited for Leicester. Made five Test appearances during 2020/21 but hasn’t played for Galthie since then.

    9. Leo Coly
    Mont-de-Marsan in the Pro D2 was his pathway into the pro ranks at club level. Continued to feature in the second tier until last summer’s switch to Montpellier where he was reunited with U20s partner Carbonel.

    1. Jean-Baptiste Gros
    Had made a name for himself at Toulon before this 2019 success and continues to progress there, featuring off their bench in last month’s European Challenge Cup final win in Dublin over Glasgow having returned at the start of May from the broken forearm suffered last October. That injury was quite a setback as he was touted to replace the injured Cyril Baille for France’s November matches. Has 21 Test caps, including appearances as a sub in all five games in the 2022 Grand Slam win.

    2. Theo Lachand
    Came through the espoirs at Toulon but switched to Aurillac in the summer of 2021 to try and prove himself at first-team level. A squad player, he has started in just 12 of his 31 Pro D2 appearances.

    3. Alex Burin
    The tighthead had featured on the Agen fringes before his age-grade glory but it took quite a while for him to make his presence felt afterwards. It was only this past season in Pro D2 when he became a regular in their No3 shirt, making 14 starts.

    4. Killian Geraci
    The lock had made a name for himself at Grenoble before this U20s success and he came back from Argentina to hook up with Lyon where he continues to play. Injuries have been a plague, including cruciate ligament damage, yet he did enough to win four Test caps with France in 2020/21. Hoped to play again last November but an injury in the warm-up cost him his spot on the bench versus Australia.

    5. Florent Vanverberghe
    Had made three appearances for Toulon before this age-grade tournament, but needed a summer 2020 move to Castres to rev up his career. Now a Top 14 regular, he travelled with France on their 2021 Australian tour but remains uncapped.

    6. Mattias Haddad
    It’s been a slow build for the La Rochelle youngster due to injury. For instance, his start in the 2022 Champions Cup final lasted just 29 minutes and this season has been limited to just four appearances due to a knee operation.

    7. Thibault Hamonou
    Unable to kick on at Toulouse and earn a debut post-tournament, he switched to Pau in the summer of 2021 where his development continues to take its time. Just the five starts in 2022/23.

    8. Jordan Joseph
    Was highly coveted at Racing but couldn’t nail down a consistent starting spot in the Top 14 until he exited on loan for Pau in 2021/22. The impending arrival of Stuart Lancaster at Racing has now tempted him back to Paris for the 2023/24 season.

    Replacements:
    16. Rayne Barka
    Didn’t make it at Pau but some Pro D2 loan exposure at Agen last term encouraged him to try Soyaux-Angouleme with better luck.

    17. Eli Eglaine
    Came of age at Grenoble in 2021/22 but started fewer matches in the 2022/23 season that ended for the club in a play-off defeat to Perpignan last Saturday.

    18. Georgi Beria
    The tighthead with Georgian roots has been slowly building his career off the Clermont bench.

    19. Paul Mallez
    Another prop who has had to bide his time. His development pathway has been at Toulouse where there have been nine Top 14 appearances this term, seven off the bench.

    20. Gauthier Maravat
    Learned his trade at Agen but has been part of the Castres engine room since the summer of 2022.

    21. Mathieu Hirigoyen
    Came through the Pro D2 ranks at Biarritz before their one-season stay in the Top 14 resulted in a move to Stade Francais for 2022/23. Was a sub back-rower in their play-off last weekend to Racing.

    Related

    22. Loic Hocquet
    Tried to make the grade at Agen but the back row spent this last season with Valence d’Agen in Federale 1.

    23. Quintin Delord
    The scrum-half has done the rounds, initially switching post-tournament from Lyon to Brive. Had his best season at Montauban in 2021/22 but is now on the move again, hooking up with Rouen for 2023/24.

    24. Mathieu Smaili
    Has enjoyed fleeting exposure with Toulon on either side of a 2020/21 loan at Mont-de-Marsan. Six appearances this season, most recently last month as a midfielder starter against Racing the weekend before Toulon’s European title win.

    25. Antoine Zeghoar
    Switched from Toulon to Oyonnax post the age-grade finals, but it’s been at Castres since the summer of 2021 that the midfielder has made his mark.

    26. Ethan Dumortier
    The most notable of the 2019 French replacements, the winger honed his skills on the World Series 7s circuit before jumping to prominence at Lyon last season and going on to start all five Six Nations matches this year for his country. Is part of this week’s World Cup training camp.

    27. Alexandre De Nardi
    Mont-de-Marsan is where the back-three operator has earned his stripes, progress that has netted a move to Montpellier for next season.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    O2 Inside Line: All In | Episode 5 | Making Waves

    Confidence knocks and finding your people | Flo Williams | Rugby Rising Locker Room

    Tackling reasons for drop-out in sport | Zainab Alema | Rugby Rising Locker Room

    Krakow | Leg 3 | Day 2 | HSBC Challenger Series | Full Day Replay

    Kubota Spears vs Tokyo Sungoliath | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

    Jet Lag: The biggest challenge facing international sports? | The Report

    Boks Office | Episode 39 | The Investec Champions Cup is back

    Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry? | New Zealand & Australia | Sevens Wonders | Episode 5

    Trending on RugbyPass

    Comments

    0 Comments
    Be the first to comment...

    Join free and tell us what you really think!

    Sign up for free
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Latest Features

    Comments on RugbyPass

    W
    Wallet Recovery Services since 2017 KeycheinX 28 minutes ago
    'Not real Lions': How the 1989 British and Irish tourists put Australia on the map

    KeycheinX | wallet Recovery Services since 2017


    KeycheinX can help you recover lost Bitcoin & Ethereum passwords with our expert Wallet Recovery Services. KeycheinX has been trusted from people all over the world since 2017. If you need help contact us: keycheinx@mail.com telegram (KeycheinX.


    Lost your Trezor Passphrase?

    Need help recovering your Ethereum Presale, Geth or MIST password?

    ERC20 Tokens from Metamask.

    Need to recover Bitcoin from Multibit Classic or Multibit HD wallet.

    Want to access Bitcoin from an Schildbach Android wallet, Electrum or blockchain.com

    Blockchain.info mnemonic or seed words.

    If you only have access to your public key there is nothing we can do. We do not accept wallets that you have purchased or downloaded from the web. Those are usually forged.

    You can also read more about our wallet recovery services by searching us on GOOGLE KEYCHEINX REVIEW or read our latest July 2024 article on how to recover Bitcoin Wallets How To Recover Bitcoin Wallet Passwords

    We are top scored on Trustpilot with over 130 5 stars. TRUST PILOT


    Below some FAQ or Frequently asked questions;


    What does KeycheinX do?

    We recover mainly Bitcoin and Ethereum wallet passwords from damaged files, computers, phones or online wallets. Our password recovery service has developed special software that can take your best password guess and generate variations in order to decrypt your wallet. We can also recover deleted wallets from hard drives, pen drives or phones.


    Can I recover bitcoin from a damaged phone?

    Yes we can help you recover crypto currencies from a dead device like Iphone or Android. We would need physical access to the device and you would need to ship it to one of our labs in Europe.


    My laptop no longer boots, do you also recover damaged hard drives?

    Yes, you can ship your laptop or hard drive to one of our locations worldwide. We can bypass the login and search for lost or deleted wallet files.


    We also recover hardware Trezor/Ledger wallets with wrong seed or lost passphrases. We can

    help you with Shamir secret seed shares or lost hidden wallets when connecting a Trezor to Metamask.


    How long have KeycheinX been around?

    Our service has been helping people all over the world since 2017. We can help you recover most encrypted files and Private Key recovery, but we mainly focus on stolen Bitcoin and Ethereum password recoveries. Although we do other coins as well like Dogecoin, Solana or BNB chain tokens.


    Do you help recover scams?

    Yes. If you have been scammed or sent crypto to a wrong address then there is a way to reverse it. Never trust anyone who asks for payment upfront to recover stolen cryptocurrency. Verify their legitimacy before taking any action. There is several ways to reverse transactions and if you pay upfront or an exit “tax” then the scammers will scam you again.


    What is the best way to contact KeycheinX Wallet Recovery Services?

    Please use telegram (keycheinX) or send us email to keycheinx@mail.com. We usually answer within 24 hours, if we don’t it might have been that your e-mail have been flagged as spam. Don’t hesitate to send us an email again as we usually answer within a day to every inquiry. If someone contacts you on Telegram, Facebook, Instagram, Quora or X claiming to be from KeycheinX and asks for any credentials or upfront payment, then it’s a scam. We never contact people on those forums or ask upfront payments. We also do not sell any software to open wallets.


    Where are you located?

    KeycheinX head office is located in Baar, Switzerland. Although we have several labs and server rooms scattered around different locations.


    How is KeycheinX Wallet Recovery Services different from other Crypto Recovery Services?

    We have strong media and conference presence. Since 2017, our team have participated as partners or sponsors at many conferences. We have sponsored conferences in Miami, Malta, Rome, Frankfurt, London, Singapore, Dubai, Tokyo and Hong Kong.


    About Us

    The story began in 2017 when a friend of ours lost access to his Ledger device with 150 Ethereum inside. During two evenings we helped the individual to recover his crypto and while working on his case, we discovered how many other people were looking for help with Crypto Wallets. In 2018 we decided to incorporate KeycheinX LLC in Delaware, USA. In 2021, the company moved to Switzerland and have ever since had their office in the Canton of Zug. We currently run several laboratories in different parts of the world and constantly develop and discover new possibilities in recovery.

    KeycheinX is the oldest incorporated company helping individuals to recover their lost Bitcoin or Ethereum.


    Where can we read more about KeycheinX – Wallet Recovery Services? You can search us on Google (keycheinX Review) Cointelegraph featuring article of 10 million Dogecoin recovered in 2021

    Cryptoslate article about AI and Passwords

    Bitcoin.com article about Bitcoin and recovery

    Cryptonomis

    t – How to recover a Bitcoin password in 2 minutes

    3 Go to comments
    W
    Wallet Recovery Services since 2017 KeycheinX 29 minutes ago
    'Not real Lions': How the 1989 British and Irish tourists put Australia on the map

    KeycheinX | wallet Recovery Services since 2017


    KeycheinX can help you recover lost Bitcoin & Ethereum passwords with our expert Wallet Recovery Services. KeycheinX has been trusted from people all over the world since 2017. If you need help contact us: keycheinx@mail.com telegram (KeycheinX.


    Lost your Trezor Passphrase?

    Need help recovering your Ethereum Presale, Geth or MIST password?

    ERC20 Tokens from Metamask.

    Need to recover Bitcoin from Multibit Classic or Multibit HD wallet.

    Want to access Bitcoin from an Schildbach Android wallet, Electrum or blockchain.com

    Blockchain.info mnemonic or seed words.

    If you only have access to your public key there is nothing we can do. We do not accept wallets that you have purchased or downloaded from the web. Those are usually forged.

    You can also read more about our wallet recovery services by searching us on GOOGLE KEYCHEINX REVIEW or read our latest July 2024 article on how to recover Bitcoin Wallets How To Recover Bitcoin Wallet Passwords

    We are top scored on Trustpilot with over 130 5 stars. TRUST PILOT


    Below some FAQ or Frequently asked questions;


    What does KeycheinX do?

    We recover mainly Bitcoin and Ethereum wallet passwords from damaged files, computers, phones or online wallets. Our password recovery service has developed special software that can take your best password guess and generate variations in order to decrypt your wallet. We can also recover deleted wallets from hard drives, pen drives or phones.


    Can I recover bitcoin from a damaged phone?

    Yes we can help you recover crypto currencies from a dead device like Iphone or Android. We would need physical access to the device and you would need to ship it to one of our labs in Europe.


    My laptop no longer boots, do you also recover damaged hard drives?

    Yes, you can ship your laptop or hard drive to one of our locations worldwide. We can bypass the login and search for lost or deleted wallet files.


    We also recover hardware Trezor/Ledger wallets with wrong seed or lost passphrases. We can

    help you with Shamir secret seed shares or lost hidden wallets when connecting a Trezor to Metamask.


    How long have KeycheinX been around?

    Our service has been helping people all over the world since 2017. We can help you recover most encrypted files and Private Key recovery, but we mainly focus on stolen Bitcoin and Ethereum password recoveries. Although we do other coins as well like Dogecoin, Solana or BNB chain tokens.


    Do you help recover scams?

    Yes. If you have been scammed or sent crypto to a wrong address then there is a way to reverse it. Never trust anyone who asks for payment upfront to recover stolen cryptocurrency. Verify their legitimacy before taking any action. There is several ways to reverse transactions and if you pay upfront or an exit “tax” then the scammers will scam you again.


    What is the best way to contact KeycheinX Wallet Recovery Services?

    Please use telegram (keycheinX) or send us email to keycheinx@mail.com. We usually answer within 24 hours, if we don’t it might have been that your e-mail have been flagged as spam. Don’t hesitate to send us an email again as we usually answer within a day to every inquiry. If someone contacts you on Telegram, Facebook, Instagram, Quora or X claiming to be from KeycheinX and asks for any credentials or upfront payment, then it’s a scam. We never contact people on those forums or ask upfront payments. We also do not sell any software to open wallets.


    Where are you located?

    KeycheinX head office is located in Baar, Switzerland. Although we have several labs and server rooms scattered around different locations.


    How is KeycheinX Wallet Recovery Services different from other Crypto Recovery Services?

    We have strong media and conference presence. Since 2017, our team have participated as partners or sponsors at many conferences. We have sponsored conferences in Miami, Malta, Rome, Frankfurt, London, Singapore, Dubai, Tokyo and Hong Kong.


    About Us

    The story began in 2017 when a friend of ours lost access to his Ledger device with 150 Ethereum inside. During two evenings we helped the individual to recover his crypto and while working on his case, we discovered how many other people were looking for help with Crypto Wallets. In 2018 we decided to incorporate KeycheinX LLC in Delaware, USA. In 2021, the company moved to Switzerland and have ever since had their office in the Canton of Zug. We currently run several laboratories in different parts of the world and constantly develop and discover new possibilities in recovery.

    KeycheinX is the oldest incorporated company helping individuals to recover their lost Bitcoin or Ethereum.


    Where can we read more about KeycheinX – Wallet Recovery Services? You can search us on Google (keycheinX Review) Cointelegraph featuring article of 10 million Dogecoin recovered in 2021

    Cryptoslate article about AI and Passwords

    Bitcoin.com article about Bitcoin and recovery

    Cryptonomis

    t – How to recover a Bitcoin password in 2 minutes

    3 Go to comments
    N
    Nicholas Brian 1 hour ago
    Springboks coach on why they want Ireland game to be hard

    It all started with a seemingly golden opportunity – a high-yield Bitcoin investment. I invested in a cryptocurrency startup that looked promising, but I never imagined it would turn into a nightmare. The platform — slick, well-marketed, and with testimonials from seemingly legitimate investors — promised me a 200% return in two weeks. I invested over 7 Bitcoins, worth nearly $500,000 at the time.  The platform’s customer support became elusive, and eventually the platform disappeared. No access, no updates, no sign of the team – just silence, and my heart sank. I had been scammed. I wasn’t alone. across the country and even internationally, victims of the same scam were reporting similar experiences. Fake trading dashboards, forged gains, withdrawal delays, and ultimately, total disappearance. It was a textbook crypto scam—decentralized, anonymous, and nearly impossible to trace, It was a classic crypto scam – decentralized, anonymous, and virtually untraceable, until I discovered Dexdert Net Pro Recovery. Unlike typical recovery agencies that rely on outdated tracing methods or cold legal tactics, Dexdert Net Pro combines advanced blockchain forensics with cyber intelligence and direct collaboration with cryptocurrency exchanges and law enforcement around the world. To recover stolen digital assets — even in the darkest corners of blockchain, when I reached out, the team at Dexdert started with forensic blockchain tracing, uncovering the maze of mixing services, private wallets, and overseas exchanges used to launder stolen BTC. What set them apart was their real-time AI-driven tracing tool that can follow the most obscure trails on multiple chains. Dexdert tracked my stolen BTC through decentralized mixers and shell accounts and identified a batch of BTC that had recently been converted and stored in dormant wallets connected to an unregulated exchange in Eastern Europe. Dexdert successfully recovered my 7 BTC, worth $500,000  after proving its illicit origin -Today, I am an active advocate for proactive recovery services. Without Dexdert Net Pro Recovery, I would have lost everything. Not only did they track down my Bitcoins, they also busted the entire scam network. If you’ve been scammed, don’t give up – contact a professional like Dexdert Net Pro Recovery before the trial runs out.

    CONTACT INFORMATION VIA:

    Telegram: (@Dexdertprorecovery) Email: (DexdertNetPro@mail.com) WhatsApp: (‪+1 859 609‑4156‬)

    0 Go to comments
    J
    Julio Langworth 2 hours ago
    'Individuals are stepping up': Vern Cotter on Beauden Barrett's influence

    In 2024, I received a substantial tax refund, which I saw as a golden opportunity to improve my financial situation. Eager to invest, I became interested in Bitcoin, a digital currency that many believe represents the future of finance. Unfortunately, my excitement led me to a fraudulent company that promised incredible returns on investments. Their persuasive tactics and seemingly legitimate operations drew me in, but it didn’t take long for me to realize that I had been deceived, and my hard-earned money $572,000 had vanished.Feeling devastated and hopeless after losing such a significant amount, I reached out to a friend who had faced a similar ordeal. They recommended a company called GRAYWARE TECH SERVICES , which specializes in recovering lost Bitcoin. Although I was skeptical, my desperation pushed me to contact them for help.From the very first interaction with GRAYWARE TECH SERVICES , I was impressed by their understanding and willingness to help. Their team guided me through the recovery process, providing the support I needed during this challenging time. They explained each step clearly and kept me informed throughout the entire journey. Their dedication rekindled my hope of recovering my lost funds.Thanks to the diligent efforts of GRAYWARE TECH SERVICES , I was able to reclaim my stolen Bitcoin. This experience not only restored my financial situation but also taught me invaluable lessons about the importance of conducting thorough research before making any investments. I now have a solid investment strategy in place and am much more cautious about where I allocate my funds.I want to emphasize the importance of being vigilant in the world of cryptocurrency. While Bitcoin offers tremendous potential as an investment, it also attracts scammers looking to exploit unsuspecting individuals. If you find yourself in a similar situation, I strongly encourage you to seek help from a trustworthy recovery service like GRAYWARE TECH SERVICES .Investing in Bitcoin can be a rewarding venture, but it is crucial to approach it with caution. Always perform comprehensive research and remain skeptical of offers that seem too good to be true,but if fallen victim to scam a GRAYWARE TECH SERVICES is available for you.You can reach them on whatsapp +18582759508, web at ( https://graywaretechservices.com/ )    also on Mail: (contact@graywaretechservices.com)

    3 Go to comments
    F
    Flankly 2 hours ago
    How 'misunderstood' Rassie Erasmus is rolling back the clock

    Nick - thanks for another good piece.


    It’s remarkable that Matt Williams gets so upset about Bomb Squad tactics. He’s not just making recommendations, but getting all sweaty about bench splits. But it’s not really about bench splits. He just does not like forwards, and their role in the game.


    I thought this quote was telling:

    What about Kitshoff, what happened to his spine in South Africa? Do we know if that is as a result of the scrummaging they are put through?

    Ouch. So we are really on a program of reducing scrummaging to reduce spinal injuries? That’s the mission? And based on the statistically significant dataset of one case, a case in which he openly admits that he does not have the details. Regardless, if his goal is to reduce spinal injuries for prop forwards then arguing about bench splits seems like an odd place to start.


    It’s not just spinal injuries that he cares about. The risk of paralysis is an important issue, and he raises this too:

    I’m a bit of a lone voice but, because of my club-mate Grant Harper (ex-Western Suburbs prop who was paralysed after a collapsed scrum), I’m not shutting up on it.

    Injuries are horrible, and paralysis is truly awful. We should absolutely take it very seriously, and diligently implement whatever safety protocols and education programs we can to minimize these things. But we don’t ban skydiving or hang gliding, or crossing the road. Though Williams is not looking to ban rugby, he does seem to be intent on reducing the role of forwards in the game, based on entirely anecdotal data.


    It’s hard to tell what it’s all about. He makes this supposed safety case and says that no-one in his echo chamber disagrees with him:

    Every time I go out, old forwards and old props go up to me and they say, ‘you’re right’. I’ve never had anyone, apart from a few South Africans – because it’s good for South Africa – say it’s rubbish.

    It’s weird that “old props” are hanging around his front door and lobbying him, or maybe he just doesn’t “go out” much. Could it be that all of the hand-wringing about bench splits and scrummaging injuries is really a proxy for something else? Is it possible his issue is not about safety at all?


    Well, that is what it seems. For me the truth is in this comment:

    Can Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Australia and Argentina compete against South Africa, New Zealand and France if that’s the way the game goes? The answer to that is no.

    So, this is the real issue for him. The Bomb Squad tactic is a really good one, and you have to be really good to play against it. Or you should try to de-power it by banning it, wailing about injuries that it supposedly causes (it doesn’t) and clutching at anecdotal straws to make your case.


    The above quote is an insult to the five countries named, and it also suggests that no-one is going to be smart enough to come up with a game plan that neutralizes the bomb squad or turns it to a relative weakness. Williams is just a noisy fan looking to change the laws to favor his team and his personal tastes.


    I agree with your conclusions. This Rassie approach is far from being unfair to backs. Not only does it favor fleet-footed and versatile “skills players” in the double-digit positions, but each individual gets more game time in any given match.


    Whenever I go out I get exactly zero “old backs” coming up to me and complaining about the Bomb Squad tactic.


    Bravo, Rassie.

    201 Go to comments
    LONG READ
    LONG READ Fur set to fly as Parisian duo dragged into Top 14 relegation dogfight Fur set to fly as Parisian duo dragged into Top 14 relegation dogfight
    Search