Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Why the All Blacks should follow the 'Marco Pierre White theory of rugby selection'

Shaun Stevenson at All Blacks training. Photo by Joe Allison/Getty Images

England have made the tough selection calls as attention shifts from club to country with the tour of New Zealand nearing, and now it is the All Blacks‘ turn to reveal who will be greeting them on the Dunedin turf.

ADVERTISEMENT

No selection is a straightforward task, especially in the backline, where All Blacks teams have historically held the upper hand with their electric attacking threats.

If 2024 is to be no different, new head coach Scott Robertson must make the right selection calls. Something easier said than done with talent aplenty across Super Rugby Pacific.

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

The playoffs are sure to provide some crucial insights into how certain players perform under pressure, and the quarter-finals have already offered some answers in that respect.

The Chiefs had run out to a 31-0 lead over the Reds by halftime, a demolition job that owes thanks to all 15 starters, but with the scoring opportunities largely orchestrated by the dynamic duo of playmaker Damian McKenzie and fullback Shaun Stevenson.

While the No. 4 and No. 5 seed quarter-final is often the most competitive, the Chiefs romped home to the most convincing win of the weekend, a relatively unexpected result that has thrown preconceptions over the title favourites tag up in the air.

The 2023 finalists have hit this year’s playoffs with by far the most energy and reminded everyone why they were considered the favourites to begin the season.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I’ll tell you who called that, (Chiefs head coach) Clayton McMillan,” Scotty Stevenson remarked on SENZ Breakfast. “We had him on the show a couple of weeks ago and we talked about when we were going to see the real Chiefs, when they were going to play their hand. Well, they played their hand on Friday night.

“That’s playoff Chiefs, that’s what that team is. The McKenzie-Stevenson combination was simply outstanding. The All Blacks coaches have been looking for that dual-playmaker for years, for the most part of the last decade, and you cannot manufacture it. It has to be organic. It has to be natural.

“Those two players, McKenzie and Stevenson, they understand themselves and each other on some transcendental frequency.

“I don’t know who can stop those players and I don’t think even Clayton McMillan knows what’s going to happen. But, the best thing you can do with McKeznie and Stevenson on the same team, is say well here is a little bit of structure, here’s how we want to play the game, you guys go and do it.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s the Marco Pierre White theory of rugby selection; just put the ingredients out there and don’t do too much to them.”

Related

The two have undeniable rugby instincts and chemistry, having grown and developed side-by-side in the Chiefs environment. The combination’s partnership may well be ready to hit the international stage in 2024 with uncertainty surrounding the black No. 15 jersey.

“You know what I love about that? You haven’t got two alfa males trying to dominate that big dog bone that’s been hanging out there. You’ve got two players who understand each other’s roles,” former All Black fullback Israel Dagg added.

“You’re not trying to get in there at first receiver, you’re giving Damian time to run the ship, but Stevenson’s stepping up in the perfect situation.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Boks Office | Episode 37 | Six Nations Round 4 Review

Cape Town | Leg 2 | Day 2 | HSBC Challenger Series 2025 | Full Day Replay

Gloucester-Hartpury vs Bristol Bears | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Boks Office | Episode 36 | Six Nations Round 3 Review

Why did Scotland's Finn Russell take the crucial kick from the wrong place? | Whistle Watch

England A vs Ireland A | Full Match Replay

Kubota Spears vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | JRLO 2024/2025 | Full Match Replay

Watch now: Lomu - The Lost Tapes

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

15 Comments
J
Jmann 287 days ago

Stephenson still has suspect defense.

G
Greg 288 days ago

And Love over Stephenson of course.

G
Greg 288 days ago

Much as I admire DMac, I don’t think he’ll drag half the Chiefs team into the ABs with him. Ratima, Stevenson and even Taukei’aho need to justify their inclusion ahead of the likes of TJ, Christie, Funaki (a bolter) and Taylor and Aumua, they’re not going to just ride in there on DMac’s back.

T
Troy 288 days ago

McKenzie - Stevenson combo would be unmatched on the international stage. As stated it's organic ,it's natural, something you can't manufacture. Also the kicking game provided by them is varied, accurate and long when needed, they would be what Hansen and then Foster tried to create but failed to the detriment of our team. Razor needs to be brave and install the chief's spine into the ABs, Stevenson, McKenzie, Ratima and Taukei'aho if he's looking for natural combinations to help fast track his new team.

M
Michael 288 days ago

He missed a bad tackle a couple of weeks back and that will cost him his place

J
Jasyn 289 days ago

Stevenson can be a wonderful attacking threat, but his effort and body language at the back sometimes suggests he's wishing anyone else was the last line of defence but him.

We already had years of turnstile-Dagg at the back until Hansen finally saw sense and put Ben Smith in 15. We don’t need a defence optional fullback again.

J
Jen 289 days ago

I love watching Stevenson play. I’d be so happy if he got a run in black again - I think last time he was thrown under the bus.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
MS 52 minutes ago
Andy Farrell answers burning Owen Farrell Lions question

I can understand negotiations for Kinghorn, White, and Ribbans. All three are playing very, very well at the current time. Kinghorn has been a leading contended for some time now; Ribbans looks as powerful as he’s ever been; while on the evidence of the most recent Six Nations, White benches behind JGP at Scrumhalf.


However, noone in their right mind should be considering Kyle Sinckler, Courtney Lawes, nor Owen Farrell. Sinckler looks unfit and can barely move around the field with any great urgency. He would be a liability on tour to Australia. Lawes is clearly ‘enjoying life’ in ProD2, and his rugby looks every bit second tier level now.


As for Farrell, not only has he been plagued by poor form and injury since moving to Racing, even the much vaunted ‘kicking record’ has long since been debunked as a USP with a percentage that simply does not stand up to scrutiny. That leaves only the intangible (desperate…) claim he would add ‘leadership’, which in a Lions squad resplendent with talent and international caps is I’m afraid, much like Farrell, a complete non-starter.


Willis is the elephant in the room…a leader and standout option for one of the best club teams in the World. Yet still a relative unknown at Test Match level. I could well see him being included on the tour - and it would prove quite the headache for the RFU if he delivers. But Back Row is so competitive across all three positions, and with genuine World Class talent there too. I’m just not sure the Lions need him.

4 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Fijian Drua rising star stunned by shock news before Hong Kong Sevens Fijian Drua rising star stunned by shock news before Hong Kong Sevens
Search