Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'I'm really concerned': Why the Black Ferns may struggle to replace Wayne Smith

Portia Woodman, Wayne Smith and Sarah Hirini celebrate following the Black Ferns' World Cup win. Photo by Hannah Peters - World Rugby/World Rugby via Getty Images

Super coach Wayne Smith was able to accomplish something truly incredible with the Black Ferns last year, as he led them to World Cup glory in front of a sold out Eden Park crowd.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rugby fans of all ages packed the stands at the famous venue, and watched on as the hosts recorded an epic 34-31 upset win over World No. 1 England.

The Black Ferns had defied the odds.

New Zealand had lost two test matches against both England and France during their end-of-season tour the November before – and they lost these four matches by empathic margins as well.

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

Change was needed. The Black Ferns needed the best.

And that’s exactly what they got.

Two-time men’s World Cup winner Wayne Smith was appointed as a technical coach in April, but later became the head coach after Glenn Moore resigned.

Smith was now in charge of a talented group of professional athletes who dared to dream of World Cup glory on home soil.

The Black Ferns were able to both unite and inspire a nation throughout their incredible World Cup run as they performed passionately on the field.

Records were broken throughout the ground-breaking tournament as sold out crowds attended tests at Eden Park, and spurred the Black Ferns onto the sports ultimate glory.

ADVERTISEMENT

But after etching their names into New Zealand sporting folklore, there are some unanswered questions facing the Black Ferns as we usher in a new year.

Wayne Smith has retired as a three-time world champion, but his replacement is yet to be announced.

Speaking on Weekend Sport with Jason Pine, New Zealand Herald columnist Alice Soper explained why she is “really concerned” about the Black Ferns’ next coach.

“I’m really concerned about who’s our next coach,” Soper said on Newstalk ZB on New Year’s Eve. “I think that lays bare a lot of structural issues that we have.

ADVERTISEMENT

“If you like Aupiki for example, we’ve had two women who have just been put in charge of teams. So now my Hurricanes Poua have (Victoria) Grant and the Chiefs Manawa have Crystal Kuau.

“That’s great but if you look at the total numbers across the coaching setup, we have no more women coaching this year than we did last year. We have a reconfiguration, but the same numbers involved.

“That’s an issue if we talk in terms of pathways up to the top. We don’t have a structure where we have been investing in specialists in women’s rugby for a long time.

“We’ve got a really small handful of people that they will be looking at and that’s a challenge because we’ve got people who have been around for quite a while; been through the good and the bad.

“It’s a case of are we ready really to have someone as good to replace Wayne? I don’t know if we do.”

While the Black Ferns were officially crowned champions for their success on the field, they were equally as deserving of that moniker for their actions off it.

Related

Stars including Ruby Tui, Sarah Hirini and Stacey Fluhler were among a talented, and now legendary, group of players who changed women’s rugby in Aotearoa forever.

Whether it was smiling during the national anthems or spending seemingly endless periods of time with supporters, this team was different.

Comparing the Black Ferns to the All Blacks, Soper said the difference was the “reconnection back to who they” are.

“I think it’s a reconnection back to who they were. I’ve talked to a lot of people and it feels like it’s that nostalgia of the early 90s where players were still people as well,” Soper added.

“We’ve got this whole production line where we’re pulling kids out of school and putting them into ‘this is how you become an All Black’ at 16, and there’s no opportunity for them to figure out who they are.

“That’s what people loved. When they’re talking to Ruby Tui, it’s the whole of herself… I love her and every poster put her on there, put her on the mic.

“Allowing people to have personalities, allowing us to have connection back to community. That’s the other reason people turn up first and foremost is because they know them.”

Super Rugby Aupiki kicks off with two exciting matches on Saturday, February 25.

Hurricanes Poua are set to host Chiefs Manawa at Levin Domain, while Matatu will face Blues Women at Forsyth Barr Stadium.

ADVERTISEMENT

Boks Office | Episode 37 | Six Nations Round 4 Review

Cape Town | Leg 2 | Day 2 | HSBC Challenger Series 2025 | Full Day Replay

Gloucester-Hartpury vs Bristol Bears | PWR 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Boks Office | Episode 36 | Six Nations Round 3 Review

Why did Scotland's Finn Russell take the crucial kick from the wrong place? | Whistle Watch

England A vs Ireland A | Full Match Replay

Kubota Spears vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | JRLO 2024/2025 | Full Match Replay

Watch now: Lomu - The Lost Tapes

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
MS 41 minutes ago
Why Blair Kinghorn should be nailed on as the Lions starting 15

I can see arguments for both Kinghorn, and Keenan starting for the Lions. But I’m less convinced by some of the claims (clearly partisan) supporters are using to argue the merits of one over the other.


For example, a number of Ireland supporters have suggested Kinghorn is ‘defensively weak’. That’s patently false - or at least on the evidence of this 6N, he’s certainly no weaker there than Keenan is, who is presumably the comparative standard they’re using. Keenan was both shrugged off in contact, and beaten on the edge for pace, a number of times during this competition.


Equally, Scotland supporters arguing Kinghorn is the more capable ‘rugby player’ seem to have overlooked the (frankly sizeable) body of evidence demonstrating that Keenan is an excellent ball in hand distributor and decision maker. So that doesn’t hold up under scrutiny either.


I don’t think there’s all that much to choose between them, and either would be a strong choice. I think it would be really interesting from a pure rugby perspective to see Keenan playing a ‘Scotland-esque’ style of high tempo attacking rugby. Either coming into the line more routinely as first receiver, or being swung as a pendulum and getting the ball on the edge against a stretched defence.


That’s assuming Andy Farrell goes that route, of course. He may well just opt for his Ireland system instead, and populate it with the likes of Henshaw, Ringrose, Lowe and Keenan. I’m sure that would win the series. Quite what effect it might have on a Lions audience who were expecting something other than ‘Ireland on tour, but wearing red’ would remain to be seen.


As for the debate at FB, the only ‘eye test’ difference I feel exists is in the pace of rugby Kinghorn (Toulouse? Scotland?) tends to play. His passing/offload game feels crisper and higher tempo than Keenan’s - and as we saw in Paris, his pace and eye for a gap from deep are superior.


But again, that will only prove a decisive factor if Andy Farrell wants to play that way. If all he wants from his FB is to sit deep, field high balls, and mop up then there’s little between these two equally excellent players.

3 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Will Jordan 'wasn't too happy' with Macca Springer's five tries vs Force Macca Springer on historic try haul vs Force
Search