Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Will Eddie Jones' latest selection pay off? 5 second Test talking points

By PA
Guy Porter walks from the ocean during an England Rugby Squad beach recovery session at South Beach on June 24, 2022 in Perth, Australia. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

England clash with Australia in a must-win second Test at Brisbane’s Suncorp Stadium on Saturday having lost the series opener 30-28. Here, the PA news agency examines five talking points heading into a game that could see the Wallabies claim the inaugural Ella-Mobbs Cup.

ADVERTISEMENT

Eddie rolls the dice
At times England’s selection policy under Jones appears as though it has been put together on a roulette wheel – players talked up and picked, then discarded.

This scattergun approach produces debuts for centre Guy Porter and wing Tommy Freeman as Suncorp Stadium, as well as a first start for Jack van Poortvliet, and could be the last that is seen of Joe Marchant and Joe Cokanasiga. It is sink or swim for the latest batch of recruits with Jones wanting to see if they can cut it at Test level.

Video Spacer

Bryan Habana, Jonny Hill’s hair pulling and South Africa’s revenge | RugbyPass Offload | Ep 41

Video Spacer

Bryan Habana, Jonny Hill’s hair pulling and South Africa’s revenge | RugbyPass Offload | Ep 41

Jam tomorrow
“The perfect practice for the World Cup” is how Jones described a do-or-die collision with Australia which England have to win to keep the series alive and avoid a fifth straight defeat.

It was a jarring statement and even though it was clarified with an assurance that Saturday is of the “utmost importance”, it adds to the sense that the here and now and is being sacrificed for an event that takes place every four years and is ferociously difficult to win. Starting three players with only one cap between them is a decision rooted in the future at the expense of the present.

Porter takes centre stage
Freeman is a thrilling prospect with the size, gas and skills to light up Brisbane from the wing, but Porter’s performance will be of greatest interested to Jones.

It is hoped the 25-year-old will provide the punch in midfield that England miss so acutely in the ongoing absence of Manu Tuilagi. Leicester have benefited from his direct running and ability to break the first line of defence in their title winning season and at 6’2? and 15stone 4lbs he has physical presence. One of the great mysteries of English rugby is its failure to produce powerful centres and Porter is the latest solution to the problem.

ADVERTISEMENT

Smash time
A heavyweight collision looms in the front row when the Wallabies prop dubbed the ‘Tongan Thor’ goes head to head with England’s Ellis Genge.

Related

Both are mighty carriers and influential figures for their teams. Taniela Tupou is an explosive runner despite his vast bulk while Genge is at his best making hard yards, consistently getting over the gainline. Tupou missed the first Test with a calf injury but intends making up for lost time after vowing to “smash” his opposite number.

The Suncorp factor
Brisbane is repeatedly referenced as the Wallabies’ “Spiritual home” and a glance at their record since England were the last team to defeat them there in 2016 explains why. Australia have rattled off 10 successive victories including three against South Africa, two against France, two against New Zealand and one against Ireland. It is a genuine fortress that puffs up the Wallabies’ chest before a punch is thrown, adding to the challenge facing England who suffered their heaviest defeat in Test history at the venue – a 76-0 mauling in 1998.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 1 hour ago
'Let's not sugarcoat it': Former All Black's urgent call to protect eligibility rules

The effects of allowing players to go overseas will only be known in 10, 20, or even 30 years time.


The lower quality professional level has to seep into the young viewership, those just starting school rugby now, along with the knockon affect of each immediate group, stars to professional, pro to emerging etc, and then it would have to cycle through 2 or 3 times before suddenly you notice you're rugby isn't as good as what it used to be.


This ideology only works for the best of the best of course. If you're someone on the outside, like an Australian player, and you come into the New Zealand game you only get better and as thats the best league, it filters into the Australian psyche just as well. Much the same idea for nations like Scotland, England, even Ireland, you probably get better from having players playing in France, because the level is so much higher. Risk is also reduced for a nation like South Africa as well, as they play in the URC and EPCR and thats what the audience watch their own stars play in. It wouldn't matter as much if that wasn't for a South African team.


So when you say Rassie has proven it can work, no, he hasn't. All he has shown is that a true master mind can deal with the difficulties of juggling players around, who all have different 'peak' points in their season, and get them to perform. And his players are freaks and he's only allowed the best of the best to go overseas. Not one All Black has come back from a sabbatical in is good nick/form as he left, yet. Cane was alright but he was injured and in NZ for most the Super season, Ardie was well off the pace when he came back.


Those benefits don't really exist for New Zealand. I would be far more happy if a billionaire South African drew a couple of stars, even just young ones, over to play in the URC, because we know their wouldn't be that drop in standard. Perhaps Jake should look there? I would have thought one of the main reasons we haven't already seen that is because SA teams don't need to pay to get players in though.

44 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ 'Welsh regional rugby has failed conclusively and there is no way back' 'Welsh regional rugby has failed conclusively and there is no way back'
Search