40 - 26

Woodward names the one 'major learning for the future' for Borthwick

18 Mar 2024

England head coach Steve Borthwick during the Guinness Six Nations Rugby Championship match between England and Ireland at Twickenham Stadium in London, England. (Photo By David Fitzgerald/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

Sir Clive Woodward has questioned the timing of England head coach Steve Borthwick’s substitutions after their 33-31 loss to France in the final round of the Guinness Six Nations.

The World Cup-winning coach was effusive in his praise of England after a third-place finish in the Championship, paying credit to Borthwick in his Daily Mail column after a “strong campaign” with “so many positives for England”.

The 68-year-old’s only criticism remains the timing of the substitutions made by the head coach, saying the changes made in Lyon were unnecessary.

Farrell vs Borthwick – Boks Office on who would take it | RPTV

Video Player is loading.

Current Time 0:00

Duration 0:58

Loaded: 0.00%

Stream Type LIVE

Remaining Time 0:58

Farrell vs Borthwick – Boks Office on who would take it | RPTV

The Boks Office crew are back to discuss the latest goings on in the Six Nations. Watch the full show exclusively on RugbyPass TV

Watch now

England raced to a 24-16 lead within seven minutes of the start of the second half, overturning a six-point deficit at half-time. Those tries preceded wholesale changes to England’s front-row.

England did not score again for another half-hour, as the hosts surged back into the lead. While there was nothing in the match to suggest those changes were the cause of France’s comeback, Woodward still feels they were not needed.

Points Flow Chart

France win +2

Time in lead

Mins in lead

53%

% Of Game In Lead

32%

67%

Possession Last 10 min

33%

Points Last 10 min

“One thing I’d still like Borthwick to do is a bit more thought on substitutions,” he wrote. “He replaced the entire front row early in the second half against France. Those switches included captain Jamie George.

“I don’t think they were needed. Neither was removing Henry Slade for Manu Tuilagi who was having a strong game. Why take off your best players, especially your captain? That’s a major learning for the future but overall, well done Steve.”

Woodward was particularly complimentary of Ellis Genge, crowning the loosehead as his player of the match. The Bristol Bears star was taken off as part of the front-row switch just moments after putting Ben Earl through a gap in the build-up to Marcus Smith’s try.

“I thought Ellis Genge was just outstanding and for me man of the match. He scrummaged well, was strong in defence, and showed some nice passing. There is no doubt England have got a more-than-promising team if they approach games with an all-out attacking mindset.”

KOKO Show | October 7th | Nic White Retires for One Final Time on The KOKO Show... We Think!

All 294 Tries in One EPIC Video | Every Rugby World Cup 2025 Try

Every England Try | Rugby World Cup 2025

Every Braxton Sorensen-McGee Try! Rugby World Cup 2025 Top Try Scorer

The CHAOS and GLORY that comes with winning a Rugby World Cup | Official Rugby World Cup 2025 Podcast | Episode 9

Canada v England | Rugby World Cup 2025 | Highlights

New Zealand v France | Rugby World Cup 2025 | Highlights

On the spectrum with Manchester United | Safia Middleton-Patel | Stronger Than You Think

Comments

2 Comments

Flankly 568 days ago

SCW really struggles to follow the modern game, doesn't he?

“Substitutions weren't needed”? Huh?

There are lots of reasons for doing substitutions, other than them being obviously or immediately needed. Coaches are managing workload and test minutes for individual players, they are building depth, giving players opportunities to prove themselves, experimenting with combinations and tactics, creating competition for places, preparing for future opponents etc.

We also do not have access to the GPS data, which tells coaches precisely how tired players are, how quickly they are resetting in defense etc. Starters are told to empty the tank, and coaches watch the fuel guage in real time. They see that a player is off the pace long before fans do.

Lastly, the Bomb Squad mindset is about playing the last 15-20 minutes with a fresher, stronger and quicker team than the tired opposition. Under current substitution rules Borthwick will need to groove this kind of strategy to be competitive.

Coaching in SCW’s day could afford to be naively outcome-oriented. But today coaches have to focus on process and let the score take care of itself. That’s the way to deliver consistent wins. And there will be mixed results until the process kicks in.

The good news for England is that the processes seem to be coming together, including in defense, attack, set pieces and game management. As relates to substitutions, without understanding the context and the intent we really can’t say whether they achieved their goals, but regardless, we do know that the substitutions did not derail the win.

Bull Shark 568 days ago

My thoughts exactly. He seems to think the coaches are working off doodled notes taken on the bus ride to the stadium.

Or that the players should be subbed just as they become lame from exhaustion.

No sophisticated models or data. Stoneage stuff.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Latest Long Reads

LONG READ

Twelve down to two: Scotland’s second-row depth gives Townsend autumn dilemma

Gregor Townsend is spoilt for choice at lock with a dozen or more contenders vying for Test places next month.

LONG READ

Have the All Blacks stumbled across the perfect midfield partnership?

The All Blacks may have inadvertently happened across the midfield partnership to take them to the 2027 World Cup

LONG READ

'Tonyball, ageing warriors and worrying growth' - What the Springboks learned from the Rugby Championship

Rassie Erasmus continues to strengthen his player pool and diversify his game plan, but there is room for improvement ahead of a massive northern tour.