1
World Rugby leak suggests Rassie Erasmus' ref criticisms are mostly correct
By Paul Smith
World Rugby will acknowledge that South African director of rugby Rassie Erasmus was correct about the vast majority of criticism aimed at referee Nic Berry following the Springboks’ first test defeat by the British & Irish Lions.
ADVERTISEMENT
This is the revelation made today by Brendan Nel and Hendrik Cronje writing in the Afrikaans weekly newspaper Rapport – South Africa’s second largest Sunday paper.
Erasmus’ 62-minute video, which was released on Twitter, pointed out 26 errors which he claimed were made by Berry, his touch judges and the TMO during the Lions’ 22-17 win in Cape Town.
Both the content and manner of the video’s publication have since come under heavy criticism and as a result World Rugby have convened a misconduct hearing next weekend. Both South Africa’s DOR and his employers SA Rugby will appear before this independent disciplinary committee to answer charges of bringing the game into disrepute.
However, ahead of this meeting Rapport has revealed that World Rugby believes Erasmus was correct about 23 of the 26 highlighted incidents.
This does not, however, deal with the question of the video being published on social media rather than sent privately to the sport’s governing body and its referee managers Joel Jutge and Joe Schmidt.
Sending this kind of video analysis – albeit usually on a vastly less substantial scale – to the referee post-match is a standard approach within the professional game.
ADVERTISEMENT
Erasmus denies making the video public and various rumours have since circulated suggesting the source of the leak to Twitter is in Australia.
On an ‘innocent-until-proven-guilty’ basis, the onus at next weekend’s disciplinary hearing will be firmly on World Rugby to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Erasmus was the source of the leak which came from an account registered to a Jaco Johan.
If found guilty South Africa’s 48-year-old World Cup winning head coach could face a range of sanctions with a fine and possible ban – or suspended ban – the most likely outcome.
🦘 Kerevi
🦘 McMahon
🦘 Cooper
Important Autumn Series discussions with their clubs are imminent…https://t.co/KsaA0yQ4CM— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) October 24, 2021
So on the 'leak'. The Vimeo account that posted the video was tied to the email address of Russell Belter, he owns a video production company that has been working for SARU and Supersport for 20 years. It was posted under the JJ account, the same initials as Jaco Johan the 'pundit' that Erasmus had been praising that week.
It's up to everyone else to decide if they think that evidence is stronger than 'rumour it came from Australia'. 😀
Leaked by whom and cui bono?
Pathetic...if this was the outcome..why all the hoolabaloo ..ban him for two years from international rugby to act as a deterrent to other officials who would want to criticize match officials publicaly after games....no one is anti south africa...we all complain about calls against out teams but he just threw mud on rugby as a sport..BAN him
Let's not forget Gatland's contribution, and if punishment is dished out he must be included.
This much was always painfully obvious to anyone who bothered watching the video under the assumption that it was not leaked by Erramus but someone else. If the Ozzie ref Berry had the decency to engage with the current world champion director of rugby then this entire episode would have been averted, how’s THAT for arrogance!? For all you self righteous Lions and Kiwi supporters out there: Imagine Fozzy and Gatland having to stomach being told as an excuse that a 5pm power nap was more important than a review of your performance of a test match that happens every 12 years. Piss poor refereeing rightly called out.