Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

WRU report says Cardiff 'robbed' of victory in Belfast

Scott Wilson of Ulster is tackled by Taulupe Faletau of Cardiff during the United Rugby Championship match between Ulster and Cardiff at the Kingspan Stadium in Belfast. (Photo By John Dickson/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

A WRU match report has claimed that Cardiff were “robbed” of victory following a controversial refereeing intervention in the dying moments of their defeat to Ulster in the URC.

ADVERTISEMENT

Cardiff seemed to be on the verge of a remarkable victory – their first win in Belfast in 14 years – when a massive call saw a 10-point turnaround in the final minutes of the game.

Match officials TMO Andrew McMenemy and referee Mike Adamson had a big say in the outcome by disallowing what would have been a hat-trick try for Theo Cabango and almost certain match-winner with the score at 16-17.

Video Spacer

Springbok legend Victor Matfield on why Jason Jenkins might take over from Eben Etzebeth

Springbok legend Victory Matfield is backing Jason Jenkins to take over the Springbok No.4 jersey from Eben Etzebeth one day.

Video Spacer

Springbok legend Victor Matfield on why Jason Jenkins might take over from Eben Etzebeth

Springbok legend Victory Matfield is backing Jason Jenkins to take over the Springbok No.4 jersey from Eben Etzebeth one day.

Instead, a penalty was awarded to the home side Ulster which edged them into a 19-17 lead with 79 minutes on the clock.

The incident that turned the match occurred late in the game when Cardiff’s replacement prop – Rhys Carre – was adjudged to have deliberately knocked on a pass inside his own 22. The ball appeared to spin backwards and was gathered by his teammate Ben Donnel. Tinus de Beer’s upfield kick and subsequent recovery seemed to have secured a dramatic late win for Cardiff with a corner try from Cabango.

However, the try was overturned, Carre was sent to the sin-bin, and Ulster’s John Cooney kicked the decisive penalty.

Points Flow Chart

Ulster win +2
Time in lead
7
Mins in lead
63
9%
% Of Game In Lead
79%
82%
Possession Last 10 min
18%
3
Points Last 10 min
3

It was a bitter pill for Cardiff and their supporters to swallow, their ever-improving onfield performances once again not rewarded.

ADVERTISEMENT

A WRU match report headlined ‘Faletau injured again as Cardiff robbed of statement victory’ said that “Cardiff were robbed of a first win in Ulster for 14 years, and their first win of 2024, when the TMO joined forces with the referee to rule out a hat-trick try for Theo Cabanago and instead awarded a penalty to the home side on the 22 at the other end of the pitch.”

Adding to Cardiff’s woes was an injury to Wales and British & Irish Lions star Taulupe Faletau. The back row exited the game after only 30 minutes due to what was initially suspected to be a recurrence of a broken left arm. This injury occurred during the World Cup when Faletau was injured against Georgia.

His attempted comeback had already been delayed by a calf injury sustained during rehabilitation. The loss of Faletau, a veteran with over 100 caps for Wales, was a further blow to the team, especially with Wales head coach Warren Gatland keen on Faletau’s successful return to the field after a prolonged absence.

“He is being assessed after having a knock on his shoulder and we don’t know the extent of the injury yet,” said Cardiff head coach Matt Sherratt. “It is not the same injury from my understanding. Fingers crossed, it’s not too bad because he’s put a huge amount of effort in over the last six or seven months to come back.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I am gutted for Toby. I’m sure the boys will get around him.”

Related

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
B
Bull Shark 211 days ago

I hope WRU cops a 12 month ban.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 2 hours ago
France outwrestle All Blacks in titanic Test for one-point win

Yeah nar I pretty much agree with that sentiment, wasn't just about the lineout though.


Yeah, I think it's the future of SR, even TRC. Graham above just now posting about how good a night it was with a dbl header of ENGvSA and NZvFrance, and now I don't want to kick SA or Argentina out of TRC but it would be great if in this next of the woods 2 more top teams could come in to create more of these sort of nights (for rugby's appeal). Often Arg and SA and both travel here and you get those games but more often doesn't work out right.


Obviously a long way off but USA and Japan are the obvious two. First thing we need to do is get Eddie Jones kicked out of Japan so they can start improving again and then get a couple of US teams in SRP (even if one its just a US based and augmented Jaguares).


It will start off the whole conferences are crap debate again (which I will continue to argue vehemently against), but imagine a 6 team Pacific conference, Tokyo Sunwolves (drafted from Tokyo JRLO teams), Tokyo All Stars (made up of best remaining foreign players and overseas drafts), ALL Nihon (best of local non Tokyo based talent, inc China/Korea etc, with mainland Japan), a could of West Coast american franchises and perhaps a second self PI driven Hawai'i based team, or Jagaures. So I see a short NFL like 3 or 4 month comp as fitting best, maybe not even a full round, NZvAUSvPAC, all games taking place within a 6hr window. Model for NZ will definitely still require a competitive and funded NPC!


On the Crusaders, I liked last years ending with Grace on the bench (ovbiously form dependent but thats how it ended) and Lio-Willie at 8. I could have Blackadder trying to be a 7 but think balance will be used with him at 6 and Kellow as 7. Scott Barrett is an international 6 sized player. It is just NZ style/model that pushes him into the tight, I reckon he'd be a great loose player, and saders have Strange and Cahill as bigger players (plus that change could draw someone like Darry back). Same with Haig now, hes not grown yet but Barrett hight and been playing 6, now that the Highlanders have only chosen two locks he'll be playing lock, and that is going to change his growth trajectory massively, rather than seeing him grow like an International 6.

63 Go to comments
T
Tom 2 hours ago
England player ratings vs South Africa | 2024 Autumn Nations Series

Interesting post. I realise that try was down to Marcus Smith not Slade, this is why I mentioned that England's attack is completely reliant on Smith working miracles. Just wanted to highlight that Slade's little touch was classy and most English players would have cocked it up. Earl has gas, he's very athletic but Underhill is nailed on at 7 in my eyes though. They both need to be on the pitch so we need a tall 6 or 8 to complement them which we have in CCS and potentially Ollie Chessum. We also have young Henry Pollock who may be the 7 by the world cup.


The whole attack needs an overhaul but Richard Wigglesworth our attack coach was a very limited scrum half who excelled at box kicking and had no running game. Spent most of his career with Saracens who mauled, defended and set pieced their way to victory.... Which might have been ok if Felix Jones hadn't quit and been replaced by a guy who coaches Oyonnax who have one of the worst defences in the French 2nd division. I'm not too emotionally invested in England right now because this coaching setup isn't capable of winning anything.


England had no attack when they were winning under Eddie either. They battered teams with huge dominant tackles and won from pressure. The last time England had any creativity in attack was the Stuart Lancaster/Mike Catt era. They played some fantastic attacking rugby but results were mediocre, lots of 2nd place finishes in the 6N although it felt like we were building something special until we got brutally dumped out of our home world cup in the pool stage.

9 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Wales 'in one of their deepest holes for a long time' Wales 'in one of their deepest holes for a long time'
Search