The British and Irish Lions isn’t a participation event. It isn’t a parent and child egg-and-spoon race where everyone gets to have a go, and receives a medal. Whilst the Lions’ tour does of course involve an egg (in the shape of the ball), the comparison largely ends there.
The tour is of course a rare example in professional sport of any kind. There are very few fixtures or tours where four nations who are traditionally at each other’s throats remove the larynx grab and extend a handshake.
However, as inclusive as the wider experience is for players and supporters, that warm cuddly feeling doesn’t extend to the selection of the squad.
There will of course be a steady selection of English players, Scottish players and a light dusting of Welsh players, but 2025 will be Ireland’s tour and rightly so. And if you don’t like it, you may be in for a long summer.
Ireland have been the premier team in British and Irish rugby for a decade and it hasn’t even been close. They’ve been ranked the number one team in the world and have been South Africa’s stiffest competition in recent seasons. Any home nation that has parity with the Springboks deserves to dominate the Lions tour.
Many, of course, love to mention that Ireland still haven’t made it out of a Rugby World Cup quarter-final. And whilst it remains a monkey on their back, when you compare it to their consistency over the past three seasons, it remains more of a thumb monkey, than a raging baboon.
Other than South Africa, who have a depth chart so deep that it requires two copies of Microsoft Excel digitally sown together, Ireland have over the past four seasons had one of the deepest squads in world rugby – certainly amongst the home nations.
The Lions’ tour is two months of all or nothing. With the Lions, there is no tomorrow, only today.
Admittedly, some of their key assets are coming towards the end of their careers. Ireland’s tighthead and loosehead options, at times, look thinner than the material used on a shirt from Temu. From an Ireland perspective and the next Rugby World Cup cycle, Andy Farrell could have been a little quicker to blood players like Ulster’s Cormac Izuchukwu.
But that doesn’t affect the Lions tour. The Lions’ tour is two months of all or nothing. With the Lions, there is no tomorrow, only today.
Looking at social media you could argue it is English supporters who are having the greatest difficulty with the likely greenwash of the Lions. But much like the switch of European rugby from BT/TNT Sport to Premier Sports, England supporters can’t always have their own way. Over the many and varied tours, England have had many years of dominance in selection and rightly so. They have the player population, the clubs and the silverware to have warranted their domination of many a Lions tour. But like or it not, this squad will have a green hue.
There is a very high chance that the starting pack will contain three Irish in the front row (Tadhg Furlong, Dan Sheehan and Andrew Porter), one in the second row (Joe McCarthy or Tadhg Beirne), plus Caelan Doris and Josh van der Flier in the back row. Add in Jamison Gibson-Park, Hugo Keenan and Robbie Henshaw and that’s more green than you’d find in a 70s bathroom.
Perhaps the most important conversation regarding the Lions isn’t how many Irish players there will be, but how will they play – which will be key with regards to which non-Irish players are selected.
With the Wallabies pack (although improved) not at the level of the Boks or All Blacks, Andy Farrell has options afforded to him that arguably no other Lions coach has had. Does Farrell pick a team of forwards and backs to shock and destroy, or entertain?
Without doubt the clearest indicator of how Farrell plans on tackling the Wallabies will be his selection at 12
A key position with regard to how far the entertainment dial is twisted, is at 10, where Farrell has the luxury of playing a more running and passing focused 10, rather than a tactical kicking option – which is a rare luxury for the Lions.
If Farrell does select a more tactical option at 10, it presents a different type of problem in that Farrell Junior (Owen) is the best tactical 10 in the English game. The backrow options will also be a key indicator with regard to how he’s going to play. Does he opt for collisions/cleanout/jackal merchants, or more ball-playing options at six and seven?
But without doubt the clearest indicator of how Farrell plans on tackling the Wallabies will be his selection at 12. It’s either Bundee Aki or Sione Tuipulotu. This columnist would love to see Sione at 12. He does all of the Bundee stuff, but also a bit more of the bungee stuff, i.e. a more elastic approach to running, plus a passing and kicking game which allows him to keep the ball on the end of a piece of string.
With the potential of eight or nine Irish players in the starting Test team, let alone the wider squad, there will obviously be some fallout on social media. It’s what makes a Lions tour a Lions tour these days. Initially, we’re all wondering why our favourite ‘rugby children’ haven’t been selected. Then as soon as we see the squad in their blazers and ties, we all become happy ‘rugby parents’.
This summer’s tour will be as fantastic as ever and will once again represent something that is truly unique in rugby. But one thing that won’t be unique is the number of Irish lads in there. There’ll be a hell of a lot more than one.*
*This column is purely an opinion from the author. Arguably a poorly formed opinion. Please don’t burn his house down, or threaten his pets. Cheers, Paul
Go behind the scenes of both camps during the British and Irish Lions tour of South Africa in 2021. Binge watch exclusively on RugbyPass TV now
No arguments with the content of the article. The style of writing is another matter . The first paragraph almost put me off reading the rest of the article. Also the dig at English supporters is unnecessary.
Let’s see how the 6N goes, ireland weren’t looking too clever in the AIs and quite a few of their key players are reaching the back end of their careers. If they win the tournament then no doubt they will form the cornerstone of the squad. If England or Scotland manage to prevail against them, then different story.
Commercial considerations have to be made, too. The number of Irish in Australia is tiny - less than 100 thousand. Good luck trying to sell an Irish lions to 900,000+ English expatriates in Oz.
'Ireland have been the Premier team'. Sure thry have. Who could forget all their astonishing victories at the RWC.
I well remember their astonishing victory over SA, the eventual champs, in the last WC.
It should known as the Irish and Scottish lions England and Wales should give it to the inform sides no offence
Irish lions has a ring to it.
For my mind Ferguson should start at 3 but nobody talks about him. Furlong will make a great impact sub but Ferguson is an absolute monster. Russell also deserves the 10 jersey.
Why single out the English fans? In previous Lions tours its been the Irish and Welsh who have caused the most issues, particularly around the 2013 tour. Completely unnecessary.
England are always in wee celtic heads.
He explains that on social media it is the English fans (as he perceives, may not be fat) who are giving out most about the likely dominance of Irish players in the Lions. Now you, another England fan, are giving out about something that happened in 2013.
Because they are the biggest whingers
My Lions team
1. Porter
2. Sheehan
3. Furlong
4. Itoje
5. Beirne
6. J. Willis
7. Van der Flier
8. Doris (c)
9. Gibson Park
10. M. Smith
11. Lowe
12. Tuipolotu
13. Jones
14. Feyi Waboso
15. Keenan
16. Cowan Dickie
17. Ashman
18. Stuart
19. McCarthy
20. Earl
21. Mitchell
22. Russell
23. Van der Merwe
You appear to have 2 hookers on the bench
Solid. But I don’t see Marcus ahead of Russel or the Irish lads.
Nor van der Merwe behind Louw. But some nice selection headaches to have.
Van der Merwe on in place of Louw and Marcus off the bench at 23.
No Zander Fegerson? Would defo have Russel at 10. Is Keenan not on great form at the minute?
Spot on,bar Smyth..hmm, Russell might be a better bet.