Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'Bizarre' and 'confusing' State of Origin proposal bashed

(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

NSW and Queensland captains and coaches have questioned the NRL’s decision to move to a two-game Women’s State of Origin series from 2023.

ADVERTISEMENT

While the league fast-tracked its NRLW expansion on Wednesday in moving straight from six teams to 10 from next year, it hasn’t followed suit when it comes to Origin with the series to be two games – one up from this year.

Should a series be tied, the reigning champion will retain the shield in effect meaning this year’s clash in Canberra doubles as game one of next year’s series.

Related

NSW captain Kezie Apps questioned if that was the right way to decide such an important series.

“I would have preferred to jump straight to three – it can be 1-1 and then how do you decide?” Apps told AAP.

“It’s just bizarre having two games and it doesn’t really make sense to me, but hopefully it only lasts for one year and maybe the year after we can push that to three Origins just like the men.”

NSW coach Kylie Hilder echoed that sentiment, adding a 1-1 tie would create a “deflating” feeling for both sides.

“It’s great they’re increasing it from one to two, but I’m a bit confused by two,” she told AAP.

ADVERTISEMENT

“If you’re going to increase it, it should just go to three.

“It’ll be interesting next year if it happens to be 1-1, it’s very deflating for the girls to walk away from an origin series where there’s no winner, or the winner is going to be determined by the previous year’s winner.”

Maroons coach Tahnee Norris also admitted being confused by the move to two games.

“I was hoping for next year (to move to three-game series),” she said.

“This is the best of the best, this game, I think it deserves three … I was (confused) a little bit.

“If we win this year and get the first game next year, the second game is a dead rubber.

“We want to go three, I think it deserves it … people want to see the best of the best.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Queensland currently holds the shield, having won both 2020 and 2021’s games.

This year’s encounter takes place on June 24 at GIO Stadium.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 50 minutes ago
Let's be real about these All Blacks

I didn't really get the should tone from it, but maybe because I was just reading it as my own thoughts.


What I read it as was examples of how they played well enough in every game to be able to win it.


Yeah I dunno if Ben wouldn't see it that way (someone else would for sure need to point it out to him though), I'm more in the Ben not appreciating that those close losses werent one off scenarios camp. Sure you can look at dubious decisions causing them to have to play with 14 or 13 men at the death as viable reasons but even in the games they won without such difficulties they made a real struggle of it (compared to how good some of their first half play was). This kind of article where you trying to point out the 3 losses really would most likely have been wins only really makes sense/works when your other performances make those 3 games (or endings) stand out.


There might have been a sentence here and there to ensure some good comment numbers but when he's signing off the article by saying things like ..

Whilst these All Blacks aren’t blowing teams off the park like during the 2010s, they are nuggety and resourceful and don’t wilt. They are prepared to win the hard way, accumulating points by any means necessary.

and..

The other top sides in the world struggled to put them away. France and South Africa both could have well been defeated on home soil.

I don't really see it. Always making sure people are upto date with the SH standing/perspective! NZ went through some tough times with so many different perspectives and reasons why, but then it was.. amusing how.. behind everyone was once they turned a corner. More of these 'unfortunate' results returned against SA and France at the start of the RWC which made it extra tasty to catch other teams out when they did bring it. So that created some 'conscious' perspective that I just kept going and sharing re thoughts on similar predicaments of other teams, I had been really confident that Wallabies displays vs NZ were real, that the Argentines can backup their thing against Aus and SA (and so obviously the rest), and current one is that England are actually consistent and improving with their attack (which everyone should get onboard with), and I'm expecting a more dominant display against Japan (even though they should have more of their experienced internationals for this one) that highlights further growth from July. 👍

57 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Sharks captain Mbonambi addresses controversial incident with referee Sharks captain Mbonambi addresses controversial incident with referee
Search