The Six Nations is of course one of the top competitions in the Northern Hemisphere, and ever since its formation in 2000, it has continued to delight and entertain millions of rugby fans.
From Grand Slams, to last-minute wins and shock defeats, there’s a wealth of iconic moments we can look back over with great fondness. However, there have also been some incredible talents plying their trade in the Championship, which has led us to ask the question, ‘who would make the greatest Six Nations XV?’.
So to answer this question, we’ve asked the RugbyPass fanbase to use our ‘Six Nations: Greatest XV’ player picker to curate their own respective teams to then help determine who indeed makes the line-up. We also asked them to consider which coach and referee would also feature amongst the Six Nations GOATs.
The RugbyPass Fanbase’s Selections
Taking the data from the middle of March 2024, thousands of our fans believe this is the greatest Six Nations XV:
Let’s take a closer look at each selection and just how close some of these choices have been amongst our fanbase:
#1 Loosehead Prop - Jason Leonard (ENG)
A true great of England rugby and of course a Grand Slam winner in the Six Nations back in 2003, Jason Leonard is the preferred choice of 22% of our fans.
This was a close one though, with Wales’ Gethin Jenkins (21%), and Ireland’s Cian Healy (18%) not far behind him.
#2 Hooker - Keith Wood (IRE)
Despite only playing in the early years of the Six Nations, former Ireland captain Keith Wood, has clearly made a lasting impression and dominated as the hooker pick, with a huge 44% of the overall vote.
In second was another former Ireland captain, Rory Best with 23% and ex-France star Raphaël Ibañez was third with 10%.
#3 Tighthead Prop - Tadhg Furlong (IRE)
At tighthead prop there’s another dominant performance from an Ireland star, as Tadhg Furlong has 48% of the total vote. The three-time Triple Crown and two-time Six Nations Grand Slam winner also held off competition from the likes of Wales’ Adam Jones (21%) and Italy’s Martín Castrogiovanni (10%).
#4 Lock - Alun Wyn Jones (WAL)
A real legend of rugby union, the triple-Grand Slam-winning former Wales captain is of course the preferred option for the majority of our fans, taking over half the total vote (52%).
However, it was a two-horse race in some respects as former England captain, Martin Johnson, was second with 38% of all votes. Ireland’s Donncha O'Callaghan was third with 2%.
#5 Lock - Paul O’Connell (IRE)
Sticking with this trend of iconic, Grand Slam-winning captains absolutely dominating the picks for the lock positions, Ireland’s Paul O’Connell has easily taken this one with 68% of the votes.
England’s Courtney Lawes (16%) and France’s Fabien Pelous (5%) were a distant second and third choice.
#6 Openside Flanker - Sam Warburton (WAL)
Despite a lot of tough competition - and some debate about his position on the openside - a sizeable 48% of our fans have opted for Wales legend Sam Warburton here.
Another inspirational captain, Grand Slam and double-Six Nations winner, the runner up to Sam was France’s Serge Betsen with 16% and Ireland’s David Wallace was third with 8%.
Number 8 - Sergio Parisse (ITA)
The choice for the team’s Number 8 was another which has seen one individual wipe the floor with the competition. In this case it was Italy’s Sergio Parisse - someone who is widely considered to be one of the best in this position in modern rugby - with 43% of the vote.
France giant Sébastien Chabal came second with 19%, followed by England stalwart Lawrence Dallaglio with 12%.
#7 Blindside Flanker - Thierry Dusautoir (FRA)
At blindside our fans have decided it should be France rugby icon Thierry Dusautoir who has also run away with it by getting 43% of the total vote. Way behind Thierry with 15% and 14% respectively are Ireland’s Peter O'Mahony and England’s Richard Hill.
#9 Scrum Half - Antoine Dupont (FRA)
You can almost feel sorry for some of the other names in this list of players - as there are some real legends in there - but it’s been an absolute whitewash by French superstar Antoine Dupont who takes the scrum half position with a whopping 75% of the vote.
The runner up was Ireland’s Conor Murray (7%) and then Wales’ Mike Phillips (4%).
#10 Fly Half - Jonny Wilkinson (ENG)
The pick for fly half was a slightly closer affair, albeit another two-horse race between England and Ireland heroes Jonny Wilkinson and Johnny Sexton. It was the former in the end who 48% of the fans have chosen, compared to the 23% for Sexo. Scotland’s rugby union Messi, Finn Russell was the third most popular choice with 14%.
#12 Inside Centre - Jamie Roberts (WAL)
Yet another big name amongst the notable, decorated Welsh contingent in our fans’ picks is none other than the big man in the middle Jamie Roberts. Jamie secured 34% of the vote, with Ireland’s Bundee Aki coming second with 28% and France’s Yannick Jauzion in third place with 12%.
#13 Outside Centre - Brian O’Driscoll (IRE)
In some ways, we probably should’ve just pencilled this one in before our poll, but at outside centre - and with the biggest margin of any pick (80%) in our lists - is of course Ireland legend Brian O’Driscoll.
Way down in second and third were Wales’ Jonathan Davies (4%) and England’s Manu Tuilagi (3%).
#14 Right Wing - George North (WAL)
Continuing the trend of celebrated Wales players absolutely bossing it, on the right wing 43% of our fans chose the nation’s second-highest try scorer, George North. France’s Vincent Clerc (16%) and Ireland’s Tommy Bowe (14%) were second and third.
#11 Left Wing - Shane Williams (WAL)
It’s a similar story on the left wing, with 42% of fans selecting another big name in Welsh rugby union history in its record try scorer Shane Williams. France’s Damian Penaud and Scotland’s Duhan van der Merwe made up the second and third spots with 20% and 19% of the vote, respectively.
#15 Fullback - Jason Robinson (ENG)
At fullback is lightning-fast, 2001 and 2003 Six Nations-winning, England legend Jason Robinson, who was another popular choice for our fans, securing 52% of the overall vote.
In second place was Wales’ Leigh Halfpenny with 18% and Rob Kearney of Ireland came third with 11%.
Coach - Warren Gatland (NZ)
There are of course many highly decorated and well-respected rugby coaches who have graced the Six Nations, but it’s Warren Gatland who our fans feel is the greatest of all time.
Warren has secured 40% of all the votes, which is no mean feat. However, his record really does speak for itself and it’s clear the incredible work he has done with Wales during his respective tenures has left a lasting impression on many fans across the world.
Referee - Nigel Owens (WAL)
We can also say the same about Nigel Owens, who has been an overwhelmingly popular choice with our fans - as 75% have chosen him as the greatest Six Nations referee.
From his charismatic and respectful in-game thoughts and commentary, to the commanding approach he took when in charge of the whistle, it probably doesn’t come as too much of a surprise to see his name firmly on our selections.
Other notable stats from our fans’ picks
When we dig a bit further into our fans’ selections, we can see some interesting stats and data. Here are just a few examples:
- Wales has by far the largest proportion of representatives, making up a third of the side.
- Scotland is the only country from the competing nations not to feature a player.
- The closest fought position has been for loosehead prop, with only a few percentage points separating five players.
- Only one player from the XV is still playing international rugby union today, Antoine Dupont.
Be sure you have your say by signing up to RugbyPass and making your selections using our player picker.
Our experts’ selections
For balance, we’ve also got the views of a rugby legend from each of the competing six nations to get their expert views on who should make the cut.
Toby Flood | Mirco Bergamasco | Mathieu Bastareaud | Jamie Heaslip | Johnnie Beattie | Jamie Roberts
After speaking with a legend from each of the Six Nations, we’ve separated out each of their respective selections. Here’s the breakdown of each:
Toby Flood’s Six Nations Greatest XV
First on our rundown of rugby legends from each nation is England hero Toby Flood. A Six Nations winner in 2011 in his own right, here’s who made it into Toby’s ‘Greatest XV’:
#1 Loosehead Prop - Tom Smith (SCO)
“I really enjoyed watching Tom play, particularly how he went about his business. I doubt he will get picked by many people though, which is a shame because of how fantastic he actually was on the pitch.
“I reckon had he been in a different pack, he might have gained a bit more awareness from rugby fans - I should say he was also great to play against as well.”
#2 Hooker - Keith Wood (IRE)
“It’s hard to look past Keith, not just for what he did, but also for how he played and what he achieved. There’s some tough competition for this position too with the likes of Rory Best in there and Ken Owens who were obviously also both incredible players.”
#3 Tighthead Prop - Adam Jones (WAL)
“Adam was so, so important to that successful era for Wales and added so much value on and off the field. In many ways you have to be that good and be like that to play in this position and I don’t think he ever got enough credit for it.”
#4 Lock - Martin Johnson (ENG)
“I wish I could have Alun Wyn Jones in here too, but you just have to go for Johnno. As a captain - and he’s the captain of my picks here too - he would always pull you to the forefront, as he was an exceptional leader - which is something you just need in your side.”
#5 Lock - Courtney Lawes (ENG)
“I guess the popular pick for this is Paul O’Connell, but I’m going for Courtney Lawes. Personally speaking I think Courtney’s athleticism is what sets him apart here. His physicality was also something that could put him head and shoulders above others.”
#6 Openside Flanker - Sam Warburton (WAL)
“Sam wins this one. He was of course the Welsh captain, but was also an unbelievable player; you just need to look at how he trained and managed himself - in what he ate and how he behaved. This was also all while carrying a huge amount of weight on his shoulders by having to be such an important character and leader for Wales.”
Number 8 - Sergio Parisse (ITA)
“I think you have to go for Sergio because to be as good as he was, in a side that was often going backwards, just shows the class he possessed. For me, even though objectively he might not have all the stats to show how great he was, he was a shining light for Italy.”
#7 Blindside Flanker - Thierry Dusautoir (FRA)
“For his longevity, what he achieved and who he was, Thierry gets the pick for me here. He’s a fascinating character as well in that he didn’t say much, didn’t give much away, but come game day his eyes almost glazed over and he became this sort of unstoppable missile.”
#9 Scrum Half - Ben Youngs (ENG)
“Everyone’s going to pick Dupont here aren’t they [laughs]? Well, I’m picking Ben Youngs, but that’s because we’re mates; I’ve got to pick him! Everyone needs to be a little subjective at points here [laughs}.
“What I find interesting about Ben is that he went through what, six, seven iterations of English coaches? But he was still there in the setup and I think people have forgotten that. I mean, you don’t hang around that long unless you’re really, really good.
“Besides, if Ben ever saw this he’d get really pissed off with me [laughs]!”
#10 Fly Half - Jonny Wilkinson (ENG)
“Man this is a tough one. I love Frederic Michalak, he’s a genius, Finn Russell is exceptional too, but based on if this was a real XV, I’d need a goal kicker - so Jonny Wilkinson gets the nod.
“Look, I mean if you needed someone to carry the weight of this position here, Jonny can do it. You just look at what he achieved, especially in the Woodward era and it’s hard to ignore why he’s one of the best.”
#12 Inside Centre - Yannick Jauzion (FRA)
“I remember playing against Yannick and I’d never seen anything like it. He was unbelievable and has been exceptional for France. He’s really strong, huge, great at offloading the ball and was a top defender; also he’s one of the worst players to come up against, as he has everything.”
#13 Outside Centre - *Brian O’Driscoll (IRE)
“There’s one guy here [in the selections] and everyone else [laughs]. It’s funny as well because technically he didn’t really achieve that much, but I reckon most people would pick him here. From my point of view, for a period of time he was the greatest player in world rugby, let alone the Six Nations.”
*Toby did ask us to point out that he would’ve loved to have picked Manu Tuilagi here and that he believes Manu was one of the best centres England has ever had.
#14 Right Wing - Vincent Clerc (FRA)
“I’m going for Vincent Clerc because as well as being the nicest man in the world, he’s one of the best wingers France has ever had. It is also a personal choice this one as there are some other standout wingers who’ve played in the Six Nations, but Vincent just did things a little differently and in a really impassioned way that I loved to watch.”
#11 Left Wing - Shane Williams (WAL)
“There’s loads of competition for this position and it’s so hard to pick, but I think Shane is another guy who just defied the odds here and became an astonishingly good player.
“I’d have gone for Damian Penaud, but it’s maybe three years too early for him. Give it time and he’ll be in the list for sure.”
#15 Fullback - Jason Robinson (ENG)
“There are some unbelievable players here but I’m going to lean towards Jason Robinson, purely because of what he did for England when he came across to rugby union. He transformed the game with what he did and no one had ever seen anything like it before. He really was unique with what he accomplished and changed what we think about fullbacks.
“It’s funny, I can remember him doing pull ups with 60kg weights on his body without any issues; but that was him, athletic, powerful and just remarkable. As a person he’s great as well.”
Coach - Warren Gatland (NZ)
“There’s a lot of strong competition when it comes to coaches, but there’s something about Warren Gatland that just puts him ahead of the rest.
“If not for his longevity as a coach, but for the fact that he transformed Wales in his first era with them, particularly in the Six Nations. You could argue of course it’s not going as well for him now, but you just can’t overlook his success and there’s always that feeling that he can find a way to make something positive happen.”
Referee - Wayne Barnes (ENG)
“Not an easy pick I’ll admit; but I’ve got a real soft spot for Romain Poite and Nigel Owens is obviously great as well. However, I’m going to lean a little bit towards Wayne Barnes.
“I know him really well off the field and he was hugely helpful for me as a young player in terms of learning how I should talk and behave on the pitch. You knew where you stood with him too; he was never overly harsh or arrogant and could just manage a conversation with ease. As a ref he was always striving to learn and improve too, which says a lot. Plus he’s a great character, he’s had a wonderful career and is by far the best English referee the game has seen.”
Bonus question: What’s your greatest Six Nations venue?
“Hmm, well the Principality is - as we all know - a hotbed of drunken Welshness on a Saturday afternoon - which is always fun. Murrayfield I didn’t particularly enjoy playing at to be honest, I always found it quite a stale stadium and quite difficult to get yourself into the game there.
“My favourite non-traditional venue though would be Croke Park. I mean we only played there a couple of times and although we got battered in 2008 it was such a unique experience with the obvious political elements involved. Having the Six Nations being played there just showed how rugby and sport could navigate through everything else and although it was a bit tumultuous, it was hugely significant. But yes, we did get absolutely battered in that famous game.
“Speaking in a more traditional sense though, as an Englishman I’d say Twickenham. When that place is bouncing it’s incredible and if you speak to players from other countries they’ll invariably tell you how they find it quite an intimidating place to play.”
Mirco Bergamasco’s Six Nations Greatest XV
To get the Italian view, we spoke to Italy legend Mirco Bergamasco. Here are the selections he made and what he told us about why these particular players made his Six Nations XV:
#1 Loosehead Prop - Andrea Lo Cicero (ITA)
“He’s a friend and I of course know Andrea very well from playing with him in the national team - I’ve always called him the ‘lifestyle prop’, because rugby is his life!
“However, to me he changed the game in that position; on the field he was clear, strong and fast, despite his skinny legs and big upper body - he also loved to play with the ball. You can’t ignore the fact he also played for a long time as well; this was probably because he was so perfect and in so many ways a model professional from the beginning to the end of his career.”
#2 Hooker - Keith Wood (IRE)
“For me Keith was the most dynamic and precise player in this position, but also on the international stage during his time, you could say he was a little strange in the way he played. Hookers are of course very strong and fast and Keith set the trend for today’s style of play. So in other words, Keith was the leading reason why we see hookers playing the way we see them today.”
#3 Tighthead Prop - Tadhg Furlong (IRE)
“Tadhg has always impressed me because he’s very strong, he has an incredibly precise pass and he’s not just a prop that gets involved in the scrum, he’s one that plays the game. I’d say you’ll find it tough to find anyone who doesn’t agree it’s not great fun to watch him play rugby for Ireland.”
#4 Lock - Martin Johnson (ENG)
“For me the number four needs to do the ‘dirty job’, but with class - and this was what Martin did. The other big positive with him was how smart he was as a player too. I mean, you don’t get to be captain of England without such a high pedigree on the field.
“I remember playing against him back in 2002 and I definitely remember him. It was not fun [laughs}”
#5 Lock - Paul O’Connell (IRE)
“You can say the same here for Paul O’Connell, another player who did that ‘dirty job’ but with so much class. He was such a presence on the field it was almost impossible to not see him, if you get me? Super strong and super smart at the same time.”
#6 Openside Flanker - Mauro Bergamasco (ITA)
“Okay, he’s my brother, yes, but this isn’t the reason I’ve picked him.
“As a player on the field, mentally and physically he was so strong. I remember when he first started playing for Italy, it just seemed so easy for him. He knew his job and his objective and he just got on with it.
“The English press used to call him the ‘Italian Stallion’ not long after he started; I think this was because he was such a nightmare for the opposition, particularly the opposing number 10.”
Number 8 - Jamie Heaslip (IRE)
“Jamie was always very physical but so skillful with the ball in his hands; to me he’s the complete Number 8. No contest. I might be using this word a lot in my picks, but he’s just a class player.”
#7 Blindside Flanker - Thierry Dusautoir (FRA)
“Thierry wasn’t just a great man, he was a great rugby captain. All the guys would respect and listen to him, probably because he was just so smart about the game. But that’s just one of his attributes, he offered so much more and was a favourite of mine, for sure.”
#9 Scrum Half - Matt Dawson (ENG)
“I’ve picked Matt because for me was able to switch seamlessly between madness and order. He was intelligent, smart and a joy to watch play. You look at his credentials too and you can clearly see that he’s a real winner. He also played so well with Jonny Wilkinson.”
#10 Fly Half - Jonny Wilkinson (ENG)
“My last pick might give this one away, but I’ll go for Jonny Wilkinson because for me he wasn’t just perfect, he was a perfectionist. He inspired me with my own kicking game and just seeing him play helped give me a better understanding of how I should be on the field.”
#12 Inside Centre - Gordon D’Arcy (IRE)
“I’ve always liked Gordon as a player, especially alongside Brian O’Driscoll. He was such a companion to his team mates, he was always with you as a support during the game. I’m talking from personal experience here, as I saw all this when I played against him.”
#13 Outside Centre - Brian O’Driscoll (IRE)
“Easy choice here, although it’s hard to completely sum up why. I guess you could say he was always ‘the difference’ when you came up against an Ireland side he was playing with, you could just see it during the game. On the field it was at times impossible to play against him.”
#14 Right Wing - George North (WAL)
“George for me is an incredible athlete and a great player. Again, I was lucky enough to play against him and I got a real appreciation of just how tall and fast he could be and just how skillful he could be. He hardly ever got knocked down as well and as you might imagine that was pretty hard to play against.
“He’s another person you could say would be ‘the difference’ when he pulls on the Wales jersey.”
#11 Left Wing - Christophe Dominici (FRA)
“It was an honour to play against Christophe and of course play alongside him. He gave everything when playing for France and was a trailblazer for giving more support to the team, despite being on the wing.
A true competitor, whether it was training or a real match, he would always try to push himself beyond his limits; he just wanted to win. He wasn’t the tallest but was so dynamic and rapid.”
#15 Fullback - Leigh Halfpenny (WAL)
“Leigh was another shorter player in stature, but despite this he was explosive, smart, precise and obviously a great kicker too. Another ‘complete’ player and every time he played for Wales, he was their ‘X-factor’ without a doubt.”
Coach - Fabien Galthié (FRA)
“Fabien was a tough talker, but I have to thank him for giving me lots of guidance, advice and pointers on the game when he coached me. You can’t deny how much of an impact he’s had on the current France team too; they’ve improved so much under his stewardship.”
Referee - Nigel Owens (WAL)
“Some ex-players may struggle to pick a referee but not me [laughs]. It’s Nigel Owens because he was super serious when he refereed, but could be super funny when he expressed himself too. He was always able to control the game and is hands down the best referee - not just in the Six Nations, but in international rugby.”
Bonus question: What’s your greatest Six Nations venue?
“This might not be a popular choice, but for me it’s the venue that Italy used before the Stadio Olimpico, the Stadio Flaminio. You’d get the fans really close to the pitch and that made such a difference; you’d feel like they were pushing you more to play better and there’s no feeling like it.
“I would say though that the Principality Stadium is really special too for the Six Nations. The Welsh fans are amazing and even on the bus entering the stadium you could just feel the excitement and anticipation. For me you also get a similar feeling from the fans there as you do at the Stadio Flaminio.”
Mathieu Bastareaud’s Six Nations Greatest XV
We also spoke with a true great of French rugby and a Six Nations winner in 2010 - the iconic Mathieu Bastareaud - to see who would make it into his Six Nations Greatest XV. Here are Basta’s choices:
#1 Loosehead Prop - Andrew Sheridan (ENG)
“I played with Andrew in Toulon and the guy’s just a big truck. The scrum was everything for him and although I’m no expert in this position, I just know that nobody wanted to play against him, be it in the Top 14 or Six Nations. I count myself lucky I didn’t have to play against him [laughs].”
#2 Hooker - Rory Best (IRE)
“If I follow my heart it’s Guilhem Guirado, he’s a close friend and the godfather of my son, so I don’t want to be in trouble with him [laughs]. However, for the sake of my selections, I’ll have to go with Rory Best. He’s someone who is a great leader and who does this difficult job perfectly, every time he plays.”
#3 Tighthead Prop - Tadhg Furlong (IRE)
“Tadhg is just ‘woah!’ - he’s a machine. It’s like he can just do whatever he wants with the ball; I once saw him pull off a 20-metre pass, which for a prop is just insane. He’s such a talented player and has some great footwork for such a big guy.”
#4 Lock - Alun Wyn Jones (WAL)
“My good friend Alun! I have the pleasure to have him here in Toulon with me helping with the team and before this I had played against him and I of course appreciated his talent for Wales, but now I see just how brilliant he is.
“He just wants to help and despite his incredible record as a player he is so humble. A great leader, great player and simply one of the greats.”
#5 Lock - Paul O’Connell (IRE)
“Paul is a legend, it’s as simple as that. A true warrior for Ireland and I loved to watch him play - not against him though! I’ve never seen such fighting spirit from a player.”
#6 Openside Flanker - Serge Betsen (FRA)
“It’s Serge for me because everyone was scared of him; he was a beast. We all remember a game he had against England in 2002 where he just focused on Jonny [Wilkinson] and he just made it a nightmare for him. A top tackler and he never seemed to get tired; Serge is a great person too.”
Number 8 - Sergio Parisse (ITA)
“Sergio made this position his own thanks to his amazing skills as a Number 8. I remember a particularly dominant performance in the Six Nations against England years ago that summed him up. Great with the ball, great kicking and great in the lineout.
“I’m a big fan of Lawrence Dallaglio as well, so this one was a close one.”
#7 Blindside Flanker - Thierry Dusautoir (FRA)
“My captain, my captain! Thierry wasn’t just an amazing player, he was a man you’d want to follow. I remember the speeches he would give before a game would make you want to put your life and your body on the line for him. Without a doubt he’s one of the greatest players I’ve ever seen.
It’s funny that outside of the game he wouldn’t talk a lot and it was like he had an on/off switch that would click into action as soon as he was on the pitch. But even though he didn’t say much I remember when I was young - and maybe not as focussed as I should’ve been during training [laughs] - Thierry would just look at you and your head would go down out of fear [laughs].”
#9 Scrum Half - Antoine Dupont (FRA)
“Easy choice here. He’s the best scrum half we’ve ever seen - and he’s still young! I remember Antoine’s debut for France as well and we all knew he was special. Right kick, left kick, passing, whatever it is, he finds it so simple. It says a lot when teams have to make a strategy against him.”
#10 Fly Half - Jonny Wilkinson (ENG)
“Probably the most difficult choice for me here, but I’ve gone with Jonny Wilkinson. I’ve also had the privilege of playing with him and he was just perfect with his kicking and defence.
“It was a dream to play with him and he could even guide you in training on where exactly he wanted the ball and when. I never thought watching him in 2003 that I’d be playing with him 10 years later.”
#12 Inside Centre - Yannick Jauzion (FRA)
“He’s easily the best inside centre I’ve had the privilege to have played with on the international stage. I learned so much from him and I think in the history of the Six Nations he’s certainly one of the best 12s, if not the best.
“I’m sorry to my good friend Wesley Fofana [laughs].”
#13 Outside Centre - Brian O’Driscoll (IRE)
“There are so many good players who could go here, but for my squad - maybe after me [laughs] - it’s Brian O’Driscoll for sure. He was just magic with the ball, a formidable opponent, a great leader and captain, the list goes on. Brian is someone where I will sit and watch his international highlights and just be like ‘woah, he’s amazing!’, you know?”
#14 Right Wing - George North (WAL)
“He’s another where I just love the way he plays. We need big players on the wing who are good with the high ball, which is George all over. Also if we needed him to, he could play centre [laughs]!”
#11 Left Wing - Christophe Dominici (FRA)
“Hmmm, left wing… I’ll put Christophe Dominici. He coached me for a season in Paris and he was like a father to me and in his memory I want him in my team. But also he was of course one of the best and was often a match winner; he was magical for the French team, not just in the Six Nations either.”
#15 Fullback - Stuart Hogg (SCO)
“This was a tough one and I nearly went with Jason Robinson, but for me it’s Stuart Hogg. I loved how he used to play - not against us mind - but he’s just one of the greatest fullbacks of all time. He’s fast, great at kicking and when he has the ball he’s always a danger for the opposition.”
Coach - Warren Gatland (NZ)
“It was a very difficult decision this one, but I’m going for Warren Gatland. His abilities and record as a coach are both hugely impressive and he’s turned so many sides around, especially with Wales. He can turn a team into a real surprise outfit.”
Referee - Nigel Owens (WAL)
“Hmmm, it has to be Nigel Owens. Every time I was reffed by him it was a pleasure and I like the fact that he always talks to the players and tries to create a good relationship with you - and this is something we like as players too.”
Bonus question: What’s your greatest Six Nations venue?
“I’d say the Principality Stadium. It’s a place I loved to play with France, especially during the Six Nations.
“I remember the Grand Slam we won in 2010, the match here was the most difficult for me out of all the games we played, and it was because the roof was closed and it just made it so much more intimidating. Also the fans are so close to you too which just adds to the intensity!
“I’ll give a special mention to Murrayfield though, as I scored my first two tries for France there; so great memories for me [laughs].”
Jamie Heaslip’s Six Nations Greatest XV
To represent Ireland, who better than triple Six Nations winner - including a Grand Slam in 2009 - Jamie Heaslip? Here are Jamie’s selections:
#1 Loosehead Prop - Gethin Jenkins (WAL)
“Yeah, Cian might kill me for this one [laughs], but with Geth, beyond just being massive, he kind of did things you wouldn’t expect a loosehead to do. But I picked him more because defensively you didn’t have to worry with him; he was agile for such a big man and he had a crazy ability to get up and over the ball.
“Playing against Wales, he was a nightmare when you were up against him. If you were sloppy in the ruck, he was there, on you. His poach rate was insane and he was a key part of a dominant Wales team.”
#2 Hooker - Jamie George (ENG)
“Jamie…well you look at him and while he’s maybe the shape of a traditional hooker [laughs], he does so much more than just putting the ball in the lineout and scrummaging.
“Really good hands, feet, great defensively and yeah, this might be a little leftfield with Jamie but that’s what I like; players who change the status quo. It’s a big shout for me as Keith Wood is in there too.”
#3 Tighthead Prop - Tadhg Furlong (IRE)
“I was a little unsure on this one at first, but Tadhg is one of the best tightheads in the world on his day. You know, when do you see a prop sidestepping a 10 at Murrayfield? When do you see a prop throwing out a 20-metre pass? All that and he can do his core role really well.
“I just think he’s another player who has changed how this position is played and when people are picking tightheads now, you look at Tadhg and say ‘that’s the standard now’.”
#4 Lock - Martin Johnson (ENG)
“Johnno led that really dominant England team during his time and this is what sealed the deal for me. I doubt there’ll be many arguments amongst people about who goes in at 4 here.”
#5 Lock - Paul O’Connell (IRE)
“Another icon of the game. I played with Paulie a lot and I can tell you his focus and detail on the game was second to none. He did the basics, but he did them so well.
“He would tell you himself he wasn’t the most skilled player, but is instead one who led by example. Also the older he got the more he adapted his game to give himself more longevity, which is testament to his abilities.
“Off the field he was an unbelievable professional too; in my book no one comes close in this position if I’m honest.”
#6 Openside Flanker - Olivier Magne (FRA)
“For me growing up, Olivier was just a legend. He did more than what a traditional 7 at the time would do; so be an absolute workhorse, tackle like a demon and poach everything. This guy was really athletic too and I learned a lot from his game.”
Number 8 - Taulupe Faletau (WAL)
“I remember Taulupe coming through playing with the Dragons and you could see how balanced he was as a Number 8. By this I mean he could read the game really well, be solid defensively and with the ball in hand not just be a big, massive lad who would bowl you over, but be able to pass and offload.
“He’s a class operator with a massive work capacity and he won’t just wait for the ball to come to him, he’ll roll his sleeves up and do the dirty work - and not a lot of 8s will do this. He stood out in a great Welsh team too.”
#7 Blindside Flanker - Thierry Dusautoir (FRA)
“Like, what a hero and an incredibly nice fella. He had a great way around him on the field too in that you could batter him and he wouldn’t react, but would just keep coming and coming. Relentless. He was a great leader too and another player I wish I’d played with rather than against.
“He’s not big size wise, but I swear, he hits so hard, so, so hard [laughs]. I’m not sure if it’s his technique or whatnot, but jeez. Also when you tackled him it was like tackling a brick.”
#9 Scrum Half - Mike Phillips (WAL)
“It’s like playing with a back row, Mike’s unbelievable. I probably appreciated his ability more when I played with him in 2009, but he had a great passing game and kicking game and was in general just such a nightmare to defend against in the ruck.
“Just so big, so quick and agile with so many strings to his bow. I hope he’s a popular choice in this list as he’s great craic too - on and off the field. An absolute wild man.”
#10 Fly Half - Jonny Wilkinson (ENG)
“Sorry Sexo…he’s going to hate me for this one [laughs]... but I’ve gone for Jonny Wilkinson because the consistent level of excellence that he brought to this position is unsurpassed. You can’t argue with his achievements either, facts are the facts.
“That group of players he was with when they got the Grand Slam before the World Cup just saw them chalking off all these milestones, and Jonny was the core of it all.”
#12 Inside Centre - Yannick Jauzion (FRA)
“Did I play against him? I think I might have in like 2006 in France, but sadly I never played against him at international level. But I remember watching him growing up being like ‘who is this mutant in the centre, who is also light on his feet and a great distributor?’. He’s another player who transformed how we see that position, like totally breaking the mould of how an inside centre should be, you know? I’ve never met him properly, but what a legend.”
#13 Outside Centre - Brian O’Driscoll (IRE)
“I mean, he’s an icon of the game; there are very few players who can be globally recognised like Brian. He changed the expectations of that position forever and while there might technically be ‘better’ players now, he transformed how you play the game there.
“Everyone will talk about his attacking prowess and how he was a great reader of the game, but how he commanded such an amount of space when defending was unreal.
“It was an unbelievable pleasure to have played with him and I reckon anyone who has - or has come up against him - will have nothing but respect for Brian.”
#14 Right Wing - Vincent Clerc (FRA)
“Yeah, he’s just class. He optimised French flair, was a great finisher and always a nuisance to defend against. I never got to play for the Barbarians, but I always wish I could’ve played with him. He was so unique with an almost unstructured way of playing and that has definitely influenced the French backs of today.”
#11 Left Wing - Christophe Dominici (FRA)
“From the outside looking in, he was just class. Another with bags of French flair and had all the things you want from an outside back, speed, agility, panache - if that’s the right word? [laughs]. I just loved watching him play, it’s as simple as that.”
#15 Fullback - Leigh Halfpenny (WAL)
“My teammate Rob Kearney is not going to be happy with me, but I think Leigh brought a level of consistency to this position that we hadn’t seen for a long time. Also to do it at such a level with Wales, accomplish so much and do it for so long is unbelievable.
“We know how good he is with his boot, but he excelled in other areas too and I probably didn’t realise just how good he was until I toured with him in 2013. This really shed a light on it for me. He ain’t tall either and is unassuming, but he made every inch of himself count on that field.”
Coach - Joe Schmidt (NZ)
“Well call me biassed if you want, but I think from a high level point of view and considering that Ireland hadn’t won anything since 2009, Joe had an immediate impact and turned us around to get back-to-back Six Nations wins. This had never been done before and then he got us to number one in the world.
“He transformed how Ireland played to an almost ruthless efficiency - and to do all this with such a small player pool is why I’d rank him up there as the best. Personally speaking he also made me a much better, professional rugby player.”
Referee - Nigel Owens (WAL)
“Nigel is known for his witty comments on the field, particularly with his ref mics, but I don’t think he gets enough credit for how he actually controls the game.
“You always knew where you stood with him, he always had a great manner with which he communicated, he was rooted in the ethics of the game - which is really important - and I just think he always wanted to create a free-flowing game where he didn’t need to get involved as much. Nigel knew what a good game felt like to the audience and the players too.
He was always someone you could talk to off the field as well, whether it was about his decisions or his views of the game. A top man.”
Bonus question: What’s your greatest Six Nations venue?
“The old Lansdowne Road - make sure you mention it’s the old one! I love the place, you had the wild terraces, the crowd were so on top of you as well.
“It’s also where I got my first cap and I was lucky enough to play in the last international and club games there, in fact I think I got the last try ever there - I know I’m completely and utterly biassed here, but it’s pretty iconic in my eyes.
“The new stadium is still pretty vocal though and because it’s in the city everyone can walk there and hit the pubs on the way!”
Johnnie Beattie’s Six Nations Greatest XV
For the Scottish perspective we spoke with RugbyPass’ very own former Scotland international, Johnnie Beattie. Here are Johnnie’s picks:
#1 Loosehead Prop - Tom Smith (SCO)
“Tom was a guy I watched growing up, and for me, was as ‘all-round’ a player as you could be. Although he wasn’t huge, every time he stepped onto the field he was monumental for Scottish rugby, in particular in that he held up his side of the scrum and was just an incredibly tough human being. Everyone says he was an outstanding teammate and bloke. Top class.”
#2 Hooker - Keith Wood (IRE)
“Keith is another guy I absolutely loved watching growing up, as he got you excited about the game and up and out of your seat. He had everything you’d want to have: power, pace, skill, fireworks, set-piece quality, but he’d then do loads of other things you didn’t expect. He always made a difference for Ireland.”
#3 Tighthead Prop - Nicolas Mas (FRA)
“This might be a bit of a leftfield choice for some, but Nicolas was a teammate of mine at Montpellier and his playing nickname was ‘the low table’, because even though he wasn’t a big bloke, he couldn’t be moved. He was so powerful and explosive and it was so cool to have him on your team. Definitely a cornerstone of the French side during his era.”
#4 Lock - Martin Johnson (ENG)
“I’ll go for Johnno. He wouldn’t be the most talented, but you need a real leader and a personality who can bring different people together - and that’s just what he did. He was pretty much the man, wasn’t he? A gnarly hard bastard, but that’s what you need on the field.”
#5 Lock - *Paul O’Connell (IRE)
“Paul is probably the best lock that’s ever been produced in modern day rugby. He could do everything; call and run a smart lineout, be disruptive, read the opposition ball and he could just drive the Ireland side up the field.
“His longevity and mental toughness were always plain to see on the field and he’s bringing the latter to Ireland now as a coach.”
*Johnnie also wanted us to explain that ideally Fabien Pelous would be his #4 to go with Paul here!
**We also asked Johnnie who he would like to captain this XV and he told us that Paul and Johnno could go into a room, have a fight, and then whoever wins can be the captain.
#6 Openside Flanker - David Wallace (IRE)
“David was… how do I put this? I’d just describe it as ‘farmer strength’ [laughs]. But seriously he was such a power-athlete and he had impeccable timing. His attack play was top, as was his poaching ability. For Ireland he also had this knack of creating carnage with and without the ball.”
Number 8 - Lawrence Dallaglio (ENG)
“I’m not sure I ever got to play against him, but Lawrence really changed things up and broke the mould. He just had a level of physicality above everyone else and was a real force of nature.
“He also added real excitement, energy and dynamism whenever he played for England - and this was something we really hadn’t seen in a Number 8 before; it was almost freakish.”
#7 Blindside Flanker - *Thierry Dusautoir (FRA)
“I remember playing against him as a young pro and he had this ‘fighting’ almost martial arts-like style - so had a different way of bringing people to the deck. He was a trailblazer with the things we tend to talk about more today, like line speed and causing chaos by getting off the mark so quickly.
“People don’t appreciate how big he was either; just a solid beast of a man with a huge engine on him. He was also a leader with a go-getter attitude, which was just another of his many attributes.”
*Johnnie did say that he would’ve ideally had Sean O’Brien in his side as well as his number 6, but ultimately opted for Thierry here.
#9 Scrum Half - Antoine Dupont (FRA)
“Right now he’s the best player in the world and I remember playing with him when he was just 17 and he made the rest of us look like we’d never played rugby before.
“He could just do everything! Physically as well he was just as good back then as he is now; almost Herculean. Antoine is one of the best rugby players we’ll ever see and it was a privilege to have played with him. It might be cliche to say but he’s also such a good bloke.
“Mike Phillips takes second place though for the sheer comedy value.”
#10 Fly Half - Jonny Wilkinson (ENG)
“I found this the hardest to choose as there are so many good players here… but Jonny Wilkinson edges it as he was the complete package. Honourable mentions to Johnny Sexton and Finn Russell though, as they’re both incredible.
“Jonny also always had a desire to improve and get better which you saw in his goal kicking as his career went on - and in his defensive work too. Jonny has also won games single-handedly from his own determination, so yeah he gets in.”
#12 Inside Centre - Yannick Jauzion (FRA)
“Yannick was an absolute beast; a natural dump truck of a man. He was also the first ‘modern’ centre in that he was bigger than most back rows, but had all the nuance and skillset of a backline player. This meant he could dominate going forward and he was really difficult to bring down. He had that real flair about him as well.”
#13 Outside Centre - Brian O’Driscoll (IRE)
“BOD of course stands head and shoulders above them all. This is one of the hardest positions to defend on the field and if you think back to his early days you’d struggle to recall any mistakes he ever made. Tough as teeth.
“He generated so many moments of magic for Ireland and was just one of those blokes that just moved differently to everyone else when he played; a little quicker, a little sharper, smarter and he was so robust even though he’s not that tall.”
#14 Right Wing - Vincent Clerc (FRA)
“In a team that probably wasn’t set up as well as the French side is now, he scored an outrageous number of tries for France and Toulouse. He was a ridiculous athlete with his turn of pace and precision - and he had real longevity on top of it all.”
#11 Left Wing - Damian Penaud (FRA)
“Damian’s character has been described like Steve Stifler from American Pie, which makes it even more ironic that he’s such a good athlete! He’s what, six foot four? But can run, chip, step, fend, bump and he’s adding nuance to the game with things like crossfield kicks that bring people in around him.
“The French boys will also tell you how fun he is to be around too, which makes a big difference. He doesn’t take himself too seriously though for one of the most talented and gifted players that we’ve ever seen in rugby.”
#15 Fullback - Jason Robinson (ENG)
"He was electric from the moment he crossed over from League. He single-handedly won England and the Lions games, often with his outrageous acceleration and a sidestep that could make the best players in the world look average.
"So quick, so evasive and he could create something from absolutely nothing. He’d be one of the best back three players to have played the game and brought a spark every time he touched the ball."
Coach - Andy Farrell (ENG)
“Fabien Galthié is the best coach I ever got to work with across 16 years of professional rugby. He was the best attack coach, the best with small details and the technical aspects, strategy, you name it. He also helped me elevate my game to another level - BUT - I haven’t picked him… I’ve gone with Andy Farrell.
“This is because I’ve a real appreciation for the way his Irish team are set up, how they attack, how they defend, how they create great plays from nothing and he’s maintained their success after Joe Schmidt. Andy is obviously the new Lions coach as well and he’s fostering an incredible environment, so he takes it for me.”
Referee - Jonathan Kaplan (SA)
“This is a bit of a random pick, but I bumped into Jonathan in Bermuda at a breakfast buffet in a hotel when on holiday and although I’d always enjoyed his on-field chat from afar, at this buffet I actually got sat down and started properly talking to him.
“After chatting all things rugby with him, I found out that he was the referee in the game against Ireland in 2010 where I scored a try and he told me he remembered how happy I was about it [laughs]. So that’s why he’s my favourite!
“But he’s also a good egg, he’s great with the whistle and is an all-round good bloke, but most referees are - as you’ll see in the Whistleblowers documentary.”
Bonus question: what’s your greatest Six Nations venue?
“We’re really spoiled, as there are so many top venues and each offers its own unique experience - although Twickenham has always been a bit too posh for me [laughs].
“Obviously the one that holds the most memories for me is Murrayfield. It’s great because it’s in the city centre as well so you can have a great social experience before the game; all the banter between fans just makes it a perfect day out.”
Jamie Roberts’ Six Nations Greatest XV
We had the privilege of speaking with one of the true greats of Welsh rugby union and indeed Wales’ Six Nations history, the one and only Jamie Roberts. Here are Jamie’s picks…
#1 Loosehead Prop - Gethin Jenkins (WAL)
“Gethin wins this, purely because he was an absolute machine who redefined the role of the loosehead prop. He was like an extra flanker on the field, plus there was his ability on the ball, his defensive qualities, his leadership qualities; just an all-round and complete rugby player. He had beautiful hands too and I learned a lot from him as a young player.
“If I had to pick a second, it’d be Cian Healy; someone I had the pleasure to play against and with on the Lions tour in 2013. Definitely a similar mould to Gethin as a complete player too.”
#2 Hooker - Rory Best (IRE)
“This is bloody hard this, particularly within the Six Nations. I mean Keith Wood was an immense player for Ireland, but I think it’s another Irishman who gets this - namely Rory Best.
“He was a leader in that Irish side that won all those Six Nations titles and look how many tests he’s played; says it all really. He was tough to play against as well and we crossed paths many times and he was unbelievably solid in the set piece, which is what you want from your hooker.
“Just behind him in second I’ll go for Raphaël Ibañez. I grew up watching him in the Six Nations in that brilliant, title-winning French side in the noughties and he was a big part of their success.”
#3 Tighthead Prop - Tadhg Furlong (IRE)
“My God, this is tough isn’t it? Hmmm, there are so many quality players you can have here. At a push, I’ll go Tadhg Furlong for the win and Adam Jones in a close second.
“Furlong is pretty formidable for Ireland and I can imagine he’s a popular choice. He clinches it for his all-round ability as a tighthead prop. Similar to Gethin Jenkins he’s redefined that role.
“It’s very hard for me to leave Adam out though as I know how important he was to Wales’ success.”
#4 Lock - Alun Wyn Jones (WAL)
“Alun Wyn Jones takes this one and it’s hard to disagree with that, surely?
“He’s another person I’ve played with and objectively you have to appreciate the heights he hit in the Six Nations. Whether it’s how he led the Wales side to Grand Slams, his longevity or how he set a standard in rugby; it speaks for itself. He’s a special and iconic Welsh player.
“I’d probably have Martin Johnson in second here. He’s an absolute warrior.”
#5 Lock - Paul O’Connell (IRE)
“Paul is a guy I played against and he was a thorn in our side for many years. He had amazing longevity, with real skill and he was an inspiration for Ireland. In the line out, he was unplayable at times, so yeah, he takes this one for me.
“I’d also say Fabien Pelous would be my second choice. He was just class and he had a bigger jaw than me, which is something I have to admire [laughs]!”
#6 Openside Flanker - Sam Warburton (WAL)
“Well, honestly, it’s a challenge for me to separate three Welshmen here [Sam Warburton, Justin Tipuric and Martyn Williams], do I have to pick just one [laughs]?
“Hmmm, okay I’ll go for Sam Warbuton then. He was a great leader for Wales and you know I’m speaking from my generation of players here and he was instrumental in helping us win back-to-back titles. It’s funny as well because he’s a gentle giant off the field - well, I say ‘giant’, he’s not that tall - and he’s really down to earth. But then get him on the pitch and he’s pretty ferocious and an unbelievable competitor.
“Martyn Williams and Justin Tipuric were more all-rounders and probably more skillful players than Sam, but as a physical competitor at the breakdown, he was formidable; he definitely set the tone for our physicality as a side.”
Number 8 - Sergio Parisse (ITA)
“It’s hard to look past Sergio…but with Taulupe Faletau and Billy Vunipola tied very closely behind for second.
“During the Six Nations Sergio has been pretty iconic, and again, in a team that struggled to win test matches, he’s been such a stand out player. So much so we always had to watch him closely.”
#7 Blindside Flanker - Thierry Dusautoir (FRA)
“I’m going to say - and this isn’t solely on titles - Dusautoir. He was an absolute warrior through the noughties for France. I grew up admiring his work rate, his ability on the ball, his carry and tackle, but also I was occasionally on the receiving end of some of these and it’s not fun I can tell you that [laughs].
“You look at some of the other names you have in here though and I’m not going to name a second, it’s just too hard!”
#9 Scrum Half - Mike Phillips (WAL)
“Another tough one… very difficult. My gut feeling is between Phillips and Dupont, but it’s easy to forget DuPont is still so young!
“Don’t get me wrong, he’s obviously an amazing player, but if we’re talking about the Six Nations, he’s not been around that long - despite how influential he’s been.
“Whereas Mike has won multiple titles and it’s hard to look past his levels of success and influence. He was also a warrior on the field and was a guy you’d always want in the team. Super talented and had it all, almost like having an extra back rower; he was great to have as a teammate too.”
#10 Fly Half - Johnny Sexton (IRE)
“I’ll go Johnny Sexton, purely for that outrageous drop goal in Paris! That was unlike anything I’ve ever seen in the Six Nations. Other than that, I was lucky enough to play with him for a few years and he was just so good.
“He was also a leader in that Irish team, especially with how he took over from Ronan O’Gara and he had a hunger and real desire to win and excel. So amongst some unbelievable players here, Sexton clinches it.
“I’m not even going to bother trying to decide on a second place there [laughs].”
#12 Inside Centre - Yannick Jauzion (FRA)
“Has anyone picked me [laughs]? Nah, in all seriousness I’m going Yannick.
“As a complete player and a 12, he had so much success with France in the noughties and he was a big part of that. He could carry, defend, play the ball and he was the silkiest of runners; as an inside centre he was someone I looked to as a real specialist.
“Close behind Yannick would be Gordon D’Arcy. He was someone I really remember having to face off against in my career; a really, really tough customer.”
#13 Outside Centre - Brian O’Driscoll (IRE)
“Brian takes this, doesn’t he? BOD was so influential in that Irish jersey and not just in the Six Nations. We crossed paths a few times and played together in the Lions and he was super hard to contain; a very, very smart player. You always felt like he was one step ahead of you.
“But this is another position where I can’t pick a second… Brian all day, everyone else second.”
#14 Right Wing - Vincent Clerc (FRA)
“I’m going for Vincent Clerc here. I think he was an unbelievable player and his try scoring record was fantastic. His finishing ability was incredible and he was just so bloody good to watch.
“I’d say George North and Tommy Bowe would be a close joint-second as top players in their own right.”
#11 Left Wing - Shane Williams (WAL)
“Shane all day long. I get asked who the best player I’ve ever played with was and it’s Shane Williams, every time.
“Just his ability to win a rugby match on his own and the ability to influence a game so much by doing something special; I don’t think many players can do that, certainly not in the Six Nations. There was an unspoken rule when he played for Wales of ‘get the ball to Shane’, so yeah, he definitely wins this one.
“To pick a second place, I’d say Keith Earls. He was a bloody hard player to come up against!”
#15 Fullback - Jason Robinson (ENG)
“Jason stands out. The impact he had coming over to union was pretty special.
“As a fullback though he was absolutely frightening. I’d love to see him play now as he would suit the modern game unbelievably well. I also think he was the most devastating open field runner in the game.
Halfpenny was a wonderful player to have in your side. Pace to burn, safe as houses in defence and under the high ball as well as metronomic off the tee, so he’s a very close second!
Coach - Warren Gatland (NZ)
"When we're talking about the Six Nations, it's between Gatland and Woodward here, but I guess people can forget how impressive Warren's record is in the Six Nations.
"He worked some real magic in a Welsh side that was always punching above our weight. Some might say this is the Welshman in me picking him here, but I just appreciate how important he's been to Welsh rugby union and fans, as well as the success he's brought."
Referee – Nigel Owens (WAL)
"It's weird because Nigel never reffed me in a test because he obviously wasn't allowed to as a fellow Welshman, so it's very hard to draw from my own experiences to pick him.
"It's another bloody hard one this anyway and it's neck and neck between Nigel and Wayne Barnes, but my red-tinted glasses mean Nigel sneaks it!"
Bonus question: What's your greatest Six Nations venue?
"Well, I'll obviously have to be an unbiased Welshman here [laughs] and pick the Principality. Winner hands down.
"I think it's the best rugby stadium in the world and I've played all over the world! It has an incredible atmosphere and I don't think anything comes close, especially when the roof is closed.
"My second behind this though would be the Stade de France. I used to love playing there with late kick-offs on a Friday or Saturday night, as again the atmosphere was incredible there too. Also, I love the history of the venue, including all those iconic moments in other sports like football. There's a certain romance about the place and it was a real privilege to play there - we also had a pretty good track record there during my career [laughs]."
